- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces a prototype-based interactive image segmentation framework, which considers not only the spatial but also semantic information provided by the user clicks. The main experiments were conducted in several mainstream IS benchmarks.
Critical strengths
The paper clearly presents the motivation for the prototype learning enhanced interative image segmentation.
Critical weaknesses
There are a lot of incorrect symbols and claims in this paper. In addition, this paper lacks a complete literature review and the insufficient experiments cannot support the contributions. I believe the current version is not ready for the submission to ICLR 2027. Here follow the detais.
- What does the 'leverage label semantics beyond pre-defined channels' mean?
- Actually, interactive image segmentation is a class-agnostic task. While the authors state 'without fixed label constraints' in the abstract, I do not fully get the contribution of this paper.
- The related work section is quite limited. The authors should provide a complete literature review for interactive segmentation, built on model-designed and SAM-based methods. There are quite a lot papers published in recent CVPR, ICLR, NeurIPS, ICCV venues.
- The citation format should be carefully checked before submission, e.g., Line 107.
- How did the authors determine the four discrete neighbors?
- While I noticed there is clear difference between stuff and things in Figure 2, I then couldn't find any related clarification on this point. In addition, there are a lot incorrect formatting issues for the variables.
- In the experimental section, the claimed comparison with 'state-of-the-art' interactive segmentation methods is not true. There are a lot recent works in this active field, while the compared methods were mostly published before 2023. The incomplete comparisons cannot support the effectiveness of the proposed method.
- Again, in figure 5, SimpleClick is a transformer-based baseline in 2023 ICCV. Only comparing the results with it for a work submitted in 2026 is not convincing.
- The inference experiments are missing.
Questions for authors
See the weaknesses above.