- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SpCon for generated-image source verification under post-processing. It based on AEDR and applies a target VAE twice, represents adjacent residuals through log-energy ratios across RGB channels and radial frequency bands, and scores the resulting features using Student-t mixture densities. Three settings TO, ER, and KR reflect different levels of negative-reference availability. Evaluation covers seven generators, 35 synthetic conditions, and three social platforms.
Critical strengths
- The method is simple and well motivated. Preserving channel–frequency structure can retain source information discarded by a global reconstruction-error ratio, while requiring only two VAE reconstructions.
- The controlled experiments are substantial. AEDR-Mix matches reference access and density modeling, while additional controls examine single residuals, normalized residuals, and concatenated residual spectra. The gains therefore cannot be attributed solely to additional reference data or a more elaborate scoring backend.
- Reference-assisted variants achieve clear empirical improvements. ER/KR outperform the evaluated baselines under many single-operation conditions and the tested platform pipelines. The appendices also disclose informative failure cases involving shared VAEs, processing chains, and adversarial attacks.
Critical weaknesses
- Table 11 provides an important control: with matched references, fitting conditions, and density modeling, SpCon-ER achieves 0.9387/0.7825 AUROC/AP over all post-processing conditions, compared with 0.7444/0.4496 for AEDR-Mix-ER. The band-count ablation in Figure 5 further supports the value of spectral resolution. However, attribution metrics do not distinguish between smaller post-processing-induced feature changes and richer features that remain discriminative despite substantial changes. Figure 3 provides qualitative evidence through average response patterns, but a paired stability analysis across models and conditions is missing. Moreover, the common-factor cancellation identity in Appendix A is valid under its assumptions, but the extent to which actual transformations satisfy those assumptions is not quantified. The novelty should be framed accordingly. AEDR already uses double reconstruction and relative errors; the principal extension is spectral structure preservation and reference-density modeling.
- Appendix J already evaluates processing chains, but these findings deserve greater prominence. In Table 32, KR decreases from 0.9838/0.9208 AUROC/AP under individual medium-severity operations to 0.8633/0.5647 for two-operation chains and 0.6427/0.2286 for three-operation chains. Table 31 reports KR AUROC of 0.7677 for Resize→JPEG and 0.5365 for Rotation→Resize→JPEG. These transformations are directly relevant to the motivating dissemination scenario. Strong results on three platform pipelines do not establish generalization to repeated editing, resampling, and re-encoding. Representative chain results should appear in the main paper, with claims distinguishing individual operations, the tested platform pipelines, and sequential processing. Broader claims would benefit from evaluating composition-aware fitting on unseen operation combinations and orders.
- Section 3.1 defines membership with respect to a specific generator, whereas Section 5 and Appendix H primarily support VAE-family-level attribution. Table 29 reports approximately 0.50–0.55 AUROC when distinguishing SD3.5-Medium from Large using their shared VAE. The authors acknowledge this limitation, but the abstract, formal task definition, and application motivation should consistently reflect it. The seven-way evaluation establishes discrimination within the selected candidate set rather than general model-level identification. The paper should explicitly define its attribution classes and explain how generators sharing a VAE should be handled in the intended application.
Questions for authors
Please see the weaknesses。
7 comments
Re: Paired Stability, Common-Factor Cancellation, and Novelty (W1)-1/2
We thank you for recognizing the value of Table 11 and Figure 5. We agree that attribution metrics alone cannot distinguish the contributions of feature stability and discriminative power, and that the theoretical assumptions in Appendix A require further empirical validation. To address these concerns, we have added paired stability analyses across models and post-processing conditions, quantitative tests of the theoretical assumptions, and controlled representation-level experiments. We have also clarified SpCon's novelty relative to AEDR and revised the abstract and contributions accordingly.
(1) Stability or discriminability: Primarily richer discriminative features. We measured paired feature changes before and after post-processing, normalized by each representation's own between-class separation on clean images, and separately evaluated discriminative performance using only clean images for reference fitting.
| Scope | Representation | Normalized Drift (Belonging / Non-belonging) | Clean-Only Fitting (AUROC / AP) |
|---|---|---|---|
| All post-proc. | First-residual spectrum | 1.4899 / 1.1796 | 0.8082 / 0.4764 |
| All post-proc. | Global ratio (AEDR-style) | 0.6286 / 0.2406 | 0.7668 / 0.4704 |
| All post-proc. | SpCon full spectrum | 1.1088 / 0.8477 | 0.8506 / 0.6270 |
| Platforms | First-residual spectrum | 1.3679 / 0.9676 | 0.8162 / 0.4078 |
| Platforms | Global ratio (AEDR-style) | 0.6543 / 0.1018 | 0.7800 / 0.4792 |
| Platforms | SpCon full spectrum | 1.0414 / 0.7241 | 0.9217 / 0.6850 |
Results show SpCon's advantage does not arise solely from smaller feature drift. Although SpCon exhibits larger normalized drift than the global ratio, it achieves higher average AUROC/AP with clean-only reference fitting (higher AUROC on 5 of 7 targets and higher AP on 6 of 7), indicating the preserved channel–frequency structure provides richer discriminative information. Compared with the first-residual spectrum, SpCon drifts less for belonging images in 14 of 15 conditions, consistent with partial cancellation by the relative response.
