- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces NeuroMI, a three-stage progressive EEG foundation model for motor imagery (MI) decoding. In Stage 1, the model learns general EEG representations from the TUEG corpus through raw-signal reconstruction and frequency-band energy reconstruction. In Stage 2, it undergoes MI-specific pretraining on approximately 290,000 four-second MI samples, using a classification loss together with auxiliary regression objectives for μ/β-band power, event-related desynchronization (ERD), and filter bank common spatial pattern (FBCSP) features. In Stage 3, the encoder is frozen and only a lightweight classification head is trained. The model combines a multi-scale CNN, frequency-aware positional encoding, and a spatiotemporal fusion Transformer, and is evaluated against task-specific models and EEG foundation models on nine public MI datasets. The results are competitive, but further evidence is needed to substantiate cross-subject generalization and establish the individual contributions of the proposed components.
Critical strengths
- The problem is practically relevant. NeuroMI uses progressive pretraining to bridge the gap between general EEG representations and the requirements of MI decoding. Incorporating sensorimotor rhythms, ERD, and FBCSP features as auxiliary supervision offers a useful direction for integrating neurophysiological priors into the domain adaptation of EEG foundation models.
- The experimental evaluation is relatively broad. The authors compare the method with several task-specific models and EEG foundation models on nine public MI datasets, and also report ablations of auxiliary losses, feature visualizations, and analyses of training-data scale. These experiments provide some supporting evidence for the proposed approach.
Critical weaknesses
- The individual contributions of the pretraining stages and the components within the EEG encoder remain unclear. The observed gains may come from several factors, including the additional MI training data, Stage 1 general-purpose pretraining, Stage 2 classification supervision, neurophysiological auxiliary objectives, and the encoder architecture. The current ablations do not sufficiently disentangle these factors. In particular, the independent contribution of Stage 1 and the roles of architectural components such as frequency-aware positional encoding have not been specifically validated.
- The neurophysiological supervision targets and their implementation details require clarification. The relationship between the 1–40 Hz band-pass filter and the 30–50 Hz band-energy target is unclear. The physiological validity of using the first 0.5 seconds of each trial as the ERD baseline should be explained in light of the cue timing in each dataset. For FBCSP, the filter-bank frequency bands, number of CSP components, definition of the 280-dimensional feature vector, and scope of data used to estimate the spatial filters should be specified.
- Evidence for generalization is insufficient. The downstream experiments primarily use within-subject five-fold cross-validation, and the classification head is still trained on labeled samples from the target dataset. This setup neither adequately evaluates generalization to unseen subjects nor establishes zero-shot cross-dataset transfer without labeled target-domain data.
Questions for authors
- Cross-subject generalization and cross-dataset transfer. Add a leave-one-subject-out or another subject-independent evaluation, as well as a zero-shot cross-dataset transfer experiment in which no labeled samples from the target dataset are used to train the classification head should be better. If these evaluations are outside the scope of the paper, how should the generalization claims supported by the current results be delimited?
- Individual contributions of progressive pretraining and the architecture. In order to determine the independent contributions of the two stages, it is necessary to compare the performance of completely removing either stage one or stage two. In addition, providing ablations of key architectural components is also important, such as frequency-aware positional encoding, and clarifying differences among the foundation-model baselines in their pretraining data, supervision signals, and training configurations.
- Implementation of the neurophysiological auxiliary objectives. How is the Stage 1 band-energy target covering 30–50 Hz related to the 1–40 Hz filtering range? Does the first 0.5 seconds of each trial correspond to a pre-task baseline for ERD in every dataset? For FBCSP, please specify the filter-bank frequency bands, the number of CSP components, the definition of the 280-dimensional feature vector, and how the spatial filters are estimated, including which data are used for estimation.
- Model adaptability. As a EEG Foundation Model, can the model truly accommodate different EEG channel configurations and input durations?
- It seems that MIRepNet is more competitive on most datasets. Why isn't it included in Figure 1(b)?