acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

CTRL: Consistency-Aware Text-Driven Representation Learning for Multimodal Vehicle Re-Identification

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

14 views

Abstract

Multimodal vehicle Re-Identification (ReID) aims to retrieve the same vehicle by utilizing complementary information across heterogeneous modalities. Recent studies further generate corresponding vehicle descriptions for images in each modality and leverage these textual semantics to guide visual feature learning and supply identity information. However, existing generation pipelines often emphasize descriptive completeness while overlooking the distinct requirements of text as visual guidance and as identity supplementation. Moreover, prior methods provide limited control over how textual semantics guide visual feature formation during encoding, and lack selective supplementation for each modality based on complementary identity cues retained by other modalities. To address these issues, we propose CTRL, a Consistency-Aware Text-Driven Representation Learning framework. Its text generation pipeline unifies attribute values and models modality-specific visibility to generate descriptions supported by the corresponding images and consistent in attribute values across modalities. Intra-modal Text-guided Asymmetric Propagation (ITAP) uses text to regulate information propagation during visual encoding, limits the information that identity-discriminative features aggregate from regions with weak identity information, and updates these regions in a controlled manner. Cross-modal Text-guided Semantic Completion (CTSC) supplements each modality with cues from other modality descriptions that are selected as receiving sufficient source-visual support while being insufficiently represented in the target text and visual features. Experiments on three multimodal vehicle ReID datasets show that CTRL significantly outperforms existing methods.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Vehicle Re-Identification, Multimodal Learning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_9r9KOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes CTRL, a text-driven representation learning framework for multi-modal vehicle re-identification across RGB, NIR, and TIR modalities. The authors argue that existing methods, when using MLLMs to generate vehicle descriptions, place excessive emphasis on the completeness of textual information while neglecting both Image-Text Consistency within the modality and Attribute-value Consistency across modalities. Meanwhile, existing methods lack fine-grained control over how textual semantics contribute to visual encoding and how cross-modal identity information is supplemented. In order to overcome this problem, the authors first construct the Consistency-aware Text Generation Pipeline, judge and aggregate the predefined vehicle properties and their modal visibility through multiple MLLMs, and generate a text description with a unified property value that conforms to the visibility constraints of each modality. Subsequently, two core modules are proposed: ITAP (Patch Routing using text correlation and visual scoring to reduce the interference of weak identity information on discriminative features through asymmetric information propagation); CTSC filters semantic information with source visual support but not fully expressed in the target modality from texts of other modalities to achieve selective cross-modal supplementation. Although CTRL shows good performance, I am concerned that some of the features claimed in the article are not fully confirmed.

