- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces a method that predicts what a multispectral optical image would have looked like without clouds. The model is given the, at least partially cloudy, multispectral optical image and synthetic aperture radar (SAR) image as input. The method first separately encodes each modality, then performs "cross-modal evidence construction" and "evidence-conditioned routing" for processing by 3 experts. Finally, the data is processed by a "gated expert mixture", latent refinement, adaptive optical skip, and a multi-scale decoder. The method outperforms prior work, specifically Pix2Pix and SAR2OPT.
Critical strengths
none
Critical weaknesses
Regardless of the experimental soundness and novelty, I do not believe this paper would be a valuable addition to ICLR or even the ML4RS community within ICLR. The paper is on cloud removal which is a specific application of ML4RS (a niche in a niche). Secondly, as far as I know, cloud removal is not as useful to ML4RS as it once was, since we now have models that can process several time steps.
The paper also does not compare against well-known baselines like GLF-CR. The paper would be improved by comparing to more baselines and even using a pre-trained foundation model like OlmoEarth, which can receive many time steps and potentially be fine-tuned for cloud removal.
Questions for authors
none
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the careful assessment of our work and for identifying several important aspects requiring clarification and further investigation.
We agree that the current submission does not provide controlled component-wise ablations isolating the individual contributions of modality reliability, cross-modal disagreement, representation uncertainty and spatial expert routing. Although our controlled experiments investigate how learned representations respond to modality degradation and cross-modal inconsistency, they do not independently quantify the contribution of each mechanism to final reconstruction performance. We will extend the experimental evaluation with targeted component-wise ablations to distinguish their respective contributions.
Regarding the mathematical formulation, our initial reliability investigation operationalizes modality reliability through relative unimodal reconstruction utility, using independently obtained optical-only and SAR-only reconstruction errors to construct empirical supervision targets. This investigation yielded Pearson correlations for optical and SAR reliability. In the final EaSe-CR architecture, reliability is extended to spatially resolved fields, which become part of the shared evidence representation. Similarly, we distinguish the perturbation-induced latent variance investigated in Section 3.5 from the learned uncertainty pathway in EaSe-CR. The former measures representation variability across eight controlled perturbation-induced evaluations and exhibits a positive association with reconstruction error; the latter produces a non-negative learned spatial representation (Section 4.1), which conditions expert routing. Importantly, this is a representation of evidence variability, not a calibrated probabilistic uncertainty estimate. We acknowledge that the earlier empirical analyses do not constitute direct calibration of the final EaSe-CR reliability and uncertainty fields, and will clarify this distinction in the revised manuscript.
We also appreciate the reviewer identifying the inconsistency in the modality-removal interpretation of Table 1. We will correct this interpretation while retaining the conclusion that the two modalities provide complementary, but asymmetric, evidence under the evaluated conditions. Regarding Tables 4–5, the aggregate PSNR, MSE and MAE are consistent with the sample-weighted regional means across the 337 matched external triplets (98 Kerala, 119 Rajasthan and 120 Ladakh). The apparent discrepancies in SSIM and SAM arise from differences in their evaluation implementations, the aggregate evaluation uses down-sampled SSIM and a valid-target-pixel mask for SAM, whereas the regional evaluation uses full-resolution SSIM and does not apply the same SAM mask. We will make these evaluation definitions explicit rather than present the metrics as directly interchangeable. We will also clarify that the PSNR values reported alongside the examples in Figure 6 correspond to individual representative patches, not regional averages.
Regarding training-run consistency, we acknowledge that the reported experiments use a single fixed random seed and do not establish variability across independently trained instances. The reported sample-level statistical analyses should therefore be interpreted as characterizing variation across evaluated observations, rather than across independent training runs. We will make this distinction explicit. For comparative evaluation, we used official released checkpoints where available, including the author-released pretrained DiffCR checkpoint, and the corresponding official implementations of the other baseline methods.
Finally, our independent external evaluation examines zero-shot reconstruction across three geographically distinct regions without fine-tuning or parameter updates. EaSe-CR achieves mean PSNR values of 30.066 dB in Kerala, 26.605 dB in Rajasthan and 17.312 dB in Ladakh. These differences reflect substantial geographical variation in reconstruction difficulty and reinforce the importance of evaluating evidence-conditioned reconstruction beyond a single environmental setting. We acknowledge that the reported regional analysis establishes EaSe-CR's performance across these regions, rather than comparative superiority over every baseline within each individual region, and will appropriately delimit this claim. More fundamentally, EaSe-CR seeks to advance the formulation of multimodal reconstruction from feature fusion towards evidence-conditioned inference, wherein the reliability, consistency and variability of available observations inform how evidence is represented, integrated and reconstructed.
We hope these clarifications address the reviewer's concerns and strengthen the presentation of the work. We would be grateful to address any further questions or points requiring clarification.