- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposed a method called Dynamic State Filtering (DSF). It reconstructs dense EEG from sparse streaming recordings through historical state prediction and topology-aware innovation correction, fused with learned channel weights. Tests on SEED, SEED-IV, and BCI2000 include three channel densities, corruption, downstream EEGNet, and frozen EEGPT evaluation.
Critical strengths
- The proposed causal prediction–correction formulation is appropriate for missing EEG channels.
- Metrics are computed on unobserved electrodes, and component ablations and fixed downstream classifiers strengthen the evaluation.
Critical weaknesses
- EEG spatial interpolation cannot create genuinely independent neural information. No evidence is provided in the paper to show that high scalp waveform correlation demonstrates recovery of focal cortical activity or discriminative spatial filtering.
- The paper evaluates EEG spatial super-resolution primarily using NMSE, PCC, and SNR. While these are appropriate signal-reconstruction metrics, whether they adequately measure the recovery of spatially specific neural information is not justified.
- The uncertainty gain is explicitly an uncalibrated surrogate, and the filtering branch has at most 20% fusion weight (Appendix C.4); evidence that filtering rather than history-driven reconstruction explains the gains remains incomplete.
- The manuscript repeatedly refers to a "BCI2000 dataset." Strictly speaking, BCI2000 is a general-purpose BCI software platform, not a dataset. The authors should just use PhysioNet dataset which is commonly used. There are some info that needs to be clarified in the manuscript about the dataset. The original dataset contains 109 participants, sampled at 160 Hz, and uses run-dependent event annotations for motor execution and imagery. The manuscript reports an 88-subject subset, 200-Hz reconstruction settings, and four-class motor-imagery evaluation.
Questions for authors
- Why only 88 subjects were used, including the subject identifiers and exclusion criteria.
- Whether the original 160 Hz recordings were resampled to 200 Hz, and how this was performed.
- Which experimental runs were selected and how the four motor-imagery classes were constructed from the run-dependent annotations.
- Whether the reconstruction and downstream classification experiments used identical subject partitions and whether any temporal windows overlapped across partitions.
- What is results of the direct comparison between downstream decoding using the original sparse electrodes and decoding using the reconstructed high-density EEG?
3 comments
Thank you again for your careful review. We would appreciate your feedback on our rebuttal and the additional experiments when you have a chance.
We have corrected the PhysioNet dataset description, clarified the preprocessing and subject partitions, and added direct sparse-versus-reconstructed decoding comparisons, regional decoding experiments, and further branch analyses. We also clarify that our results support scalp-signal reconstruction and decoding utility, without claiming recovery of independent neural information or focal cortical sources.
Could you let us know whether these clarifications and additional results address your concerns, or whether any specific issues remain? We would be happy to provide further explanations or evidence.
Thank you again for your time and consideration.
Thank you for answering my questions. I will maintain my score.
Dear Reviewer h7Ke, could you please let us know whether our responses, protocol clarifications, and additional experiments address your concerns, and whether you have any remaining or new questions we could clarify?