- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents NoRRA, a framework for modeling long-range interactions in machine-learned interatomic potentials. It uses species-weighted structure factors to augment the atom and pair features of a local model with information about the atomic arrangement in the full structure. The model also predicts latent atomic charges, constrained to sum to the specified total charge, and uses them to compute an additional interaction energy with a learnable sum-of-Gaussians kernel. The authors evaluate implementations based on PET and MatterSim architectures on various molecular and materials datasets. They assess energy and force errors and report additional tests of molten-salt structure and thermal expansion, together with the longitudinal–transverse optical phonon splitting in NaCl.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses the challenge of capturing long-range effects in local interatomic potential models and evaluates the proposed approach across several datasets and physical observables. The ablation study (Section 4.5) examines the contributions of the non-local input features and the interaction energy modeled by the sum-of-Gaussians kernel. Their combination gives the lowest reported energy and force errors on the three systems included in this comparison (Table 4).
Critical weaknesses
I think the manuscript contains some promising ideas, but they need to be developed further and tested more carefully. Despite the many calculations, it remains unclear what the method adds and whether the results support the claims. I believe substantial revision is needed before the paper is suitable for publication.
Detailed comments:
W1. I find it difficult to understand what the authors consider the main contribution. As the authors acknowledge, nonlocal features, interaction energies based on latent charges, and learnable sum-of-Gaussians kernels have already been explored in previous work, including https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5128375, https://proceedings.mlr.press/v202/kosmala23a.html, and https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/ssp9-7s81. NoRRA passes nonlocal atom and pair embeddings to an existing backbone and predicts an additional interaction energy from latent atomic charges. It remains unclear what is new in the embeddings, their use by the backbone, or their combination with the interaction energy. The paper should explain whether its contribution is a new method, better results from combining existing methods, or a better understanding of when this combination is useful.
W2. The ablation in Section 4.5 is useful, but I find it difficult to relate its results to the rest of the paper. It shows that combining the two components improves energy and force errors on three systems. However, it does not show whether the same conclusion holds for the main benchmarks or the models used to calculate physical properties. The phonon calculation appears to use a separate PET model with the SOG interaction-energy component but without the nonlocal input features, so it does not test the proposed combination. The authors should explain which conclusions from the ablation apply to the other results and test the individual components under the conditions used for those calculations.
W3. The SPICE results are also difficult to interpret because the training settings differ. NoRRA uses an energy-to-force loss weight of 0.25:1, while the PET and PET-LES baseline models use 0.01 or 0.05. Giving more weight to energies could itself reduce the energy error. The authors should explain why these weights differ and provide comparisons with the same training settings. I could not find the corresponding SPICE force errors. The reported force-sign accuracies do not show whether the lower energy errors come at the expense of force accuracy.
W4. I would also like to see how the PET baseline compares with the models reported in https://arxiv.org/abs/2601.16195v3. The published numbers use different test sets and error measures, so they cannot be compared directly. Evaluating these PET models on the same test set would help establish whether the reported gains depend on the particular baseline used here. Differences in model size, training time, and computational cost should be taken into account too.
W5. I do not find the argument in lines 57–65 convincing. Writing the total energy as a sum of atomic contributions does not prevent correct long-range behavior when those contributions depend on nonlocal features. LODE and related approaches explicitly connect such features to electrostatic asymptotics (https://doi.org/10.1039/d0sc04934d). The authors should explain which limitation of these approaches NoRRA resolves, especially since its learned SOG kernel does not itself guarantee the Coulomb asymptote.
W6. The authors use a fixed reciprocal-space cutoff, but it is unclear whether the sums are sufficiently converged for different simulation cells. A cutoff that works for one cell may not be sufficient for a larger cell. Related concerns about the dependence on summation parameters and transfer between systems are discussed in https://openreview.net/pdf?id=ssfrYXdQ4x. The authors should show how the predicted energies, forces, and stresses depend on the cutoff and clarify whether it controls numerical accuracy or is part of the learned model. They should also test whether repeating the same periodic structure in a larger cell preserves the energy per atom, forces, and stress.
W7. The SPICE models also use different charge constraints. Table 6 specifies charges that sum to the total system charge for NoRRA, while the LES charges are constrained to sum to zero. The authors should explain this difference and its effect on the comparison. PET-QEq uses a hard 12 Å interaction cutoff and is fine-tuned for 30 epochs from an epoch-150 checkpoint, whereas the other SPICE models are trained for 207 epochs (Appendices C.4 and D.1). These differences should be justified. The QEq results also need to be interpreted with this cutoff in mind, since they do not establish how NoRRA compares with QEq models that include interactions beyond 12 Å.
W8. Several experiments do not clearly support the authors’ explanations. The Au/MgO cutoff test uses an adaptive neighborhood targeting eight neighbors, so increasing the cutoff does not necessarily increase the structural information available to the model. The ion-pair test checks only force signs. The authors could also compare force magnitudes and their dependence on distance, which does not require isolated-ion reference energies. Finally, the OMat results use different datasets and training stages of 1, 6, and 300 epochs. It is therefore unclear whether the larger improvements on ionic systems come from their stronger long-range interactions or from differences in the data and training.
W9. The presentation of the MatterSim results is misleading. The main table includes only cases where both energy and force errors improve, while Appendix F reports worse energy errors elsewhere and different training schedules for Au/MgO. It is also unclear whether MatterSim uses both NoRRA components. These results do not establish that the reported benefits hold across backbones.
W10. The paper should state how forces and stresses are calculated for each experiment. The RDF simulations use nonconservative forces (Appendix E.3), and Appendix B.5 allows forces calculated with the predicted charges held fixed. Since these charges depend on atomic positions, this dependence must be accounted for when differentiating the energy. The authors should also check whether the simulation results change with the way they compute forces.
W11. Appendix B.5 describes direct summation, PME, and NUFFT as alternative ways of calculating the interaction energy. The authors should show whether they give the same energies and forces for the same structures. Any resulting differences, and which implementation is used for each experiment, should be explained.
W12. The supplement contains saved results and plotting scripts, but no NoRRA implementation, trained models, or complete settings to reproduce the experiments.
Questions for authors
My questions follow directly from the weaknesses presented above and would be answered by addressing them.