Critical strengths
  1. The authors don’t directly use the free text generated by MLLM for training, but first unify the attribute values between different modalities, and then construct the corresponding text according to the visibility of each modality to the attribute. The design reduces cross-modal attribute conflicts at the rule level and reduces the risk of introducing information into visual guidance that cannot be independently verified by the current modality.
  2. The experimental results are highly competitive. CTRL achieved the highest mAP on the 3 data sets, with MSVR310 reaching 67.6%, WMVeID863 reaching 73.1%, and RGBNT100 reaching 89.2%.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The reliability of Consistency-aware Text Generation lacks independent, direct validation. Although the authors constrain text generation through uniform attribute values and modal visibility filtering, these decisions rely on MLLM predictions, including attribute candidate values, attribute confidence, visibility judgments and their confidence. A high degree of confidence in an MLLM does not necessarily mean that the prediction is correct, and multiple models may also produce consistent but erroneous judgments on difficult samples (although multiple MLLMs are said to be used, only Qwen-3.5-plus and GPT-5 are used for attribute evaluation). In addition, the set of attributes is determined by a predefined template, and its adequacy and impact on identity discriminative learning remain unclear. The tie-breaking rules for attribute values and visibility judgments in Appendix A are deterministic, but they lack a further analysis of decision reliability. Although Table 5 and Appendix C.2 show that author-generated text is beneficial for downstream ReID performance, these results do not directly prove the correctness of generated attributes, the reliability of confidence, or the accuracy of visibility judgments. Therefore, the verification of text consistency in the paper is more reflected in the downstream performance benefits, rather than the direct verification of its key generation mechanism.
  2. There is a certain gap between the judgment basis and semantic interpretation of Identity-discriminative patch in ITAP. In the Text-aware Identity Routing, the authors obtain the Patch's Visual Evidence Score through the learnable MLP, and calculate the cosine similarity between the Patch Feature and the corresponding modal global EoS Text Feature, and then combines the two scores and makes Top-K selection. While this learnable scoring mechanism is reasonable in itself, the Visual Evidence and Patch-Text Semantic Relevance are not necessarily equivalent to Identity Discriminativeness. In particular, certain areas that are highly relevant to vehicle descriptions may only have universal class semantics and lack the fine-grained information needed to distinguish between different vehicle identities. Existing ablations have demonstrated the effectiveness of the combined use of visual and text scoring, but have not directly verified whether high-score patches actually have stronger identity discrimination. Therefore, the interpretation of Top-K selection results as Identity-discriminative Patches still needs to be supported by fuller visual or quantitative evidence.
  3. The specific design of Asymmetric Information Propagation in ITAP still lacks sufficient ablation study support. Eq.(4) uses the Routing Score to modulate the Attention Contribution of the source patch and the Feature Update Magnitude of the target patch with weak identity. The former can be understood as reducing the information contribution of low-score regions, but the latter also weakens the effective context information obtained by weak-identity patches from high-score regions. In particular, for patches with very low routing scores, their feature updates may be significantly compressed. This introduces a certain tension with the authors’ motivation to enhance the representation of weak identity regions through global context. Although the paper verifies the effectiveness of ITAP as a whole, it does not yet clearly distinguish between the independent contributions of the source-side Modulation and the Receiver-side Modulation, nor does it compare with alternative strategies such as simple Restricted Attention. Therefore, the necessity of a dual modulation mechanism remains unclear.
  4. The semantic filtering mechanism of CTSC relies on the feature matching hypothesis that has not been fully verified. CTSC judges whether the candidate text token has the Source Visual Support, and whether it meets the Target Text Insufficiency and the Target Visual Insufficiency by using the matching score of Eq.(8), the Learnable Null Prototypes, and the Hard Gumbel-Softmax. However, the high similarity between the text Token and the reference feature set does not necessarily mean that the semantics has obtained sufficient visual support; a lower matching score does not necessarily mean that the target modality lacks corresponding identity information. Especially for NIR and TIR features with strong cross-modal appearance differences, this matching determination may be affected by the quality of feature space alignment.
Questions for authors
  1. Can we provide a quantitative assessment of attribute value accuracy and modal visibility judgment accuracy on a representative sample subset, and analyze the performance under clear and difficult imaging conditions respectively? In addition, is there a correlation between the confidence of MLLMs and the true prediction accuracy? When different models give conflicting judgments or flat votes, how often do these situations occur and what is their impact on the quality of the generated text? Are predefined attribute groups validated via ablation?
  2. Can the authors provide Patch Routing Score Map visualization under different modes to verify whether the high-resolution regions mainly correspond to the local features of vehicles with real identity discrimination?
  3. Can the authors further explain why the weak identity patch needs to reduce the update range according to its own low Routing Score when obtaining context information from high-score regions?
  4. Can the authors provide specific Token Selection cases or quantitative analysis to show that the candidate semantics selected by the model are indeed identity information that has source visual support and is lacking in the target modality?
Reviewer_N1S2OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper discusses how generated text is used in multimodal vehicle ReID and categorizes its use into guiding visual feature learning and providing identity information. The proposed approach jointly examines images from three modalities through a consistency-aware text generation pipeline, unifies attribute values, and organizes descriptions according to modality visibility to improve intra-modal image-text alignment while preserving cross-modal attribute-value consistency. Extensive experiments on three public multimodal vehicle ReID benchmarks demonstrate reliable performance improvements over existing methods.

Critical strengths

Improved alignment of multi-modal embeddings and cues for reidentification of vehicles. Extensive ablation studies. Almot 7% improvement in mAP for one of the datasets!

Critical weaknesses

Non-uniform improvements across multiple datasets. The authors should experiment with AICity Challenge datasets, which included natural langauge as a modality a few years back. AICity challenge has been going on since 2019 in various CVPR meetings, the laetst version being at ECCV 2026.

Questions for authors

Test your approach on AICity Challenge dataset. Explore the role of agenti AI for reidentification.

Reviewer_P26EOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes CTRL for multimodal vehicle re-identification, the method combines consistency-aware text generation, text-guided visual attention and selective cross-modal semantic completion. The proposed method achieves SOTA performance on three benchmarks.

Critical strengths
  1. This paper identifies the inconsistency problem in previous ReID methods, and the analysis is meaningful.
  2. This paper proposes to fuse the text information in intermediate transformer layers instead of fuse it in late stages, which is more effective.
  3. The experiments is comprehensive and the paper is well written.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper claims the proposed text generation method improves both intra and inter cross model consistency, but the experiments mainly conducts on downstream ReID tasks, which does not confirm that the consistency is improved.
  2. The proposed methods rely on multiple MLLMs to process different modality information, which may hinder its practical appliance.
Questions for authors
  1. Can the author provides more evidance that the proposed method improves the consistency and then the downstream ReID performances improved too.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.