- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
Partita addresses single-click, multi-granularity 3D part segmentation. It constructs PartNeXt-XL by recursively grouping existing part annotations with a VLM, trains multiple mask candidates against the nested targets containing a click, and combines low-resolution prompt interaction with a high-resolution geometry branch.
Critical strengths
- The data and training contributions are supported by useful controlled ablations. Table 3 tests hierarchical annotations under both fixed-mask and fixed-object settings, and Table 11 in the Appendix separates set matching from single-target supervision on the same data. These results strengthen the case that the improvement is not simply due to adding more training objects.
- The geometry branch offers a concrete quality–memory trade-off: Table 4 reports 11.18 versus 20.25 GiB for full-resolution interaction, with broadly comparable overall IoU.
Critical weaknesses
The semantic quality of the new supervision remains insufficiently quantified. Appendix A.1 verifies structural properties, but disjointness, coverage, and connectivity do not establish that a grouping corresponds to a meaningful part. Appendix E explicitly acknowledges this limitation. The manually reviewed Partita200 benchmark is initialized by the same annotation pipeline (Appendix C.1), while no quantitative human audit of the training hierarchies is reported. Because scalable meaningful hierarchy construction is a central contribution, the distinction between structurally valid and semantically valid annotations affects the interpretation of the dataset and the Partita200 gains
Questions for authors
What fraction of a randomly sampled set of training hierarchy nodes is judged semantically valid by independent human inspection? Please describe any existing audit, its sampling procedure, and how often manual review changed Partita200's initial hierarchy.
2 comments
Dear Reviewer Y1Lk, as the discussion period ends today, we would be grateful if you could share any further feedback on our rebuttal, if time permits. Please let us know if any concerns remain or further clarification would be helpful. Thank you for your time and consideration.
Response to Reviewer Y1Lk
We thank the reviewer for recognizing our controlled ablations and the geometry branch’s quality–memory trade-off, and for the helpful suggestions on evaluating annotation quality.
W, Q1. Semantic quality of the generated training hierarchies.
We agree that structural validity does not guarantee semantic validity. As acknowledged in our Discussion and Limitations, semantic verification within the automatic annotation pipeline relies on the VLM’s capabilities and therefore cannot strictly guarantee that every generated grouping is semantically sound. We therefore conducted a human audit during the rebuttal period, randomly sampling 1,000 generated nodes (merged masks) for manual inspection. Of these, 92.6% were judged semantically valid. This result supports the use of the generated annotations as training supervision. We describe the sampling and review protocol below.
We uniformly sampled 1,000 newly generated non-leaf nodes from our training set and divided them equally between two independent reviewers. The interface showed each target region in the context of the complete object and allowed reviewers to adjust viewpoints and inspect the original constituent parts. A region was judged semantically valid if it formed a meaningful part or component whose constituents had reasonable functional, geometric, or compositional relationships. The two batches yielded validity rates of 93.4% (467/500) and 91.8% (459/500).
We further examined the causes of semantically invalid nodes and identified three categories: (1) semantically inappropriate groupings produced by our annotation pipeline, where the grouped parts do not form a meaningful part or component; (2) semantically incoherent whole objects, appearing as arbitrary assemblies of disorganized mesh fragments; and (3) semantically inappropriate atomic parts in the original annotations, arising from HY3D-Bench-Part's automatic merging of small-area components into adjacent larger components. The statistics are summarized below:
Q2. Construction and manual review of Partita200.
Appendix C.1 provides only a brief description of this process, so we clarify it here. Partita200 is a curated subset of automatically annotated objects. Specifically, one author visually inspected the candidate objects and their generated hierarchies, retaining objects with reasonable groupings and leaving their annotations unchanged. Objects with questionable groupings were discarded. Selection was stratified by maximum hierarchy depth, with 50 objects each at depths 2, 3, 4, and 5. We retained only textured assets spanning diverse categories, such as furniture, household items, machinery, vehicles, characters, and buildings. All selected objects were excluded from the training set by asset ID.
W. Additional evidence for the effectiveness of our annotations.
We further assess the effectiveness of our annotations through experiments on PartNetM. As described in the paper, PartNetM is a subset of PartNet whose hierarchies originate from human annotations. Following the fixed-mask-budget and fixed-object settings of Table 3, we show that our multi-granularity annotations improve Match mIoU and AP on this human-annotated multi-granularity benchmark, while AR remains comparable, as shown below:
Please let us know if any points remain unclear or if you have further questions. We would be happy to provide additional clarification.