- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper formulates EEG spatial super-resolution (EEGSR) as scalp-field inpainting and utilizes a fixed set of unseen electrodes : these specific locations are strictly excluded from training conditions, reconstruction loss calculations, and validation model selection, and are only evaluated during testing. The paper attempts to demonstrate that the model can extrapolate from observed scalp fields to unsupervised electrode sites.
Critical strengths
Fixing the unseen set and evaluating exclusively on is a significantly stronger and more rigorous approach than the traditional random missing-channel protocol. The experimental problem definition is well-defined and clear. The experiments are relatively comprehensive, covering multiple datasets, different sparsity ratios, and various regional occlusion scenarios.
Critical weaknesses
The most valuable contribution of this paper is its evaluation protocol, not the proposed network methodology. Treating unseen electrodes as field inpainting is conceptually sound, but the paper fails to clearly demonstrate that its specific architecture provides a novel, irreplaceable mechanism compared to existing coordinate-conditioned neural fields, continuous interpolation techniques, or simple field-completion models.
The "zero-shot unseen site" capability is still confined within fixed standard montages or discrete grids. It does not demonstrate true generalization to continuous coordinates, different electrode caps, different coordinate systems, or genuine cross-hardware montages. Therefore, the conclusion should be accurately restricted to "fixed location holdout within the same discrete montage."
Baseline fairness remains highly problematic. Some baseline methods are evaluated in a frozen state, some are mixed-adapted, and others can only be run under different settings. While such comparisons can serve as a reference, they are insufficient to support strong claims regarding state-of-the-art performance.
The quantity, spatial distribution, and distance to the nearest training electrodes for the holdout set are limited. The observed performance gains may be heavily influenced by the specific geometric difficulty of the chosen rather than representing a genuine site generalization capability.
Questions for authors
Compared to existing coordinate-conditioned neural fields or continuous field completion methods, what crucial new capability does the proposed network mechanism (rather than the testing protocol) actually introduce? It is reasonable to describe EEG reconstruction as scalp-field inpainting, but it leads me to a question: Can the EEG foundation model really produce broader temporal, spectral, and cross-channel structure? What the eeg foundation model gives should be semantic representation, right?
Please retrain adaptable coordinate-query baselines under the exact same fixed protocol, and clearly distinguish between a model being "unable to adapt" and simply yielding "poor performance."
Please disclose the electrode identities, random seeds, scalp regions, and distances to the nearest training electrodes for all sets, and report performance across multiple independent configurations.
Can the model be trained on one montage and tested on a completely different real-world montage, or tested on continuously queried coordinates? If not, are you willing to narrow the scope of the "unseen electrode generalization" claim in the text?
6 comments
Our fine-tuning efforts for ZUNA1.1 also revealed valuable insights. On the original recipe, from-scratch training stays at the level of a zero prediction (NMSE about 1, PCC at most 0.01) in all 11 SEED configurations and 9 of the 11 SEED-V configurations. A one-factor ablation on SEED-V 4x shows that a smaller model (382M to 51M parameters) or a higher loss weight on observed tokens (0.1 to 1.0) is each sufficient to resolve this, while longer training alone (10k to 20k steps) is not (Table 13). The modified recipe combines all three changes, so ZUNA1.1 is adaptable and enters the from-scratch comparison in its trained form. No official fine-tuning code is released, so the training code and hyperparameters are replicated to our best effort (Appendix D.4). Methods that cannot be adapted are discussed under [W3].
Overall, these results answer the question of what "new capability" the network mechanism introduces against "the testing protocol." An explicit scalp lattice lets a model trained on a single dataset reconstruct unseen electrodes more accurately than coordinate-conditioned models trained on the same data. We also make sure our claims are fully grounded. The abstract, Sec. 4.1 and the conclusion make the revised claim within the from-scratch regime, and Sec. 4.1 reports the fine-tuned ZUNA1.1 result. Manuscript updates: Tables 1 and 12 (ZUNA1.1 and ScalpINR), Table 13 (recipe ablation), Table 15 (per configuration), Appendices C.5 and D.4, Abstract, Sec. 4.1, Conclusion. We thank the reviewer for suggesting this comparison, which helped shape the contribution further.
[W2, Q4] "The 'zero-shot unseen site' capability is still confined within fixed standard montages or discrete grids. ... the conclusion should be accurately restricted to 'fixed location holdout within the same discrete montage.'" / "... tested on a completely different real-world montage, or tested on continuously queried coordinates? If not, are you willing to narrow the scope ...?"
We thank the reviewer for kindly suggesting precise definitions and scope. We made a substantial effort to clarify the limitations and potentials of the 2D lattice.
The lattice follows an established convention. Placing electrodes on a 2D topographic grid is a standard representation in CNN-based EEG analysis (Bashivan et al., 2016; Thodoroff et al., 2016; Wang et al., 2020; Su et al., 2022), and we use the TorchEEG layout (Zhang et al., 2024) as the specific assignment (Sec. 3.2).
In our model, the lattice is internal to the model and the actual data format (i.e., what the model reads or outputs) remains the same as other baselines, retaining the ease of comparison. The inputs are the recorded signals of the seen electrodes, placed in their cells without spatial interpolation, and the outputs are the signals at the held-out electrodes, read from their cells. Inputs, outputs and metrics are therefore the same electrode signals for every method in Table 1, and the lattice only defines which electrodes are neighbors inside the network. The lattice is also not tied to one montage: the 62-channel SEED/SEED-V montage and the 19-channel Mumtaz2016 montage are placed on the same reference lattice (Appendix C.4).
