- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces GeoCR, which unifies cloud removal for RGB, multispectral, and SAR data within a single model using FLUX.2 and flow matching. The model is jointly trained on ten datasets and provides perceptual metrics and visual comparisons across multiple benchmarks.
Critical strengths
The experiments cover various observation configurations, enabling thorough visual comparisons.
The training settings, data splits, and evaluation protocols are described in detail. These materials facilitate reproducibility and provide useful references for future research on remote sensing cloud removal, regardless of the paper's acceptance.
Critical weaknesses
The contribution lies primarily in engineering integration. Flow matching and LoRA are both existing techniques, and the paper does not propose a novel de-clouding mechanism. Moreover, LoRA does not consistently improve performance across multiple datasets.
The paper does not report inference speed, memory usage, or computational cost. For large-scale deployment, it is necessary to compare the inference overhead with that of dedicated de-clouding models. Although optimal efficiency is not required, understanding this aspect remains important.
In Figure 1, some cloud-covered regions appear nearly pure white in the displayed RGB image, yet the output still contains clear surface details. What information does the model rely on to recover these details? Is this due to information preserved in other spectral bands or SAR data, or could there be overlap between the training and test samples?
Questions for authors
Clarify the technical contributions of the paper beyond its engineering integration.
Please specify whether the test images are disjoint from the ten training datasets, and explain how the model recovers surface details in thick cloud regions.
Report the single-image inference latency, memory usage, and computational cost of the proposed method, and compare them with baseline methods on the same hardware.
Revised Manuscript and Follow-up
Dear Reviewers and AC,
Thank you again for your constructive feedback. We have revised the GeoCR manuscript to incorporate the main results and clarifications from our responses.
If you have any remaining questions about the revision or our responses, we would be happy to clarify.
Best regards, The Authors