- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The manuscript presents NeuroStream, a streaming EEG foundation model that combines within-frame spatial Transformer attention with channel-wise causal Mamba state-space modeling. It also introduces next-frame amplitude-spectrum prediction for self-supervised pretraining and evaluates the model across five EEG downstream tasks. The problem of processing continuous EEG signals is relevant, and the proposed framework demonstrates promising performance on long-duration tasks. However, the methodological novelty is limited, as the core framework primarily integrates established spatial attention, state-space modeling, and frequency-domain pretraining techniques. The distinct technical contribution of this particular integration is not sufficiently established.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses a meaningful practical problem: modeling continuous EEG signals without relying on fixed temporal windows or repeatedly processing historical observations.
- The separation of spatial attention and temporal state-space modeling provides an intuitive and computationally efficient architecture for streaming EEG analysis.
Critical weaknesses
- The proposed architecture is not sufficiently differentiated from existing spatiotemporal modeling approaches, such as CBraMod. Replacing temporal attention with a standard Mamba-based state-space module enables causal streaming but does not by itself establish a substantial methodological contribution.
- The claimed advantages of bounded memory, variable-length inference, and adaptive temporal context largely follow from established properties of causal state-space models. The manuscript does not introduce a clearly distinct mechanism beyond their application to EEG.
- The proposed next-frame amplitude-spectrum prediction combines established autoregressive prediction and frequency-domain pretraining strategies. Its methodological novelty and specific advantages over existing EEG pretraining objectives remain insufficiently demonstrated.
- Although the experiments show promising performance, the ablations do not adequately isolate the benefits of the proposed architectural integration or pretraining objective. Moreover, different temporal input lengths between streaming and non-streaming baselines complicate direct performance comparisons.
Questions for authors
- Beyond replacing temporal attention with Mamba, what specific methodological contribution distinguishes NeuroStream from existing spatiotemporal EEG architectures such as CBraMod? Is there an EEG-specific mechanism that cannot be achieved through a straightforward combination of existing components?
Reviewer Feedback and Final Discussion
Dear Reviewers,
The authors have submitted their rebuttals addressing your review comments, and the reviewer–author discussion period is coming to an end.
Could you please review the authors' responses, provide your feedback (if you have not), and actively engage in the final discussion before the deadline?
Thank you for your time and contributions.
Best regards,
The AC