- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes an event-guided Gaussian Splatting framework for dynamic scene reconstruction, addressing motion inconsistencies and blurred details caused by shared deformation fields, particularly for fast-moving objects. The method estimates dynamic vision optical flow from event streams and uses an observability-aware motion grouping strategy to identify regions with shared motion patterns. It assigns Gaussians to static, rigid, or freely deforming branches through rendering-weight voting, while introducing spatial completion and track-guided seeding to handle event-sparse object interiors and underrepresented transient regions.
Critical strengths
-
The paper clearly identifies motion inconsistency and detail loss in deformation-based dynamic Gaussian Splatting, motivating the use of event-guided motion constraints.
-
The paper presents the proposed method in a coherent sequence, from event-based optical flow estimation and motion grouping to Gaussian assignment and reconstruction.
Critical weaknesses
-
Since the proposed method groups Gaussians by shared motion, comparisons with anchor-based or motion-sharing Gaussian methods would help clarify the benefits of its observability-aware grouping and event-derived motion supervision.
-
Reporting stage-wise runtime and peak GPU memory usage would clarify the computational costs of event preprocessing, motion grouping, and reconstruction.
-
The reliance on synchronized RGB frames and event-camera data introduces additional hardware and synchronization requirements. Discussing the trade-off between reconstruction quality and these requirements would clarify practical applicability.
Questions for authors
-
How does the proposed observability-aware motion grouping differ from existing anchor-based or motion-sharing Gaussian representations in enforcing coherent object motion?
-
Which stages contribute most to the overall computational cost, and could the authors provide a breakdown of runtime and peak GPU memory usage?
-
In what scenarios does the use of event-camera data provide sufficient benefits to justify the additional hardware and synchronization requirements compared with RGB-only approaches?
3 comments
The authors have adequately addressed my concerns, and I will raise my rating.
Dear Reviewer yrbD,
We sincerely appreciate your valuable suggestions. Thank you for your time and effort in reviewing our paper.
Best regards,
The Authors
Official Comment by Authors
Q1. "How does the proposed observability-aware motion grouping differ from existing anchor-based or motion-sharing Gaussian representations in enforcing coherent object motion?"
A1. Thank you for this question. Existing anchor-based and motion-sharing representations already allow multiple Gaussians to share motion parameters. We do not claim shared transformations themselves as our novelty. Our contribution concerns how motion groups are constructed from observed event evidence and how that evidence constrains their shared motion.
We have added SpeeDe3DGS with GroupFlow enabled as a representative motion-sharing baseline. Across our ten scenes, its mean dynamic-region PSNR is 22.59 dB, compared with 26.67 dB for our method; its mean rendered-flow EPE is 9.337 px, compared with 6.244 px. We complement it with the H=I ablations to examine the roles of directional observability and event-derived motion evidence within our pipeline.
Q2. "Which stages contribute most to the overall computational cost, and could the authors provide a breakdown of runtime and peak GPU memory usage?"
A2. Thank you for pointing out the missing computational analysis. We have conducted a stage-wise profiling of runtime and peak GPU memory usage and added the results to the Tab.11 in appendix. The breakdown is presented below.
Q3. "In what scenarios does the use of event-camera data provide sufficient benefits to justify the additional hardware and synchronization requirements compared with RGB-only approaches?"
A3. Thank you for raising this practical trade-off. We consider event sensing most valuable when object motion is insufficiently constrained by RGB observations at the available frame rate and exposure, particularly for rapid rotation and short-lived motion. Asynchronous events provide additional motion evidence between RGB frames, while RGB supplies appearance information.
These benefits come with additional sensor, spatial-calibration, and timestamp-synchronization requirements. We therefore view the method as most applicable to calibrated RGB–event acquisition systems where recovering fast motion is important. For slow motion with sufficiently sampled, sharp RGB observations, the additional hardware may offer less benefit. Beyond the methodology itself, event cameras also offer the advantage of low power consumption—though this is a factor that would only be considered during actual deployment.