- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes an INR algorithm for EEG super-resolution, although I think it is rather an EEG imputation algorithm. Because the problem is not using a 30-channel EEG cap signals to predict 60-channel EEG cap signals, but using a small fraction of channels(maybe all on the left scalp) to predict the rest of channels. The algorithm adopts the 3D electrode coordinate to predict the EEG signals, thus can predict any variable electrode topologies. Experiments on three datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Critical strengths
- Formulating the problem as suppot and query funciton is interesting,
- Explicitly introducing time and frequency loss helps reconstructing EEG with higher fidelity.
- Experiments are sufficient but the settings are not clear.
Critical weaknesses
- The effectiveness of support-topology consistency is not that reasonable, since you train your model with different masks, training multiple epochs already achieves so-called support-topology consistency even without the loss function (11).
- The writing of the paper is very confusing and vague, many items are not demonstrated clearly, like what's the meaning of FiLM? The paper does not explicitly state whether the process involves independent equiprobable sampling, uniform sampling of a fixed number of channels, or another strategy; nor does it fully describe the specific sampling distribution for the support ratio during training. While the paper notes that approximately 10% of the electrodes were permanently held out, it fails to provide sufficiently detailed information, such as a complete list of channels or the specific configurations corresponding to each dataset. Information regarding dataset partitioning and downstream classifier details remains inadequate. Like what's the neural network of the Task classifier in Table 4?
- The citation of the paper is far from rigorous. Line 33-34, while you are introducing EEG spatial super-resolution, none of the cited paper are about EEGSR (Lawhern et al.,2018; Nejedly et al., 2019; Jaramillo-Jimenez et al., 2023; Wang et al., 2025).
Questions for authors
- What's the exact experiment settings? How's the dataset split?
- Cited paper should be carefully checked.
3 comments
(2/2) We thank Reviewer TY1c for the effort in reviewing our work and providing constructive comments. We address each concern or question below.
W1. The effectiveness of support-topology consistency is not that reasonable, since you train your model with different masks, training multiple epochs already achieves so-called support-topology consistency even without the loss function (11).
Response. Thank you for the question. Training with random masks supervises each support-conditioned prediction against the ground truth. The support-topology consistency loss additionally constrains predictions from two support sets to agree at the same query locations, with gradients stopped through the branch with more observations. Random-mask training does not explicitly impose this agreement between predictions.
To isolate this effect, we retain dual-support sampling and both reconstruction losses, set only the weight of Eq. (11) to zero, and keep the remaining training conditions unchanged. Removing this term increases NMSE on all three datasets at both support ratios, supporting the contribution of the direct consistency constraint. Values are means across 50 test masks using a single training seed (2026).
| Dataset | r | Full ScalpINR NMSE ↓ | Without consistency loss NMSE ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|
| SEED | 0.25 | 0.4071 | 0.4400 |
| SEED | 0.5 | 0.2470 | 0.2878 |
| EEG-AAD | 0.25 | 0.3327 | 0.3625 |
| EEG-AAD | 0.5 | 0.2944 | 0.3348 |
| BCI2000 | 0.25 | 0.2511 | 0.2812 |
| BCI2000 | 0.5 | 0.1865 | 0.2366 |
Changes in the revised manuscript. We clarified how the consistency objective differs from random-mask training and added the controlled loss ablation (Section 2.3, Lines 248–254; Tables 12–14; Appendix G.1, Lines 1052–1058, in red).
W3. The citation of the paper is far from rigorous. Line 33-34, while you are introducing EEG spatial super-resolution, none of the cited paper are about EEGSR (Lawhern et al.,2018; Nejedly et al., 2019; Jaramillo-Jimenez et al., 2023; Wang et al., 2025).
Q2. Cited paper should be carefully checked.
Response. Thank you for pointing out the citation issue. The statement about EEG spatial super-resolution in Lines 33–34 of the original manuscript should be supported by directly relevant work. In the revised manuscript, we have retained Wang et al. (2025), added ESTformer and SRGDiff, and moved the application-background references to the statements they support (Section 1, Lines 33–36).
