- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This work argues that for specialist domains, one should use a new adapter for each segmentation prompt modality, rather than using a shared adapter. The authors show on a benchmark that they collected from other datasets (of circuit parts) that their proposed method performs better than baselines.
Critical strengths
The figures are actually relatively simple and easy to understand. I got most of the point of the method from the figures alone.
Also, the results appear to be stronger than baseline. This suggests that using per-modality adapters may be useful.
Critical weaknesses
In contrast to the figures, the text appears AI generated and is really hard to digest. There were several sentences and captions in the paper where I spent several minutes trying to figure out what they said, and still was not clear what they did. I want to emphasize this is despite being familiar with segmentation literature, and most of my understanding ended up drawing from prior knowledge rather than actually understanding what they wrote. Thus it is hard to judge the details of their results.
In my opinion until the paper is rewritten no amount results or SOTA improvement will make it worthy of acceptance.
Also, I am not really sure what the core novelty is. It looks like they argue to use a different set of LoRA weights for every type of condition. But I feel it is not clear what the insight from this is, then.
Questions for authors
It seems extremely counterintuitive that finetuning with LoRA has such strong results but with DoRA it is so weak. Is it possible the DoRA baseline did not have good hyperparameters or there was some other issue?