- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes an AI-generated image detection framework that first extracts neighborhood median residuals (NDR), then processes them through local wavelet and global Fourier branches, and performs classification using bidirectional adaptive fusion. Trained using ProGAN as the sole source of generated images, the model outperforms the compared methods on ForenSynths, AIGCDetectBenchmark, and WildRF.
Critical strengths
1.The framework combines local and global forensic cues, and the single-generator training setup is appropriate for evaluating cross-generator generalization. 2.The method achieves the best average results among the compared methods on three benchmarks, including the real-world social-media dataset WildRF.
Critical weaknesses
1.Limited conceptual novelty over NPR. NPR already exploits neighboring-pixel relationships for generated image detection, so the dependency-oriented perspective emphasized in this paper substantially overlaps with prior work. The clearer differences are the median-based residual operator and the subsequent dual-branch architecture. 2.The contribution of NDR itself is not sufficiently isolated. Removing NDR only demonstrates that residual preprocessing is useful. Without comparisons replacing NDR with NPR or standard filtering residuals under the same architecture, the specific advantage of the proposed representation remains unclear. 3.The robustness evidence remains limited. Accuracy on WildRF is 67.1%, only 1.2 percentage points above the runner-up. The stronger claims about robust real-world generalization therefore require additional support.
Questions for authors
1.With the downstream architecture and training setup fixed, how does NDR compare with NPR, standard median-filter residuals, and mean-filter residuals? 2.What evidence distinguishes the proposed “dependency irregularities” from the local residual artifacts exploited by NPR and related methods?
Response to Reviewer ZCX2
Thank you for your constructive feedback and for recognizing the complementary local/global design and the single-generator training protocol. We respond below. The additional experiments are included in the revised manuscript's appendix.
Q1. Controlled comparison with NPR and standard filtering residuals
We agree that removing NDR alone does not establish its advantage over alternative residual representations. We therefore fixed the downstream architecture and training settings and replaced only the front-end representation (Appendix C.1, Table 8). Entries below are mAcc./mAP (%).
NDR achieves the best mAcc and mAP on AIGCDetectBenchmark and WildRF. Compared with the standard median-filter residual, the gains are 6.1/1.8 and 2.9/3.5 percentage points, respectively, while performance remains close to the best on ForenSynths.
The key to NDR is highlighting dependencies between the center pixel and its neighbors. Unlike standard median filtering, we set the center pixel to zero before median aggregation, making the reconstruction independent of its original value and more dependent on surrounding pixels. The difference between the original pixel and this reconstruction explicitly measures its deviation from neighborhood context, highlighting potential synthesis-induced dependency irregularities. These explanations and comparisons are included in Appendix C.1.
Q2. Distinction from NPR and the meaning of “dependency irregularities”
NPR primarily targets local pixel correlations associated with upsampling operations, using differences within local grids relative to a reference pixel at a fixed sampling position. NDR instead constructs a contextual baseline through neighborhood median reconstruction. Here, “dependency irregularities” has a concrete representational meaning: deviations between original pixel values and their neighborhood-supported reconstruction baselines.
Building on NDR, we model these irregularities at complementary local and global scales. The local subband dependency branch (LSDB) captures directional texture inconsistencies and cross-subband associations through wavelet decomposition and local-window interactions. The global spectral dependency branch (GSDB) captures image-wide spectral correlations, periodic responses, and long-range contextual information through Fourier-domain modeling. Bidirectional confidence-guided fusion (BCGF) then mutually calibrates and adaptively integrates these features according to the input image.
The controlled comparison in Table 8 shows that NDR outperforms NPR in both mAcc and mAP on all three benchmarks under the same downstream architecture and training settings, supporting the benefit of neighborhood-context reconstruction.
Furthermore, with the same NDR input and without BCGF, LSDB alone achieves 86.1% mAcc on AIGCDetectBenchmark. Combining LSDB and GSDB raises mAcc to 87.2%, supporting the contribution of global spectral information. With the same dual-branch configuration, adding BCGF further increases mAcc to 92.2% and mAP from 93.2% to 96.9% (Table 6), supporting bidirectional calibration and adaptive fusion.
Our contribution therefore lies in a unified framework combining explicit neighborhood-context residuals, complementary local-subband and global-spectral modeling, and bidirectional adaptive integration. The controlled experiments support the contributions of the representation, complementary branches, and fusion module.
Additional concern: robustness and real-world generalization
On WildRF, our method achieves the highest mean accuracy among the compared methods, reaching 67.1% and exceeding the runner-up by 1.2 percentage points under the reported protocol.
To provide additional robustness evidence, we evaluated common post-processing operations on ForenSynths (Appendix F, Table 12):
The model retains at least 80.0% mAcc and over 90.0% mAP under all three conditions. JPEG compression reduces mAcc by only 2.5 percentage points, while Gaussian blur largely preserves accuracy. These experiments support the robustness of our method under the tested post-processing conditions and provide further evidence of its applicability to image dissemination scenarios.