acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Necessary and Sufficient Conditions for Autoencoder-based Style Transfer

Abstract

While style transfer and controllable generation have achieved strong empirical performance across audio, vision, and multimodal learning, most existing methods remain largely heuristic and offer limited theoretical guarantees. This paper studies autoencoder-based attribute transformation from a theoretical perspective and characterizes when exact conversion is achievable. We introduce a formal framework that isolates a task-relevant factor from a controllable attribute and ask when a learned encoder–decoder pair can implement the desired transformation while preserving all non-target information. Our main contributions are theoretical: under minimal and interpretable assumptions on the data-generating process, we establish both sufficient and necessary conditions for exact attribute conversion. We further move beyond idealized settings by deriving explicit error bounds that quantify how imperfect reconstruction and residual dependence in the learned representation translate into transfer degradation. Overall, our analysis shifts the focus from latent recovery to synthesis-oriented guarantees, providing a principled foundation for understanding when reliable task-driven style transfer is possible.

Primary area:
learning theory
Keywords:
style transfer, controllable generation, autoencoders, theoretical guarantees, exact conversion, error bounds

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_kLjrOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies attribute conversion under an injective generative model, with independent content and attribute variables. For discrete content distributions without nontrivial measure-preserving permutations, it proves that perfect reconstruction and latent–attribute independence imply exact conversion. It establishes necessity through an equivalent representation and, under entropy minimality, for the original encoder. Additional results bound conversion error using reconstruction error, paired latent invariance, and decoder Lipschitz continuity. Experiments examine speech-cluster frequencies and a controlled synthetic conversion task.

Critical strengths

S1: The distinction between necessity for an equivalent realization and necessity for the actual encoder is useful and explicitly qualified. S2: Lemma 2 provides a valid, interpretable bound under Assumptions 4–6. Appendix H appropriately distinguishes a certified architectural Lipschitz bound from an empirical local estimate. Table 1’s calculations are consistent with the reported inputs. S3: Appendix G usefully distinguishes matched-noise conversion error from error against an independently generated target.

Critical weaknesses

W1: The novelty framing understates prior synthesis work. Sections 1 and 8 contrast the paper’s synthesis focus with Shaham et al. (2022), but that paper already formulates the same conditional synthesis task and uses reconstruction plus independence training. AutoVC also provides bottleneck-based style-transfer theory. The present contribution should therefore be positioned around its explicit symmetry restriction, pointwise correctness result, and qualified necessity statements. A theorem-level comparison would clarify the significance without implying these earlier results subsume the new theorem.

W2: The experiments support narrower conclusions than suggested. Appendix E’s unequal empirical cluster frequencies concern a WavLM-derived proxy on one corpus; they do not establish distinct population probabilities for the true content variable or quantify separation from symmetry. Appendix H directly trains paired invariance, so it illustrates Lemma 2 rather than validating Eq. (4)’s independence-based route. Its continuous uniform content distribution also does not satisfy Assumption 2, although that assumption is unnecessary for Lemma 2. The exact generator, architecture, sample counts, training settings, and run variability are not reported sufficiently to reproduce Table 1. Narrowing the empirical claims and supplying those settings would address the reporting concern; a controlled independence-only experiment varying probability separation would directly investigate the central stability gap.

Questions for authors

Q1: Will Proposition 3 be restricted to finite content entropy, and will the continuous-extension claim be proved or removed? Q2: What precise theorem-level advance distinguishes the results from Shaham et al. and AutoVC beyond the synthesis framing?

3 comments

We thank the reviewer for the detailed review and address the raised concerns below.

W1: Positioning relative to Shaham et al. (2022) and AutoVC (also Q2)

We thank the reviewer for highlighting the importance of distinguishing our contributions from prior synthesis-oriented work. We revised the relevant sentence in Section 1 to clarify that our contribution shifts the theoretical focus from analysis to synthesis, rather than introducing synthesis as a new application. We also revised the "Non-probabilistic Autoencoders" paragraph in Section 8 to explicitly acknowledge and compare the synthesis contributions and theoretical guarantees of Shaham et al. (2022) and AutoVC. While Shaham et al. (2022) provide theoretical guarantees for latent variable recovery up to an entropy-preserving transformation, alongside a methodology for conditional synthesis, our work extends the theoretical characterization to pointwise conversion correctness. Specifically, we show that perfect reconstruction and independence, together with a distributional asymmetry assumption that eliminates nontrivial measure-preserving transformations, are sufficient to guarantee exact conversion (Proposition 1). Unlike AutoVC, which provides asymptotic distribution-level conversion guarantees under speech-specific assumptions and bottleneck constraints, our framework establishes pointwise exact conversion guarantees under explicit structural conditions, without requiring an asymptotic utterance-length regime. We further establish qualified necessity results: Proposition 2 shows that every exact converter admits an equivalent representation satisfying reconstruction and independence, while Proposition 3 establishes necessity for the original encoder under an additional minimality condition. Beyond exact conversion, Lemma 2 provides an explicit non-asymptotic conversion error bound under bounded reconstruction error, sample-wise latent invariance, and decoder Lipschitz continuity.

