- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposed NEMORA, using learnable FMM to achieve equicvariant Long-Range Atomistic Learning. NEMORA allow different angular mixing during long-range propogating, and using density trick for multi-body interaction. Experiment results indicate that it increased the performance.
Critical strengths
- Provides extensive experiments that demonstrate the effectiveness of NEMORA across multiple benchmarks and different backbones.
- has low computational complexity and can scale to large scale systems.
Critical weaknesses
- FMM is already an effective method for long-range interactions. This paper lacks the abaltion with Fixed FMM (or, in other word, fixed NEMORA). Also, FMMCLASSIC outperforms the full model on some benchmarks, which makes this comparison important.
- Lack the accuracy performance evaluation on large scale system of NEMORA.
Questions for authors
- The authors provide many experiments and show good results. However, these experiments do not sufficiently demonstrate that the complex learnable mechanisms in NEMORA are necessary. Could the authors provide additional ablation experiments to clarify this (W1)?
- From my perspective, NEMORA shares some core ideas with existing hierarchical message passing methods. Could the authors compare NEMORA with these methods?
- How does the full NEMORA perform on large scale systems in terms of accuracy (W2)?
3 comments
Thanks to the authors for the detailed response. My major concerns have been addressed, and I have raised my score accordingly.
One suggestion is to provide clearer guidance in the main text on how to choose between different NEMORA variants for different application scenarios. This would help users to better use it for their specific scenarios.
Thank you, and guidance on choosing NEMORA variants
Dear Reviewer 25hJ, thank you for your detailed review, your follow-up, and for raising your score. Your questions on the fixed-FMM ablation, accuracy on large systems, and comparison with hierarchical message passing led to new experiments that strengthened the paper. We agree with your suggestion: in the final version we will add explicit guidance in the main text on which NEMORA variant to use: the fixed FMM where the long-range energy is essentially Coulombic (e.g., ionic melts, water), and the learnable operators where it is not (e.g., cumulene, carbon chains). We would be glad to clarify anything further before the discussion closes on Nov 18. We greatly appreciate your support.
Response to Reviewer 25hJ
We thank the reviewer for three clear questions at the core of the method. New results: Appendix J. We uploaded the revised manuscript and, as supplementary material, a comparison with the submission. We also edited the text for clarity and brevity; the method and theory are unchanged, and all changes are marked in the comparison.
R1 – Ablation with a fixed FMM (W1, Q1). Yes: where the long-range physics is more than a sum of Coulomb terms, the learnable FMM is far more accurate than a fixed FMM trained on the same data. We ran the ablation you ask for, with every operator fixed to its classical value and the same backbone, data and schedule (Section 5.2, Appendix J.1).
Force RMSE (meV/Å), three seeds each:
R2 – Accuracy on large systems (W2, Q3). The accuracy holds. Models trained on periodic cells of at most 1,024 atoms are tested on unseen cells of up to 32,768 atoms, 32 times larger, and the error stays flat. The submission showed this to 4,096 atoms (Table 3 there); the revision extends it to 32,768 (Table 2, Appendix J.3).
Periodic ionic melt, force RMSE (meV/Å); cells above 1,024 atoms unseen:
R3 – Comparison with hierarchical message passing (Q2). NEMORA shares the hierarchy and differs in what the hierarchy carries. Hierarchical message passing (EGHN, MuSE) summarizes a cluster by a scalar-weighted average of its atoms, which discards how they are arranged about the centre. Multipole pooling keeps that arrangement, direction included, and the far field depends on it.
Force RMSE (meV/Å), mean ± standard error of three seeds: