- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper studies cloud removal across different land surfaces and cloud conditions. It combines 300,948 cloudy–clear image pairs from 14 datasets.
SDA-DD selects a smaller training set. It uses features from clear images to describe the land surface. It uses feature differences between cloudy and clear images to describe degradation. The selection method gives more weight to rare conditions.
OmniCR uses different experts for different image regions. During training, it gives more weight to scene and cloud conditions with large errors. The paper tests the method on ten datasets.
Critical strengths
-
The problem has practical value. Existing datasets contain different scenes and cloud types. Sections 4.1 and Appendix C explain why direct data pooling can create an uneven training set.
-
The selected data help several models. In Table 2, SDA-DD improves MPRNet, Restormer, and OmniCR over random selection. The gains are 2.08, 2.35, and 2.87 dB, respectively. All three models use 20% of the data.
Critical weaknesses
- The tests do not show how much each new part helps. Table 2 compares different feature choices. It does not compare selection with and without inverse-density weights while keeping the features fixed. Thus, it does not isolate the value of these weights. In Table 3, local routing adds 0.05 dB. ReLU routing adds another 0.18 dB. These results do not explain the much larger gain of the complete system. A comparison with equal model size or compute would help. Appendix E measures coverage with the same score used to select samples. This test does not show whether the method beats a simpler balancing method. The cited [UniRain] also combines data selection, experts, and task weights. OmniCR uses different features and local routing. Section 2.1 should explain why these differences matter.
- Important result and cost details are missing. Table 1 reports four individual datasets and an average over ten. The paper should report the other six results. It should state whether the average gives equal weight to datasets or images. Appendix A explains how the method reduces memory use. It does not give the number of reference samples or the retained rank for the Nyström approximation. It also does not explain how the approximation keeps similarity scores nonnegative. Table 5 reports computation for one model pass. The comparison needs the full sampling cost and measured inference time. The authors should also give selection time, baseline training schedules, and variation across repeated runs.
Questions for authors
See weakness.
The response did not impress me any further, so I will maintain the original score.