Together, these results distinguish our theoretical contribution from prior synthesis methodologies by identifying conditions for pointwise correctness, characterizing the necessity of these properties, and quantifying the stability of approximate conversion under explicit assumptions. We hope these clarifications better position our contribution relative to the existing literature.

W2: Interpretation and reproducibility of the experiments

Appendix E. The purpose of Appendix E is to provide an example of distributional asymmetry in speech-related content representations derived from the real-world speech data. We extract WavLM embeddings from LibriSpeech-clean-100 and cluster them into K=100K=100 categories to construct the discrete speech-content units by capturing recurring phonetic patterns. These units serve as a proxy for the unobserved variable SS. Their empirical frequencies are consistent with the asymmetric prior in Example 1. The analysis illustrates the plausibility of asymmetric content distributions in real speech data, not as a statistical verification of Assumption 2.

Regarding Appendix H, we consider a controlled synthetic setting with paired examples to investigate the informativeness and tightness of the conversion-error bound in Lemma 2. The experiment is not intended to validate the independence-based objective, but rather to demonstrate how deviations from ideal reconstruction and latent invariance affect conversion accuracy. Please note that, following the suggestion of Reviewer 2mdc, we added an additional synthetic experiment that satisfies Assumption 2 of our theoretical framework. In addition, we have introduced a new experiment on the Colored-MNIST dataset using an HSIC-based independence objective, providing further empirical evidence of the applicability of our theoretical analysis. In addition, we narrow the empirical claims to accurately reflect the scope of our experiments. Finally, we will release all code we used for these experiments including hyperparameters to improve reproducibility.

Q1: Finite-entropy scope of Proposition 3 and the continuous-extension sentence

We thank the reviewer for raising this point. To maintain simplicity and clarity of presentation, we retain the restriction of Proposition 3 to discrete random variables with finite entropy and remove the statement regarding its extension to continuous variables. Developing a rigorous continuous counterpart is nontrivial and requires additional theoretical analysis beyond the scope of the present work.

Thank you once more for the constructive and careful feedback. We welcome any further questions and would be glad to engage in additional discussion.

Reviewer_kLjrOpenReview ↗

Thanks for the discussion

I appreciate the thorough discussion you further provided. I will consider changing the score accordingly.

Dear Reviewer, we sincerely appreciate your reconsideration and your decision to raise the score. Thank you for your careful evaluation and constructive discussion.

Reviewer_UaDFOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies when an autoencoder can change the style of an input while preserving its content. It gives conditions for correct conversion and studies how errors affect the result.

Critical strengths
  1. The question is interesting and relevant. Understanding when reconstruction and independence from style are enough to preserve the content during conversion could be useful, and the paper does show results on real data.

  2. The paper also considers imperfect models. The error bound shows how reconstruction errors, differences between the latents of the same content, and the decoder’s sensitivity to those differences affect the output.

Critical weaknesses

I would appreciate clarification on how well Assumption 2 describes realistic data. Appendix E supports the assumption by showing different empirical frequencies for 100 speech clusters. However, could some of these differences simply come from the particular samples used? I am also not sure how showing this for the clusters tells us that the assumption holds for the underlying content. Could the authors clarify this connection?

Questions for authors

I think the results could be useful, although I would like a clearer explanation of how the asymmetry assumption applies to real data.

1 comment

We appreciate the reviewer's encouraging assessment of the research question and the approximate-conversion analysis. Please see the detailed response below.

W1: Whether empirical speech-cluster frequencies support Assumption 2

The purpose of Appendix E is to provide an example of distributional asymmetry in a discrete, speech-derived representation. Specifically, we extract WavLM embeddings from LibriSpeech-clean-100 and cluster them into K=100K=100 categories. Since WavLM representations encode phonetic and speaker-specific information, these clusters can serve as approximate speech-content units, where different categories capture recurring language phonetic patterns. Their relative frequencies construct the distribution of discrete speech content. The observed unequal empirical frequencies are consistent with the asymmetric prior considered in Example 1.

