- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Spectral Geometry Signatures (SGS) for attributing generated images to their source diffusion models. SGS probes candidate denoisers with frequency-controlled perturbations and measures their cross-frequency responses, without model inversion or modification. Experiments cover diffusion and flow-matching models, achieving 99.99% and 99.98% accuracy in 15-model and 19-model closed-set settings, respectively. The authors also evaluate robustness to prompt shifts, image distortions, and different VAEs.
Major Comment
This paper presents an interesting approach and reports impressive results across several settings. However, I have two main concerns: whether the near-perfect accuracy reflects genuine image-source attribution rather than candidate-model identification, and whether the limited baseline comparisons sufficiently establish the method's advantage over recent work.
These issues are important for assessing the paper's central claims. I lean toward rejection, but would reconsider if the authors provide convincing cross-model attribution analysis and stronger comparisons.
Critical strengths
1. Interesting approach to model attribution. Instead of relying on image artifacts or reconstruction errors, SGS uses the spectral responses of denoising networks. This offers a different perspective on model attribution, particularly for closely related models such as SD v1.4 and SD v1.5.
2. Strong experimental results. SGS achieves near-perfect closed-set attribution accuracy across different model architectures and fine-tuned variants. The experiments also cover flow-matching models, prompt distribution shifts, image distortions, and VAE variations.
Critical weaknesses
1. Model fingerprints are not clearly distinguished from image source attribution.
SGS extracts features by directly querying each candidate denoiser, which may naturally reveal the model's identity. However, distinguishing denoising networks does not necessarily establish which network generated a given image.
This concern is amplified by the large gap between the training-free Argmin method (78.33% on 8 models and 65.56% on 15 models) and LinearSVC (approximately 99.98% and 99.99%, respectively). The paper does not sufficiently explain what the supervised classifier learns or how much of its performance comes from image-source matching rather than candidate-model identity.
A cross-model analysis, where images from different sources are evaluated using the same candidate denoisers, would help clarify this issue.
2. Insufficient comparison with recent attribution methods.
The main comparison includes only RONAN and LatentTracer, both based on inversion or reconstruction-related signals. This is insufficient to establish the advantage of SGS over other attribution approaches.
Relevant studies include Detecting Origin Attribution for Text-to-Image Diffusion Models, Who Made This? (FRIDA), and Tracing the Roots. Although these methods have different assumptions, comparisons under matched settings, where applicable, would better establish the contribution of SGS.
Questions for authors
Q1. Can the authors provide a cross-model attribution score matrix, showing how each candidate denoiser responds to images generated by different source models? Including unrelated or real images as controls would help verify that SGS captures image-source information rather than only model identity.
Q2. Why does LinearSVC outperform Argmin by such a large margin? Can the authors clarify what information the classifier learns and whether its predictions depend on the true image source?
Q3. The full SGS configuration requires 1,200 denoiser forward passes per candidate model. Can the authors report inference time and computational cost against existing methods? Also, since a single timestep already achieves 99.97% accuracy on 15 models, what practical benefit justifies the full five-timestep configuration?