- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses generative model attribution, which aims to identify the source model of a generated image. As the number of generative models continues to grow, collecting sufficient training data from every model becomes increasingly impractical. To address this challenge, the authors construct a proxy generative model using autoencoders with diverse architectures and initializations. Specifically, they use COCO images to generate outputs from these autoencoders and train a ResNet-based classifier to distinguish which autoencoder produced images. After training, they discard the classification head and reuse the encoder as a feature extractor. For attribution to actual generative models, they compute image embeddings and perform classification using model-specific prototype vectors. The key idea is to learn transferable model fingerprints from synthetic proxy models rather than directly training on a large collection of real generative models.
Critical strengths
The performance of the proposed paper, it achieved higher performance compared to FP
This paper proposed agent-driven training strategies in attribution field.
Critical weaknesses
-
The central idea highlighted in the abstract and the first contribution—training a fingerprint extractor solely on a bank of synthetic reconstruction models (288 architectures, 5,760 models) without real-generator images—appears to be the core contribution of Yang et al. (2025), which is used here only as the FP baseline and is not discussed in the related work or acknowledged in Sec. 3.2. The authors should explicitly attribute the model bank and the training paradigm to prior work, and reframe their contributions around what is actually new (the additional objectives, agent-guided scheduling, and bank expansion), supported by corresponding ablations.
-
Since the 26 sources are drawn from different benchmarks with likely differing resolutions, formats, and compression, and the method relies on residual FFT amplitudes, the reported separability may reflect dataset-level processing shortcuts rather than generator-specific fingerprints; cross-benchmark verification of the same model or evaluation under unified preprocessing is needed to rule this out.
Questions for authors
-
Explain the difference of FP, it seems that the core contribgution is entirely same as FP but this paper is neither explained in related work and not introduced in problem formulation. as FP uses autoencoders as scaleable proxy to determine its fingerprints, the authors should describe the difference
-
Explanations are poor, the authors should provide detailed setup
-
as stated earlier, the fingerprints can be learned through shortcuts, the reviewer strongly suggest the authors to experiments the analysis on fine-tuned model or post-processing. meaning, how does the fingerprints change if one fine-tunes its style of post-processes the image? Regarding the problem formulation, the fingerprints should remain fixed.