- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a plug-in module for direct IS2RE prediction on OC20. The module encodes the distance between each atom and the adsorption site with RBFs, adds it to the atom or edge features, and modulates the result with a sigmoid gate at every message-passing layer. The authors apply the module to SchNet, DimeNet++, and PaiNN and report lower MAE on the 10k, 100k, and full training sets, with the largest gains at 10k. An ablation on SchNet suggests that the distance encoding and the gate are complementary.
Critical strengths
S1. The module is simple and applies to backbones with different message-passing schemes. The same distance encoding and gating attach to node features in SchNet, directed-edge features in DimeNet++, and edge RBFs in PaiNN. All nine backbone and data-size combinations show lower aggregated MAE, with the largest gains in the 10k regime.
Critical weaknesses
W1. The evaluation does not establish the module’s value on stronger backbones.
The experiments are restricted to SchNet, DimeNet++, and PaiNN. Published results for direct OC20 IS2RE without auxiliary tasks or Noisy Nodes report val_id MAEs of 0.5088 eV for Equiformer and 0.5161 eV for EquiformerV2, below the proposed method’s best result of 0.5547 eV. These literature results do not constitute a controlled comparison, but they highlight the absence of stronger backbones from the evaluation. Since the contribution is presented as a broadly applicable module, demonstrating that it also improves a stronger backbone is more informative than improvements on older architectures alone. The current experiments leave its practical value beyond the evaluated backbones unresolved.
W2. The methodological advance over existing locality-based modeling is insufficiently established.
The module combines site-distance RBF encodings, feature fusion, and sigmoid gating. These are established architectural components, and the cited local-environment pooling work already exploits the importance of atoms near the adsorbate. The paper’s main distinction is therefore the repeated incorporation of site information into intermediate message-passing representations. However, it does not compare this design with adding the same site-distance features only at the input, injecting them only at readout, or using local-environment pooling under the same backbone and training protocol. The site-only/gate-only ablation tests the combination of components but does not isolate the benefit of their placement across message-passing layers. Consequently, the experiments establish improvements over the original backbones, but do not establish the added value of the central architectural distinction over simpler ways of supplying the same local prior.
Questions for authors
Q1 (experiment request). Could you apply the module to a stronger backbone such as Equiformer or EquiformerV2 under the same direct IS2RE setting? Gains on such a backbone would support the claim that the module is broadly applicable.