We agree that empirical frequencies do not necessarily reflect exact population probabilities, as small differences may arise from finite-sample fluctuations. To further support our observations, we add a histogram reporting the actual sample counts for each of the 100 speech-unit categories, providing a clearer view of their frequencies and the statistical reliability of the observed differences (please see in Appendix E). While these results provide empirical evidence of asymmetry in the learned speech-content representation, we acknowledge that the clustered variable S~\tilde S is a proxy for the underlying content variable SS, rather than a direct identification of its distribution. Thus, our analysis is intended to illustrate the plausibility of asymmetric content distributions in realistic speech data, rather than formally establish Assumption 2 for the unobserved generative factors.

We are grateful for this useful suggestion and for the constructive review. We would be happy to discuss further.

Reviewer_2mdcOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4(+1)
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates the theoretical conditions under which conditional autoencoders can perform exact attribute conversion while preserving task-relevant content. The authors consider a generative model X=f(S,C)X=f(S,C), where SS denotes latent content and CC represents an observed, controllable attribute. Building on existing reconstruction- and independence-based approaches, the paper introduces an additional distributional asymmetry assumption on SS and establishes that perfect reconstruction and statistical independence between the learned representation and CC are sufficient to guarantee exact conversion. In particular, the analysis shows that these conditions yield a single, attribute-invariant, invertible reparameterization of the content variable.

The paper further investigates necessary conditions for exact conversion. It shows that any exact conversion function admits an equivalent encoder-decoder representation satisfying reconstruction and independence, and argues that these properties are also necessary for the original model under an additional minimum-entropy information bottleneck assumption.

Beyond the idealized setting, the authors derive conversion error bounds based on reconstruction accuracy, sample-wise latent invariance, and decoder Lipschitz continuity, with an extension to stochastic generation. The paper also discusses reconstruction- and dependence-based training objectives. For empirical validation, it analyzes clustered speech-unit frequency distributions using WavLM and LibriSpeech to examine distributional asymmetry and presents synthetic experiments in Appendix H to numerically investigate the approximate conversion error bound and the effect of Lipschitz regularization.

Overall, the paper extends prior latent-representation analysis by formally characterizing exact attribute conversion and its approximation error, with its primary contributions being theoretical rather than a new architecture or demonstrated empirical improvement in real-world style transfer performance.

Critical strengths

1. A meaningful theoretical refinement of existing latent-representation guarantees.

The paper provides a rigorous sufficient condition for exact attribute conversion by introducing a distributional asymmetry assumption on the latent content variable. This assumption addresses an important ambiguity in reconstruction- and independence-based representation learning: statistical independence from the controllable attribute does not, by itself, guarantee that the learned representations consistently preserve the same content across different attributes. By establishing the existence of an attribute-invariant, invertible reparameterization of the content variable, Proposition 1 connects representation-level properties to exact conversion correctness. I consider this the paper's strongest theoretical contribution, as it clarifies the additional conditions required for reliable attribute conversion.

2. A broader theoretical analysis of exact and approximate attribute conversion.

The paper goes beyond establishing sufficiency by investigating the structural properties of exact conversion and deriving explicit conversion error bounds. In particular, Proposition 2 characterizes exact conversion through the existence of an equivalent representation satisfying reconstruction and independence, while Lemma 2 relates conversion error to reconstruction accuracy, sample-wise latent invariance, and decoder Lipschitz continuity. The synthetic experiments in Appendix H also provide numerical illustrations of the approximate error bound. Although these results rely on additional assumptions, they offer a structured theoretical perspective on the factors governing conversion correctness and the consequences of deviations from ideal conditions. This analysis is potentially useful for understanding the behavior and limitations of conditional autoencoder-based systems.

Critical weaknesses

1. Limited practical significance and a gap between the theoretical guarantees and the proposed learning objective.

Although the paper provides a meaningful theoretical refinement of prior latent-representation results, the broader significance and applicability of its guarantees remain insufficiently established. The sufficient condition relies on an injective generative model and a distributional asymmetry assumption that excludes nontrivial measure-preserving transformations of the latent content variable.

In fact, Assumption 2 cannot hold for any distribution of the content variable with a non-atomic component, since such distributions admit nontrivial measure-preserving transformations. Consequently, Proposition 1 effectively applies only to purely atomic distributions with pairwise distinct atom masses, substantially limiting its applicability to continuous latent factors commonly encountered in realistic style transfer. Although footnote 1 discusses extending entropy-based analysis to continuous variables, this does not resolve the incompatibility between Assumption 2 and non-atomic distributions.

