- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a method for partitioning 3D objects using point prompts. It uses the shape representation of a pretrained 3D generative model, jointly assigns interior points to the prompted parts, and extracts closed part meshes with little interpenetration from the same signed distance field. The method supports segmentation of existing meshes and part decomposition of image-generated shapes. It is evaluated through baseline comparisons and ablations on part generation and mesh segmentation.
Critical strengths
- The method uses point prompts to extract closed parts from a single whole shape, with very little interpenetration. This addresses a common problem with generating parts independently and has practical value.
- The experiments show good part quality and segmentation performance. For mesh-conditioned generation, [email protected] is 84.4, compared with 73.9 for the best baseline on this metric. On PartNeXt, mIoU is 57.76, compared with 54.89 for the best reported baseline. The method and training objectives are clearly specified. The experiments are well organized and include ablations, a different backbone, and an additional dataset; the method, equations, and figures are easy to follow.
Critical weaknesses
The joint prompt segmentation design is very close to Instruct-Particulate [1]. That work already lets part tokens attend to the whole shape and then to one another, while query points attend first to the shape and then to all part tokens. Final labels are assigned by argmax. Each part or query update uses the same attention order as Eqs. (4) and (5), though the layer schedule and scoring head differ. This work is not cited, and the related-work section describes earlier promptable methods as answering each prompt independently.
The paper’s ablation also shows a large reduction in interpenetration when independent assignments are replaced by argmax, with a much smaller change in part quality. The remaining contributions in interior volume partitioning and mesh extraction are not enough to convince me to recommend acceptance.
[1] Ruining Li et al. Instruct-Particulate: Scaling Feed-Forward 3D Object Articulation with Kinematic Control. arXiv:2606.14699, 2026. Paper.
Questions for authors
- Compared with Section 4.2 of Instruct-Particulate (arXiv:2606.14699), this paper completes part encoding before query decoding in Eqs. (4) and (5) and uses a different scoring head. Which problems do these differences address, and where do the existing results show their effects? Apart from interior volume partitioning and closed-mesh extraction, what is new in the joint prompt segmentation component?
- I am curious what would happen if a simple step to remove overlap were applied to CubePart or X-Part outputs. Only process regions where parts intersect: assign each location to the part with the nearest surface, choosing among the parts that already contain that location, and leave everything else unchanged. This keeps the union of the parts unchanged. Could this reduce interpenetration to a level close to this method while preserving part quality? Could you report pCD, pF1, and pen% before and after this step? This would affect how much weight I give to the low penetration rate when judging the contribution.
I would consider raising my score after a convincing response, particularly to Question 1.
2 comments
Thank you for the response. The Q2 experiment answers my question directly.
Regarding Q1, the revised Section 2 now discusses Instruct-Particulate. Given that it is concurrent work, and that this paper extends joint partitioning to interior volumes and closed-part generation, I no longer consider this a major concern and have raised my score to 3.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for recognizing the practical value, good performance, and clarity of our approach. We address the questions below.
Question 1. We thank the reviewer and now discuss this concurrent work in Sec. 2. The two methods address fundamentally different problems: surface segmentation versus solid decomposition. Instruct-Particulate relies on PartField’s output, an existing part segmentation model, whereas ours decomposes the entire solid directly from whole-shape latents. Surface segmentation is a special case of our more general formulation (Sec. 3.3). While both methods share similar attention operations, our scoring head assigns spatial queries to jointly encoded part representations, enabling dense volumetric partitioning and closed-part generation. We further introduce consistency supervision to learn part-level representations from whole-shape features, whose effectiveness is demonstrated in Table 3(b).
Question 2. We thank the reviewer for suggesting this additional evaluation. We apply overlap-removal post-processing to X-Part and CubePart using Trimesh to reassign each location to the nearest part. Invalid X-Part meshes are first repaired with Trimesh, followed by Blender voxel remeshing when necessary.
Although post-processing reduces penetration to nearly zero, it does not improve part quality (pCD, pF1) and introduces additional latency. We discussed our residual penetration in Appendix B. Our method achieves substantially better part quality and faster inference without overlap-removal post-processing, demonstrating that its benefits extend beyond low penetration alone.