- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper investigates the architectural limitations of MLIPs in representing remote atomic responses. Specifically, for an L-layer model, the force response between atoms separated by more than 2L graph hops is identically zero. The authors validate this finding by demonstrating that model depth affects force responses in the Au₂/MgO system. Furthermore, even when the architecture has sufficient expressive capacity, it does not necessarily produce physically accurate responses. Overall, this paper examines the influence of receptive fields on MLIPs, particularly in the context of remote atomic interactions.
Critical strengths
- Clear theoretical formulation. The theoretical framework is well formulated, particularly in distinguishing the general concept of receptive fields from the actual interatomic interactions that a model can represent.
- Solid experimental analysis. The experimental analysis is convincing, and the conclusions are clear and well supported.
Critical weaknesses
- I have some reservations about the overall contribution of this paper. Receptive fields have long been studied in MLIPs, and numerous existing works have introduced additional architectures or dedicated branches to capture long-range interactions. Moreover, in many systems, such as small molecules and relatively small crystals, the receptive field is of limited relevance, as the atomic graph may even be fully connected.
- Insufficient evaluation of practical significance. Although the experiments clearly demonstrate the 2L-hop threshold effect, the practical significance of this remote response has not been sufficiently evaluated. For example, how does the inability to capture such long-range responses affect the accuracy and reliability of actual atomistic simulations?
Questions for authors
Could the authors clarify the practical significance of the identified graph-reach limitations for actual atomistic simulations? To what extent do these missing remote responses affect simulation accuracy and reliability? Are existing approaches designed to capture long-range interactions in MLIPs sufficient to address the limitations identified in this paper? If so, what additional insights or practical benefits does the proposed analysis offer?