Notably, the synthetic study in Appendix H uses S∼Unif([−1,1]2)S \sim \mathrm{Unif}([-1,1]^2), for which the reflection s↦−ss \mapsto -s violates Assumption 2. While this is not a formal contradiction because Appendix H evaluates Lemma 2 rather than Proposition 1, it illustrates that even the authors' own synthetic setting falls outside the scope of the exact-conversion sufficient condition. Similarly, the empirical analysis in Appendix E examines the frequency distribution of clustered speech representations but does not directly validate Assumption 2 for the underlying content variable or demonstrate its relevance to actual conversion performance.

More importantly, there is a gap between the proposed independence-based learning objective and the approximate conversion guarantee. Property 2 requires statistical independence between the learned representation and the controllable attribute, whereas Lemma 2 relies on Assumption 6, which imposes a stronger, sample-wise invariance bound across different attributes for the same content. Small statistical dependence does not necessarily imply small sample-wise representation differences.

This distinction can be demonstrated even when Assumption 2 holds. Consider independent binary variables and an injective generator with encoder

S∼Bernoulli(1/2+δ),C∼Bernoulli(1/2),0<∣δ∣<1/2,S \sim \mathrm{Bernoulli}(1/2+\delta), \qquad C \sim \mathrm{Bernoulli}(1/2), \qquad 0 < |\delta| < 1/2,

f(s,c)=(s,c),e(f(s,c))=s⊕c.f(s,c)=(s,c), \qquad e(f(s,c))=s\oplus c.

The decoder d(z,c)=(z⊕c,c)d(z,c)=(z\oplus c,c) reconstructs the input perfectly, and since the two values of the content variable have distinct probabilities, Assumption 2 holds. As the distribution of the content variable approaches uniformity, the statistical dependence between the learned representation and the attribute vanishes,

I(e(X);C)→0as δ→0,I(e(X);C)\rightarrow 0 \qquad \text{as } \delta\rightarrow 0,

yet the sample-wise representation difference remains

\left\\|e(f(s,0))-e(f(s,1))\right\\|=1.

Therefore, arbitrarily small dependence does not imply a correspondingly small sample-wise invariance error, even within the class of distributions satisfying Assumption 2. Lemma 1 establishes exact invariance under exact independence and Assumption 2, but the paper does not provide a quantitative counterpart connecting approximate independence to the invariance error required by Lemma 2.

In particular, the paper does not establish how minimizing the dependence loss in Section 7 controls the invariance error appearing in the approximate conversion bound. The numerical study in Appendix H does not directly address this gap because it optimizes a paired invariance objective,

\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{inv}}=\mathbb{E}_{S,C,C'}\left[\left\\|e(f(S,C))-e(f(S,C'))\right\\|_2^2\right],

which requires access to different attribute realizations of the same underlying content. Such counterfactual pairs are generally unavailable in unpaired real-world style transfer settings, so this objective differs fundamentally from the dependence-based objective discussed in Section 7. Consequently, it remains unclear how the theoretical results translate into actionable guidance for training more reliable style transfer models.

This limitation is particularly consequential because reconstruction and independence objectives are already well-established in prior work, including Shaham et al. (2022), which also considers synthesis applications. Although the present paper provides additional theoretical results, it does not sufficiently demonstrate what new understanding or practical design principles follow from its characterization beyond the existing framework.

2. A potential inconsistency in the minimality assumption underlying the necessity result.

The necessity result for the original encoder-decoder model (Proposition 3) appears to contain an important inconsistency between the formal definition of Assumption 3 and its proof.

As written in Section 5.3.2, Assumption 3 defines a minimum-entropy representation subject to exact reconstruction for all combinations of inputs and attributes, rather than only for input-attribute pairs belonging to the joint data support. Under this literal formulation, every feasible encoder must be injective on the support of the input distribution, since

d~(e~(x),c)=x∀x,c\tilde d(\tilde e(x),c)=x \qquad \forall x,c

must hold for every attribute value.

For example, consider independent discrete content and attribute variables with at least two possible attribute values and distinct content probability masses, and let

f(s,c)=(s,c),e(x)=x,d((s,c),c′)=(s,c′).f(s,c)=(s,c), \qquad e(x)=x, \qquad d((s,c),c')=(s,c').

