- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies prediction of neural activity preceding behavior on the marmoset ECoG data. The authors propose to align multi views of the data including spectral features, window-specific functional connectivity and information bottleneck subgraph learning module. Improved classification accuracy is reported, as well as interpretation of learned masks as evolving predictive neural activity. However, I find the paper not very well-written. The contribution is mostly a combination of existing components with no technical novelty. Methodology lacks insights, with repeated emphasis on of "aligning spectral representations and functional topology". However, I do not see challenges in combining these methods and more importantly why the combination would lead to better scores.
Critical strengths
I believe predicting behavior before its onset is an important problem for responsive brain–computer interfaces. The authors have done a good job in introducing the background in the introduction. The authors attempt to facilitate understanding of which neural signals support these predictions by the use of ECoG data.
Critical weaknesses
My main concern is that the paper does not bring forward much technical novelty and there seems to lack a convincing motivation for the combination of existing modules. The proposed cross-view coupling, which the authors repeatedly emphasize throughout the paper, amounts to applying graph attention to node features and adjacency matrices, which are standard steps. It is unclear to me what challenges or failures of the existing methods that this proposed "alignment" resolves.
The experiments also does not seem to sufficiently support the proposal: destorying the feature–graph correspondence reduces accuracy by only , and removing temporal attention slightly reduces accuracy while improving ROC-AUC. The interpretability claims are also not very well supported. Table 9 indicates that random retention outperforms learned retention. While improved scores are appreciated, what is more important is the necessity of the proposed mechanisms, the insights that the combination would work, and empirical evidence that tells what enables the improved scores.
Questions for authors
Please refer to weaknesses for questions.