- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents Seg-Voxel, a representation and generation framework that jointly produces object geometry and part-separation boundaries from a single image. Built on TRELLIS.2, it adds a binary boundary attribute to the sparse voxel representation and fine-tunes the VAE and flow model to generate geometry and boundaries together. The decoded boundaries are completed using graph-based processing, temporarily removed to extract connected components, and reassigned to recover part surfaces. Experiments on HY3D-Bench evaluate reconstruction, part generation, and the two boundary-processing stages, reporting competitive whole-object geometry, improved part-level scores, and a runtime of 20.68 seconds per object.
Critical strengths
-
Representing part structure through local separation boundaries is a useful way to incorporate part discovery into native 3D generation. It avoids explicitly predicting global part identities or requiring an external segmentation model.
-
The experiments support the practical value of the approach: it preserves whole-object geometric quality while improving the reported part-level scores and achieving a low inference time. The reconstruction results and boundary-processing ablations provide useful evidence for the main design choices.
Critical weaknesses
-
The part-level metrics check whether each ground-truth part has a similar generated part, but do not directly check whether the output contains extra fragments.
-
The method treats disconnected pieces as different parts, even if they belong to the same annotated part. It also allows parts to share boundary faces. The paper should show the parts pulled apart to clarify whether their contact surfaces are complete.
-
The paper shows examples with different levels of complexity, but reports only average scores over 300 test objects. It does not give separate scores for objects with many parts, small or thin parts, or complicated contacts.
-
The paper reports 20.68 seconds per object, but does not give separate times for generation, boundary completion, connected-component extraction, and boundary assignment.
Questions for authors
The following questions correspond, in order, to the critical weaknesses above.
-
Could you check whether the generated outputs contain extra fragments that are not reflected in the best-match scores? Is there an additional metric that could measure this?
-
How do you handle an annotated part made of disconnected pieces? Please show the generated parts pulled apart so we can check whether their contact surfaces are complete and whether they share faces.
-
Could you report separate scores for objects with many parts, small or thin parts, and complicated contacts? Please also show failure cases from the final outputs.
-
How much of the 20.68 seconds is spent on generation, boundary completion, connected-component extraction, and boundary assignment?