The generator is injective, and this encoder-decoder model achieves exact attribute conversion. Moreover, the identity encoder satisfies the minimum-entropy requirement under the stated all-pairs reconstruction constraint: since any feasible encoder must be injective on the input support, every feasible discrete representation has entropy H(e~(X))=H(X)H(\tilde e(X))=H(X). Nevertheless, the learned representation explicitly contains the controllable attribute and is therefore not independent of it, contradicting the conclusion of Proposition 3.

Appendix C implicitly uses a different reconstruction constraint. Specifically, the candidate representation S~=S\tilde S=S with decoder d~=f\tilde d=f is not feasible under Assumption 3 as written, because f(s,c′)≠f(s,c)f(s,c')\neq f(s,c) for c′≠cc'\neq c by Assumption 1. Restricting the reconstruction constraint to input-attribute pairs belonging to the joint data support, namely pairs satisfying x=f(s,c)x=f(s,c), would make this candidate feasible. Under this interpretation, the remainder of the argument appears to go through, suggesting that the issue may be a fixable formalization error rather than a fundamental impossibility.

The authors should clarify and correct the precise feasible set in Assumption 3 and verify that Proposition 3 and Theorem 1 remain valid under the corrected definition. Since the necessity result is a central component of the paper's claimed necessary-and-sufficient characterization, this ambiguity directly affects the soundness of one of its principal theoretical contributions as currently stated.

Questions for authors

Q1. Validity of the minimality assumption and necessity result

In Section 5.3.2, Assumption 3 defines the minimum-entropy encoder subject to the reconstruction constraint

d~(e~(x),c)=x∀x,c.\tilde d(\tilde e(x),c)=x \qquad \forall x,c.

As written, this appears to require exact reconstruction under every possible conditioning value, rather than only under the original condition associated with each observation. Under this literal interpretation, every feasible encoder must be injective on the input support, and all feasible discrete representations have the same entropy as the input.

Consider independent discrete content and attribute variables, where the content variable has distinct atom masses and the attribute has at least two possible values. Let

f(s,c)=(s,c),e(x)=x,d((s,c),c′)=(s,c′).f(s,c)=(s,c), \qquad e(x)=x, \qquad d((s,c),c')=(s,c').

This model achieves exact attribute conversion, and the identity encoder satisfies the minimum-entropy requirement under the stated all-pairs reconstruction constraint. Nevertheless, the learned representation explicitly contains the controllable attribute and is therefore not independent of it, contradicting Proposition 3. The construction also satisfies Assumptions 1 and 2.

Appendix C appears to use a different reconstruction constraint, under which the candidate representation and decoder based on the original content variable are feasible only for correctly paired input-attribute samples.

Could the authors clarify the intended quantification in Assumption 3? Should reconstruction be required only for pairs belonging to the joint data support? If so, could the authors provide a corrected formal statement and verify that Proposition 3 and the corresponding necessity claim in Theorem 1 remain valid?

This clarification is important because the necessity result is a central component of the paper's claimed theoretical characterization.

Q2. Relationship between statistical independence and the approximate conversion guarantee

The paper motivates reconstruction- and independence-based learning through Property 2 and the objective in Section 7. However, Lemma 2 relies on Assumption 6, which requires a uniform, sample-wise invariance bound across different attributes for the same content.

These conditions are not equivalent. In particular, arbitrarily small statistical dependence does not necessarily imply small sample-wise representation differences, even when Assumption 2 holds.

For example, consider independent binary variables

S∼Bernoulli(1/2+δ),C∼Bernoulli(1/2),0<∣δ∣<1/2,S\sim\mathrm{Bernoulli}(1/2+\delta), \qquad C\sim\mathrm{Bernoulli}(1/2), \qquad 0<|\delta|<1/2,

with the injective generator and encoder

f(s,c)=(s,c),e(f(s,c))=s⊕c.f(s,c)=(s,c), \qquad e(f(s,c))=s\oplus c.

The corresponding inverse decoder achieves perfect reconstruction. For nonzero delta, Assumption 2 holds because the content values have distinct probabilities. As delta approaches zero, the statistical dependence between the learned representation and the attribute approaches zero, while the sample-wise representation difference remains one.

Could the authors establish additional conditions under which minimizing the dependence objective in Section 7 controls the invariance error required by Assumption 6? For example, would a quantitative lower bound on the asymmetry of the content distribution be necessary?

Furthermore, Appendix H directly optimizes a paired invariance loss using different attribute realizations of the same underlying content, rather than the dependence-based objective in Section 7. Such counterfactual pairs are generally unavailable in unpaired real-world style transfer settings.

Could the authors clarify how the numerical validation in Appendix H supports the proposed practical learning objective?

