- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes GUIDE for multi-modal object re-identification using RGB, near-infrared, and thermal images. Its central idea is to construct graph connectivity from fixed patch geometry rather than modality-dependent feature similarity. A Grid Graph Encoder performs local propagation, while an Axial Strip Readout aggregates the refined tokens into ordered strip representations. These structural features complement global ViT features, with auxiliary losses encouraging global–structural consistency, cross-modal consistency, and strip diversity. Experiments cover three person and vehicle benchmarks, including missing-modality evaluation.
Strengths
- The framework is straightforward and achieves competitive performance across all three benchmarks. The component ablations on RGBNT201 show improvements from adding GGE, ASR, and the auxiliary losses, supporting the effectiveness of the overall design.
Weaknesses
- The implementation details are incomplete. Several hyperparameters, including the number of graph layers, the number of strips, and the strip diversity margin, are not explicitly specified. The paper also does not analyze sensitivity to these choices, making it difficult to reproduce the results and assess their robustness.
- Moreover, all quantitative component ablations are restricted to RGBNT201, leaving their contributions on vehicle datasets unclear. The choice of strip orientation is not experimentally examined, and whether spatial augmentations are synchronized across modalities is unspecified despite its relevance to the spatial-consistency motivation.
Critical strengths
The method is straightforward and improves retrieval performance across three benchmarks. The ablation results on RGBNT201 further support the effectiveness of its components, making it a relatively simple approach with demonstrated empirical benefits.
Critical weaknesses
-
Incomplete implementation details and limited ablation coverage. Several hyperparameters, including the number of graph layers, the number of strips, and the diversity margin, are not explicitly specified. Although the loss weights are examined, sensitivity to these other choices is not reported. Furthermore, all component ablations are conducted on RGBNT201, leaving their effectiveness on the vehicle datasets unclear. These limitations hinder reproducibility and assessment of robustness.
-
Limited methodological novelty and insufficient validation of key design choices. GGE uses fixed eight-neighbor aggregation with feature transformations and residual connections. What advantages does this design offer over conventional methods, and what quantitative evidence supports these advantages? Have alternative strip partitioning strategies been investigated? Is partitioning along the longer spatial dimension equally suitable for both pedestrians and vehicles? The experiments show differences in retrieval performance, but provide limited direct evidence that the proposed mechanisms work as intended.
Questions for authors
-
Implementation details: Please specify the number of GGE layers, the number of strips, the diversity margin, and the inference fusion weight. Beyond the loss-weight analysis in Table 3, how sensitive are the results to these choices?
-
Contribution of GGE: What advantages does fixed eight-neighbor aggregation offer over conventional local aggregation methods? Beyond the retrieval results in Table 4, is there quantitative evidence supporting the claimed improvement in cross-modal structural consistency?
-
Strip partitioning: Have alternative strip orientations or partitioning strategies been evaluated? Is partitioning along the longer spatial dimension equally suitable for pedestrians and vehicles? Please also provide quantitative results for the ASR-only variant shown in the appendix.
-
Ablation coverage: All quantitative component ablations are conducted on RGBNT201. Do GGE, ASR, and the auxiliary losses provide consistent benefits on the vehicle datasets?
-
Data augmentation: Are random flipping and cropping synchronized across modalities, and are identical augmentation settings used for all ablation variants? Has the effect of these augmentations been examined, particularly given the method’s reliance on spatial organization?
-
Feature dimensions and loss computation: Please clarify the output dimension of the ASR projection and how the global and structural representations are combined for . Figure 2 lists this loss but does not clearly show its computation path.
-
The qualitative visualizations focus on pedestrians. Why are vehicle examples not included, and can you provide them to assess whether the proposed structural modeling also works for vehicles?
Thanks for addressing my concerns on this paper. My concers have been solved.
Please remember to include the parameter details and analyses in the revised version.
I have improve my rating form 2 to 3.
Good luck.