Changes in the revised manuscript. We corrected the EEG spatial super-resolution citations and moved the application references to the statements they support (Section 1, Lines 33–36, in red).
Dear Reviewer TY1c,
Thank you again for identifying the unclear experimental details and questioning the role of support-topology consistency. We have posted detailed clarifications and revised the manuscript accordingly.
To isolate the consistency term, we retained dual-support sampling and both reconstruction losses while removing only the agreement constraint. This increases mean NMSE on all three datasets at both tested support ratios, providing direct evidence beyond random-mask training alone (Tables 12–14; one training seed and 50 test masks).
We also specified the subject splits, support-sampling distribution, held-out-electrode lists, FiLM definition, and frozen EEGNet evaluation settings. The introductory EEG spatial super-resolution citations have been corrected, and the application references moved to the statements they support.
When you have a chance, could you please revisit our responses and let us know whether the controlled ablation and expanded protocol description address your concerns? We would be grateful for any remaining questions about the method or experimental setup.
(1/2) We thank Reviewer TY1c for the effort in reviewing our work and providing constructive comments. We address each concern or question below.
Response. Thank you for identifying the missing details. We clarify the data partitions, support sampling, held-out electrodes, FiLM conditioning, and downstream classifier below.
Data partitions. The datasets are split by subject into training, validation, and test sets before temporal windows are extracted within each partition (Section 3.1, Lines 293–296; Appendix C.1, Lines 678–686). The partitions used in the additional experiments are listed below. The complete subject identifiers are provided in Appendix C.1.
FiLM. Feature-wise Linear Modulation generates time-varying scale and shift parameters for each decoder layer from the observed EEG, modulating the hidden features (Section 2.2, Lines 165–168 and 190–194; Eqs. (1) and (4)).
Training support sampling. For each batch, we independently sample two support ratios from the uniform distribution on [0.5, 0.8). For each ratio, the number of support electrodes is round(r × C), where C is the number of available electrodes, and the electrodes are sampled uniformly without replacement for each window. Both support sets receive reconstruction supervision, while the consistency term stops gradients through the branch with more observed electrodes. The H1 ablations use an effective batch size of 12, 10 training epochs, and training seed 2026.
Evaluation masks. For r<1, the additional ablations use 50 test masks generated with seeds 41–90, shared across all ablation variants. At r=1, all non-held-out electrodes are observed. Each support set contains at least one electrode, and r is defined relative to the non-held-out electrodes in held-out evaluation.
Permanently held-out electrodes. The H1 electrodes below are excluded from ScalpINR training, validation, and model selection in these additional experiments, and are used only as test queries. Newly computed normalization statistics use only training subjects and permitted electrodes.
Permanently held-out electrodes in H1
EEG-AAD originally contains 255 stored channels. We exclude zero-based indices 47, 253, and 254, leaving 252 channels with valid coordinates.
Downstream classifier. The additional evaluation uses EEGNet with a 1×64 temporal convolution (8 channels), a depthwise convolution across electrodes (D=2), 1×4 average pooling, a 1×16 depthwise-separable temporal convolution (16 output channels), 1×8 average pooling, a 256-dimensional embedding, and a classification layer. It uses BatchNorm, ELU, and dropout=0.25. We train with Adam, a learning rate of 10⁻³, weight decay of 10⁻⁵, and cross-entropy loss for 50 epochs, using batch size 128 and seed 2026. The checkpoint is selected by accuracy on validation subjects, with ties resolved in favor of the earlier epoch. The classifier is then frozen and shared across methods; CAR and per-channel temporal z-score normalization are applied independently to each input.
Changes in the revised manuscript. We clarified FiLM, subject/window counts, H1 electrode lists, support sampling, and the EEGNet evaluation settings (Section 2.1, Lines 143–145; Tables 5–6; Appendix C.2, Lines 739–744; Appendix C.5, Lines 832–841, in red).