Alternatively, if no direct connection is established, could the authors clarify that Lemma 2 provides a conditional stability guarantee under a separate, stronger invariance assumption, rather than a guarantee resulting from minimizing the independence-based objective?

Q3. Applicability of the distributional asymmetry assumption

Assumption 2 excludes all nontrivial measure-preserving automorphisms of the latent content distribution. This assumption plays an essential role in Lemma 1 and Proposition 1 by ensuring consistent alignment of learned representations across different attribute conditions.

However, non-atomic continuous distributions admit nontrivial measure-preserving transformations. Consequently, Assumption 2, as currently formulated, cannot hold for such distributions, substantially restricting the applicability of the sufficient condition to continuous content representations commonly used in practical style transfer systems.

Could the authors clarify the intended scope of Assumption 2? In particular, is Proposition 1 intended to apply primarily to discrete latent variables, or is there an alternative formulation that would permit meaningful sufficient conditions for continuous content representations?

Although footnote 1 discusses extending entropy-based analysis to continuous variables, this does not appear to resolve the restriction imposed by Assumption 2.

Additionally, Appendix H employs a continuous content distribution. While this experiment evaluates Lemma 2 rather than Proposition 1 and is therefore not formally inconsistent with the theory, it illustrates that even the authors' own synthetic setting falls outside the scope of the exact-conversion sufficient condition.

Appendix E also reports distinct empirical frequencies of WavLM-based speech-unit clusters. However, these clusters are proxies for the unobserved content variable rather than direct observations of the underlying generative factors.

Could the authors explain to what extent these empirical observations support Assumption 2, and identify realistic settings in which the assumption is expected to hold?

A clearer characterization of the applicable distributions would materially strengthen the generality and significance of Proposition 1.

Q4. Distinct scientific contribution beyond prior latent-representation theory

The paper emphasizes a shift from latent recovery to synthesis-oriented guarantees. However, Shaham et al. (2022) already investigate reconstruction- and independence-based representation learning and demonstrate synthesis applications, including image synthesis and voice cloning.

I recognize that the present paper provides additional theoretical results, particularly the distributional asymmetry-based sufficient condition, necessity characterizations, and approximate conversion error bounds.

Nevertheless, the distinct scientific insights enabled by these results could be articulated more clearly.

Could the authors explain precisely which limitations or ambiguities in the theoretical guarantees of Shaham et al. (2022) are resolved by Proposition 1? In particular, does Assumption 2 eliminate an identifiability ambiguity that remains unresolved under the previous assumptions, and can the authors provide a concrete comparison illustrating this distinction?

Furthermore, what new conclusions about conditional autoencoders become possible through the necessity results and approximate conversion bounds that could not be obtained from the existing reconstruction- and independence-based framework?

Finally, could the authors identify concrete settings in which the proposed characterization would lead to different model design choices, training objectives, or evaluation procedures?

The paper need not introduce a new architecture or demonstrate state-of-the-art empirical performance to make a meaningful theoretical contribution. However, a clearer explanation of what the new characterization enables researchers to understand or do differently would substantially strengthen its significance.

9 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Part 1

We thank the reviewer for the careful and technically detailed assessment, for recognizing the soundness and interpretability of our theoretical results, and for highlighting the useful distinction between exact and approximate conversion. We thank the reviewer for identifying the quantifier error in Assumption 3, and for the suggestion in Q2, which led to a new result (Appendix J). We addressed the corresponding weakness below.

W1: Broader significance and applicability, Assumption 2 cannot hold for any distribution... As stated in the formulation of Section 3, the content variable is indeed discrete and Proposition 1 treats exact-conversion guarantee for asymmetric discrete content distributions, rather than as a general theorem for arbitrary continuous content.

Nevertheless, Assumption 2 is relevant to several practical settings in which the underlying content variable SS can naturally be modeled as discrete. For example, in text style transfer, SS may represent the semantic content of a sentence or a sequence of linguistic tokens; in speech and voice conversion, SS may correspond to the underlying sequence of phonemes or words, independently of speaker identity; and in image style transfer, SS may describe discrete semantic factors, such as object identities or scene configurations. Moreover, continuous content variables can be approximated by discrete variables through quantization, providing a possible framework for extending the analysis to approximate conversion, although such discretization does not directly establish the exact guarantee for the original continuous distribution.

W2: Example in Appendix H. We thank the reviewer for highlighting the discrepancy between the synthetic experimental setup and the assumptions of our theoretical framework. To address this concern, we added to the Appendix H.3 a new example that satisfies Assumption 2. We refer the reviewer to the revised Appendix H for details.