What the lattice does limit is where the model can be queried. Queriable targets are within the lattice cells, so the model cannot evaluate at arbitrary continuous coordinates in between. Each model is also trained on one dataset, so we have not shown transfer of a trained model to a different montage or cap. Following the reviewer's suggestion, the abstract, introduction, Sec. 3.1 and the conclusion now describe the setting as "fixed-lattice site holdout within the same montage." Manuscript updates: Abstract, Introduction, Sec. 3.1 and Conclusion (scope); Appendix A (method limitations: no continuous queries, no cross-montage transfer established); Appendix B (both as future work).
[W3] "Baseline fairness remains highly problematic. Some baseline methods are evaluated in a frozen state, some are mixed-adapted ... insufficient to support strong claims regarding state-of-the-art performance."
We thank the reviewer for asking that the training regime of every baseline be clear where the comparison is made. The revised Tables 1, 2 and 9 now label each method by its regime, and we added trained baselines wherever a method can be adapted.
The baseline regimes follow from what each method permits. SSI is spline interpolation with no trainable parameters, so it is training-free. ZUNA 1.0 is evaluated with its released weights because its public release contains inference code and weights but no training loop. SRGDiff cannot output the held-out electrodes without supervising them, because its VAE latent is fitted to a fixed channel set; we therefore train it on the seen electrodes and apply SSI to reach U (hybrid). This is the "unable to adapt" case of the question Q2. ZUNA1.1 is the adaptable case: we wrote its training code ourselves and reported it both fine-tuned and from scratch (see [W1, Q1, Q2]). DeepConv, ScalpINR and NeuroX-EEG are trained from scratch on the seen electrodes.
Consistent with the reviewer's point, the paper now overly claim state-of-the-art performance in generalized settings. The headline claims in the abstract, Sec. 4.1 and the conclusion are made within the from-scratch regime, and every table labels each method by its regime. In that regime, where all models learn from the same data under the same protocol, NeuroX-EEG has the lowest NMSE in 5 of the 6 SEED and SEED-V settings. Checkpoints of NeuroX-EEG and the ZUNA1.1 baselines are selected by NMSE on the held-out electrodes of the validation subjects, and test subjects are never used for selection (Appendix C.3). Manuscript updates: regime labels in Tables 1, 2 and 9; Appendix C.5 (note on baseline adaptation); Sec. 4.1 (headline ranking within regime).
We thank the reviewer for the rigorous review and for recognizing the significance in fixing the held-out set and evaluating exclusively with "a significantly stronger and more rigorous approach than the traditional random missing-channel protocol." The review also raises an important point: what the architecture contributes should be shown separately from what the protocol contributes. We agree that making this separation highly strengthens the paper, and we ran additional experiments to this end. The manuscript has been updated accordingly, with all changes marked in blue.
[W1, Q1 (first part), Q2] "... the paper fails to clearly demonstrate that its specific architecture provides a novel, irreplaceable mechanism compared to existing coordinate-conditioned neural fields ..." / "... what crucial new capability does the proposed network mechanism (rather than the testing protocol) actually introduce?" / "Please retrain adaptable coordinate-query baselines under the exact same fixed [U] protocol, and clearly distinguish between ... 'unable to adapt' and ... 'poor performance.'"
To isolate the contribution of the architecture, we trained 88 new models: two recent coordinate-conditioned models, ZUNA1.1 in three training regimes and ScalpINR, each trained on all 22 SEED and SEED-V configurations (4 x 22). The first is ZUNA1.1 (Warner et al., 2026), the updated release of ZUNA, which conditions on continuous 3D electrode coordinates. We trained it in three regimes: fine-tuned from its released weights, and from scratch with its original recipe and with a modified recipe. The second is ScalpINR (Liu et al., 2026), a coordinate-conditioned implicit neural representation for unseen-electrode generation, which we trained from scratch. Every model uses the same held-out electrode set U as NeuroX-EEG. U is fixed for each configuration and never enters the conditioning input or the training loss (Sec. 3.1); for ZUNA1.1, only the seen electrodes are tokenized during training, so the coordinates of U are never presented. Subject splits and metrics are also identical.
NMSE on U, lower is better; bold marks the lowest NMSE among the from-scratch models (PCC and SNR are in the revised Tables 1 and 12):
For a fair comparison of architectures, we compare models within the same training regime. When all models are trained from scratch on the target dataset, NeuroX-EEG is the strongest overall: it has lower NMSE than ZUNA1.1 in 5 of 6 settings with the modified recipe and in 6 of 6 with the original recipe. Model size ablation did not narrow this gap. On the configuration where we varied the size of ZUNA1.1 (the recipe ablation, SEED-V 4x C1), a larger model did not improve: a 382M variant that trains well reaches NMSE 0.753 and the 51M modified recipe 0.763, both above NeuroX-EEG (134M) at 0.728 (Tables 13 and 15). We attribute the advantage to the inductive bias of the explicit scalp lattice, which builds local neighborhood structure into the architecture, whereas a coordinate-conditioned model must learn spatial regularity from the same data. ZUNA1.1 shows its strength when it starts from weights pretrained on a large external corpus. Fine-tuned, it showed a better NMSE than NeuroX-EEG in 4 of 6 settings (SEED 8x and all SEED-V scales), by 0.025 to 0.053, while NeuroX-EEG still presented more accurately at SEED 2x and 4x.
ScalpINR is a recent model designed for unseen-electrode generation, and it is the strongest from-scratch competitor in our comparison. Because no official code is available, we re-implemented it from the paper (Appendix C.5). It ranks second to NeuroX-EEG at SEED 2x and 4x and is the most accurate from-scratch method at SEED 8x. NeuroX-EEG has lower NMSE than ScalpINR in 5 of 6 settings and in 16 of the 22 individual configurations (Tables 1 and 15).