(2) Quantitative validation of the assumptions in Appendix A. We further quantified the extent to which the common-factor assumption holds. Let and denote the changes in channel–frequency log energies of the two residuals. We define the cancellation coefficient as:
Here, indicates perfect common-factor cancellation, while lower values indicate greater deviations from the assumption. The results show that the assumption holds approximately for sharpening, blurring, contrast adjustment, resizing, brightness adjustment, and noise (–), moderately for cropping, rotation, and Telegram (–), and less closely for saturation, WebP, JPEG, WeChat, flipping, and Facebook (). Importantly, the band-wise cancellation coefficient exceeds its global () counterpart for 11 of 12 operation types, all three platforms, and six of seven targets, demonstrating the advantage of band-wise comparison over global aggregation. Where is low, robustness is not explained by cancellation alone: reference densities directly model the remaining differential components for fitted conditions (e.g., JPEG), while their mixture supports generalization to unfitted conditions. These findings demonstrate that SpCon's robustness benefits from both band-wise cancellation and reference-density modeling, rather than relying on the cancellation assumption alone. We have added these quantitative results to Appendix A and clarified the theoretical scope of the cancellation identity.
Re: Paired Stability, Common-Factor Cancellation, and Novelty (W1)-2/2
(3) Novelty clarification. We agree with your characterization of SpCon's contribution. SpCon builds upon AEDR's double-reconstruction and relative-error framework, while related double-reconstruction or second-order-difference designs also appear in [1–4]. We do not claim this underlying strategy as our contribution. Contribution 2 (Section 1) and Section 2 now explicitly state two extensions: (i) preserving the 48-dimensional channel–frequency structure of relative changes between consecutive reconstruction residuals, rather than collapsing them into a global scalar; and (ii) reference-density modeling. We have also replaced "identify a phenomenon" with "characterize." These extensions are not merely a domain transformation. By Parseval's theorem, transforming to the frequency domain and then aggregating global energy is mathematically equivalent to the spatial-domain global ratio (Appendix A). Thus, the improvement cannot be attributed to the domain transformation alone, but to the preserved structure. To further demonstrate the distinction from AEDR, we added controlled representation-level experiments using identical references, fitting conditions, and density-modeling backends, varying only the input representation.
[1] SWIFT: Sliding Window Reconstruction for Few-Shot Training-Free Generated Video Attribution, CVPR 2026.
[2] Data Provenance for Image Auto-Regressive Generation, ICLR 2026.
[3] MGI: Member vs Generated Inference, ECCV 2026.
[4] A Difference-in-Difference Approach to Detecting AI-Generated Images, CVPR 2026.
Controlled representation-level results (AUROC / AP):
| Representation | Dimension | TO | ER | KR |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Global Ratio | 1 | 0.6999 / 0.3239 | 0.7447 / 0.4372 | 0.7498 / 0.4502 |
| AEDR-Mix | 1 | 0.7495 / 0.4236 | 0.7444 / 0.4496 | 0.7579 / 0.4724 |
| Mean of 48 Band Responses | 1 | 0.5370 / 0.1950 | 0.7315 / 0.4230 | 0.7527 / 0.4408 |
| RGB Channel Means | 3 | 0.6161 / 0.2573 | 0.7850 / 0.4727 | 0.7995 / 0.4893 |
| SpCon | 48 | 0.8756 / 0.6251 | 0.9387 / 0.7825 | 0.9642 / 0.8586 |
Global Ratio uses with summed RGB energies and is equivalent to by Parseval's theorem, without the GLCM term. Mean of 48 Band Responses averages the 48-dimensional response vector , while RGB Channel Means averages the 16 band responses within each RGB channel. Under identical backends, Global Ratio, AEDR-Mix, Mean of 48 Band Responses, and RGB Channel Means achieve only 0.73–0.80 AUROC under ER/KR, whereas the full 48-dimensional SpCon representation reaches 0.9387/0.9642. This demonstrates that the gains arise from preserving channel–frequency structure rather than the domain transformation itself. Moreover, references alone do not close the gap: with identical references and backend, no low-dimensional summary exceeds 0.80 AUROC under KR, whereas the 48-dimensional response reaches 0.9642.
Manuscript revisions: Appendix A now includes Empirical Check of the Common-Factor Assumption, with the definition of and per-condition results (Table R2), and Paired Stability versus Discriminability, reporting paired drift and clean-only discriminative performance across conditions and targets (Tables R2–R3). Appendix I adds the controlled representation comparisons (Table R8). We have reframed the novelty as spectral structure preservation and reference-density modeling in Section 1 (including the replacement of "identify" with "characterize" and the revision of Contribution 2) and Section 2. The abstract, introduction, and opening of Appendix A no longer claim inherently greater feature stability, instead emphasizing richer and more robust discriminative cues. Appendix A also reports the clean-only results for the first-residual spectrum.
Overall Response to Reviewer ZXx1
We sincerely thank you for recognizing the simplicity and theoretical motivation of our method (S1), the substantial controlled experiments (S2), and the clear empirical improvements (S3). We also appreciate your detailed and valuable feedback. In response, we have added paired stability analyses, quantitatively examined the common-factor assumption, and further clarified our novelty (W1); moved sequential-processing results into the main paper and added composition-aware fitting experiments (W2); and unified the attribution-class definition while clarifying how shared-VAE models are handled (W3). The manuscript has been revised accordingly, with changes highlighted in blue. Each response identifies the corresponding manuscript revisions. Our detailed responses follow.