W3: Interpretation of Appendix E. First we agree the existing text in Appendix E overstates what this evidence establishes and we corrected that wording. Second, we would like to clarify how we empirically examine Assumption 2 using a real-world speech dataset. Since the underlying content variable SS is unobserved and its precise definition is challenging, we adopt a more flexible interpretation of content as the task-relevant information that should be preserved during conversion. Accordingly, we approximate SS using a discrete proxy S~\tilde{S}, constructed by applying K-means clustering (K=100)(K=100) to continuous speech representations extracted using a pretrained WavLM model on LibriSpeech-clean-100. These clusters approximate phonetic content units and provide a meaningful discrete representation of speech content. We estimate the probability of each content state from its empirical frequency and observe that all estimated probabilities are pairwise distinct, consistent with Assumption 2 for S~\tilde{S}. This demonstrates that distributional asymmetry is plausible for meaningful, task-relevant definitions of content in real-world speech.

W4: Relevance to actual conversion performance. We emphasize that our work is primarily theoretical, aiming to establish necessary and sufficient conditions for exact conversion and characterize conversion errors. The empirical analysis in Appendix E illustrates the plausibility of Assumption 2 using real-world speech data, while the controlled synthetic experiments in Appendix H investigate the proposed conversion error bound. These experiments are intended to support and illustrate the theoretical findings rather than demonstrate improvements in real-world conversion performance.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Part 2

W5: A gap between the proposed independence-based learning objective and the approximate conversion guarantee.

We agree with the reviewer that approximate statistical independence does not, in general, guarantee approximate sample-wise invariance without additional quantitative conditions. However, this observation is consistent with our theoretical framework. Under Assumptions 1–2 and perfect reconstruction, Lemma 1 establishes that exact statistical independence implies exact sample-wise invariance. In the finite discrete setting, Assumption 2 guarantees a strictly positive separation between the content probabilities. In the reviewer's counterexample, this separation is Δp=2∣δ∣\Delta_p=2|\delta|, which approaches zero as the statistical dependence vanishes. Thus, the counterexample demonstrates the absence of a uniform guarantee independent of the asymmetry margin, but does not prevent a quantitative relationship that explicitly depends on this margin. Importantly, Lemma 2 does not require such an implication: it directly assumes bounded sample-wise invariance through Assumption 6 and derives the corresponding conversion-error bound. We have clarified this distinction in the revised manuscript. In addition we extend our appendix with another assumption based on approximate statistical independence measured by total variation distance, together with additional regularity conditions. We provide a new assumption, new proposition and its proof in Appendix J (Approximate Independence Assumption and Conversion Error Bound). This provides a complementary theoretical guarantee that does not require Assumption 6 and more directly connects approximate independence to conversion accuracy.

Corollary 2 (HSIC-Based Conversion Error Bound). Furthermore, assuming finite latent support of size M, strictly positive-definite kernel Gram matrices with minimum eigenvalues γS^,γC\gamma_{\hat S}, \gamma_{C} and πmin=min⁡cP(C=c)>0\pi_{min} = \min_c P(C=c) > 0, we establish

\frac{\sqrt M} {2\pi_{\min}\sqrt{\lambda_{\hat S}\lambda_C}} \sqrt{\operatorname{HSIC}(\hat S,C)}.$$ Combining this with Proposition 4 yields $$E_S [ \epsilon_{\mathrm{conv}}] \leq 2\epsilon + \frac{4L^2 D_{\hat{S}}^2 p_{\max}\sqrt{M}} {\Delta_p \pi_{\min}\sqrt{\lambda_{\hat{S}} \lambda_C}} \sqrt{ \mathrm{HSIC} (\hat{S},C)}$$ This establishes a direct population-level connection between HSIC-based independence regularization and conversion accuracy under explicit regularity conditions. The new Colored-MNIST experiments in Appendix K complement this analysis by empirically evaluating HSIC-based training without paired counterfactuals. And the error bound based on approximate independence: **Proposition 4 (Robust Conversion Error Bound).** Under Assumptions 2, 4, 5, and 9, for finite content support, let $$\delta=\sup_{c\in\operatorname{supp}(C)} \operatorname{TV}(P_{\hat S\mid C=c},P_{\hat S}),$$ and define the content probability separation margin $$\Delta_p=\min_{i\neq j}|p_S(s_i)-p_S(s_j)|>0.$$ Then, for any source and target conditions c,c', $$E_S[\epsilon_{\mathrm{conv}}(S,c,c')] \leq 2\epsilon + \frac{8L^2 D_{\hat{S}}^2 p_{\max}}{\Delta_p}\delta.$$ This result provides a quantitative connection between approximate statistical independence and expected conversion error, without requiring Assumption 6.
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Part 3

W6: Paired invariance versus independence-based training (Appendix H). We thank the reviewer for this observation. We clarify that the paired setup in Appendix H was chosen as a controlled experiment to investigate the tightness of the proposed conversion error bound. Access to paired samples allows us to directly measure latent invariance and conversion errors, rather than serving as a requirement of our proposed learning framework.

