- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper targets video polyp segmentation and argues that the token order of a recurrent spatial model should follow foreground/background relevance rather than the raster grid. ProtoTwinMamba turns a coarse mask into soft pooling weights, builds frame-wise foreground and background prototypes, and converts prototype similarity plus the coarse prior into two guidance maps; masked linear attention refines features with them and two separately parameterized Mamba branches sort the same tokens by them before scanning. Grids are restored before a bidirectional temporal scan, and a shallow detail path plus a convolutional decoder produce the masks. With PVTv2-B2 it reports the best listed scores on all four SUN-SEG subsets and beats a retrained STDDNet on a custom CVC-612 split.
Critical strengths
-
It is cheaper than what it beats: 27.93 M parameters and 35.7 GFLOPs per frame versus 38.16 M / 75.17 for STDDNet and 82.73 M / 86.58 for SALI. Whole-model capacity therefore cannot explain the gain, which removes the first alternative explanation I would test.
-
The ordering claim is tested the right way: FixOrd changes only the scan order and costs 2.6 and 2.2 Dice on the two unseen splits, with Figure 9 showing the permutations. The paper also states plainly what the mechanism does not do (no partition, grid restored, non-causal), so its claims are sized correctly.
Critical weaknesses
-
Table 7 gives 0.749 Dice on Hard-Unseen for removing both Mamba branches while Table 5 gives 0.734 for removing only the background one — impossible for nested variants, and the same inversion appears on two other subsets. With a single run and no variance estimates the 0.761 of w/o FG versus 0.762 of the full model cannot be read at all, so the second contribution has no evidence.
-
The tables stop at STDDNet (ICCV 2025) and omit CP-Mamba — the paper's own closest prior, which orders Mamba tokens by predicted category — along with every 2025-2026 VPS method cited in Section 1, and CVC-612 has one baseline. The headline +20.4 / +22.4 Dice is measured against SALI's PVTv2-B2 row (0.592 / 0.579), 6.4 / 5.7 points below its own B5 row, so the margin is an artefact of the configuration.
Questions for authors
Q1. Given Eq. 2 and the margin term in Eq. 19, is the background guidance roughly the complement of the foreground guidance, which would make the background branch a near-reverse scan? If so, what does the twin design add over a bidirectional scan — can you report a single-branch forward+backward variant?
Q2. Please reconcile Tables 5 and 7: w/o FG+BG scores 0.749 on Hard-Unseen, w/o BG alone 0.734, which cannot both hold if the variants are nested. With no SUN-SEG validation split, on what data were the five-frame clip length and the loss weights chosen, when all are optimal on the test subsets?
Q3. Why does the comparison stop at STDDNet, and why is CP-Mamba absent when Section 2.2 names it as the closest prior? Please add CP-Mamba and the strongest 2025-2026 method under your protocol, plus SALI's B5 row alongside the B2 row you report.
Q4. On CVC-612, the weighted F-measure rises from 0.407 to 0.540 while Dice moves from 0.716 to 0.726. How does a one-point Dice gain produce a 13-point F-measure gain — same script and frame set for both methods?
Q5. What are the parameter counts of each row in Tables 5-7? Since removing a branch deletes a full Mamba block and MLA head, a capacity-matched control is needed to show the deltas come from ordering rather than capacity.
3 comments
After considering the responses in the rebuttal and the other reviews, I retain my original rating of the paper.
Dear Reviewer,
Do you have any remaining questions or concerns? We would be happy to discuss them further with you.
Thank you for your valuable comments. We have carefully addressed your concerns in our rebuttal and would greatly appreciate it if you could review our responses when convenient.