- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The proposed method, BrainMamba, integrates a coupled multi-channel Mamba state update, periodic spatial/temporal Transformers, mixture-of-experts routing, and masked reconstruction, pretrained on heterogeneous EEG corpora. Evaluations cover emotion, motor imagery, cognition, and clinical datasets.
Critical strengths
- Multi-corpus pretraining and heterogeneous montage handling.
- Comparisons with LaBraM, CBraMod and other EEG models, plus corpus-sampling analyses.
Critical weaknesses
- The central generalization claim is confounded by pretraining on the unlabeled target datasets before fine-tuning. The paper reports strong performance across more than ten datasets. There is a fundamental problem in the experimental setting: the pretraining was done on all available unlabeled EEG datasets followed by downstream evaluation on those same datasets. This causes a serious data leakage issue. The basic rule for machine learning is: test data should never be used in any stage of the training, no matter whether their labels are used or not; otherwise, the purpose of evaluating generalizability is forfeited. Authors should do a leave-one-dataset-out pretraining experiment, where the target dataset is excluded entirely from pretraining.
- Eq. 4 collapses cross-channel interactions into a shared transformed sum, potentially modeling common-reference and volume-conduction effects instead of neurophysiological connectivity.
- The rank argument for a later Transformer recovering information already discarded by a state bottleneck is not convincing without residual information paths.
Questions for authors
- Does BrainMamba genuinely model spatial interactions between EEG channels? Or, how can the model learn meaningful spatial connectivity when the coupling operator does not distinguish individual channel pairs?
- Does the experimental protocol demonstrate genuine foundation-model generalization?
- How does your proposed architecture (an integration of several other known components) bring new insights?
Kind Reminder to Review Our Rebuttal Responses
Dear Reviewer, thank you very much for your time and consideration. As the rebuttal period will end soon, we would like to kindly remind you that we have provided detailed responses to your comments and concerns. We would greatly appreciate it if you could take a moment to review our rebuttal before the deadline. Thank you again for your valuable feedback.