To further address the reviewer's concern, we introduce an additional experiment using Colored-MNIST, where the model is trained using only the reconstruction objective and an HSIC-based independence penalty, as described in Section 7, without access to paired counterfactual samples during training. Paired samples are used only for evaluation to measure conversion accuracy.

We construct Colored-MNIST using 10,000 images and three attributes C={R,G,B}C=\{R,G,B\}. The generative map f(s,c)f(s,c) places handwriting identity ss in the RGB channel specified by cc. Because every selected image is unique and nonzero, both the identity and color can be recovered from f(s,c)f(s,c); hence ff is injective and Assumption 1 holds. We define SS as the individual handwriting identity and sample it using

+\alpha\frac{2(K-i+1)}{K(K+1)},\qquad \alpha=0.25.$$ All 10,000 identity probabilities are distinct, including after the correlated-color sampling adjustment. Consequently, no non-identity permutation can preserve $P_S$, so Assumption 2 holds. We examine two cases: in the first one we model the samples so that $S \perp C$, while in the second one we pick a challenging setup and design the experiment so that $\S \not \perp C$. In the second case, each identity has a preferred color with probability $0.9$, and the other colors occur with probability $0.05$ each. We train identical conditional autoencoders with reconstruction alone or reconstruction plus HSIC, and evaluate all six ordered conversion directions. This construction lets us examine whether approximate statistical independence produces the sample-wise invariance needed for correct conversion. HSIC loss term enables conversion, reducing the mean conversion MSE by approximately 83.6% and the sample-wise latent invariance error $\epsilon'$ by approximately 97.8%, while introducing a modest increase in reconstruction MSE (for the second challenging setup). These results demonstrate the empirical benefit of independence regularization for content-preserving attribute conversion. This additional experiment is added to **Appendix K** (MNIST example with HSIC loss objective) and directly examines the practical independence-based learning objective, complementing the controlled analysis of the theoretical bound in Appendix H. Furthermore, in **Appendix J** (also new one), we establish a quantitative connection between HSIC and total variation under finite-support and kernel regularity assumptions, yielding an explicit conversion-error bound in terms of HSIC. This provides additional theoretical justification for independence-based training.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

General Comment to Reviewers

We sincerely thank all reviewers for their careful evaluation, constructive feedback, and recognition of the strengths and contributions of our work. We greatly appreciate the thoughtful comments and suggestions, which have helped us improve the clarity, rigor, and presentation of the paper.

We particularly appreciate the reviewers' positive assessment of our main theoretical contributions, including the sufficient conditions for exact attribute conversion through distributional asymmetry, the distinction between necessity for an equivalent representation and for the original model, and the explicit conversion-error bounds characterizing the effects of reconstruction accuracy, latent invariance, and decoder stability. We are also grateful for the recognition of the relevance and potential usefulness of our theoretical framework.

We have carefully addressed the reviewers' concerns in detail in our responses below. In particular, the revised manuscript includes several important additions and improvements:

  • Appendix H: Additional controlled synthetic experiments satisfying the distributional asymmetry assumption, alongside expanded experimental details.
  • Appendix J (New): A theoretical extension establishing a conversion-error bound under approximate statistical independence, including a quantitative connection between HSIC and conversion accuracy under additional regularity assumptions.
  • Appendix K (New): Colored-MNIST experiments evaluating HSIC-based independence regularization without paired samples during training, including both independent and correlated content–attribute settings.
  • Additional revisions: Expanded empirical analysis of speech-content distributions in Appendix E, corrections and clarifications to the theoretical assumptions and proofs, and a more explicit comparison with prior work.

We have also uploaded a revised version of the manuscript, with all modified text and newly added appendices highlighted in red to facilitate reviewing the changes.

We believe these revisions substantially strengthen the paper's theoretical contributions, empirical examples, and clarity, and we respectfully invite the reviewers to reconsider their assessments and consider increasing their scores.

We sincerely thank the reviewers again for their time and valuable feedback. We would be happy to engage in further discussion and address any remaining questions or concerns.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.