- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SAGE-GS, an event-guided dynamic Gaussian reconstruction framework based on E-D3DGS. The method introduces two modules: spatial event-supervised weighting, which adaptively adjusts the weights of event reconstruction errors by fusing RGB-Event features and spatial priors; and sparse temporal opacity gating, which achieves time-dependent opacity adjustment by modulating the rendering contribution of the dynamic Gaussian at different time steps. Experiments on 8 synthetic scenes and 4 real-world scenes show that, compared to E-D3DGS, this method achieves average PSNR improvements of 0.52 dB and 0.24 dB, respectively.
Critical strengths
This paper addresses a problem of practical research significance: event signals do not always reliably reflect the motion of objects in the real world. By fusing features from RGB and event data and combining them with spatial prior information to perform adaptive weight adjustment for event-based supervision, this paper proposes a reasonable and well-motivated technical solution.
This paper conducts experimental evaluations on both synthetic and real-world scenes and provides ablation experiments for each module. The reported experimental results show that, compared to the baseline method E-D3DGS, this approach achieves performance improvements across multiple test scenes, preliminarily validating the effectiveness of the proposed modules.
Critical weaknesses
This method primarily combines event loss weighting with temporal opacity gating. The RGB-Event feature fusion draws on CompEvent, while a similar temporal gating mechanism has been studied in previous dynamic Gaussian methods. The paper does not fully explain the technical innovation or necessity of this combination.
Compared to using supervised weighting alone, temporal gating yields only an additional average PSNR improvement of approximately 0.08 dB on synthetic scenes, and performance actually declines in some scenes. Detailed weight ablation experiments were conducted only on the “fan” scene, and the study lacks experiments with multiple random seeds as well as robustness tests under event noise and lighting variations. Furthermore, the visual evidence provided in Figures 3 and 4 is limited and does not sufficiently support the reported performance improvements.
Questions for authors
Q1. In Eqs. (3)–(5), the weight predictor uses reconstruction residuals as input. How do the authors rule out the possibility that it simply learns to down-weight difficult pixels? Please compare against a predictor without residual input and analyze the relationship between predicted weights and reconstruction errors.
Q2. Adding temporal gating improves average synthetic PSNR by only about 0.08 dB over supervision weighting alone, with regressions on some scenes. Could the authors report mean and standard deviation over multiple random seeds on representative scenes, together with results at held-out timestamps? A comparison with fixed temporal gating would also help establish the value of the learned gates.
Q3. Why is the detailed weighting ablation conducted only on fan? Please extend it to at least one additional synthetic scene and one real scene. A limited robustness test under event noise or illumination changes, together with enlarged rendering crops and error maps, would better support the main claims.
Q4. In Table 1, the T-only SSIM on celestial_globe is 0.997, while the S-only and T-only results on Eagle are identical. Could the authors verify these entries and clarify how the best-PSNR checkpoints were selected? Please also report the main hyperparameters and the computational overhead of the added modules.