- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TRIDA for RGB–NIR–TIR object re-identification, building on ICPL-ReID. It introduces GRACE for channel-group exchange and adaptive feature enhancement, GRASP for cross-modal feature consistency, and MCGA for mitigating conflicting modality gradients during training. The method is evaluated on five person and vehicle ReID benchmarks, with component ablations on RGBNT201 and RGBNT100.
Critical strengths
TRIDA combines cross-modal feature exchange, consistency regularization, and gradient conflict mitigation in a unified framework. It improves mAP over the ICPL-ReID baseline across five person and vehicle ReID benchmarks, supporting its effectiveness across different datasets and object categories.
Critical weaknesses
The experimental comparison omits recent relevant methods. There are some recent examples published at CVPR 2026: CoT-ReID (main conference), FusionBridge, and RoDI (Findings). Notably, CoT-ReID is cited in the paper but is not included in the comparison tables. These omissions make it difficult to assess whether TRIDA offers meaningful improvements over recent approaches.
Questions for authors
- The fixed channel exchange strategy is insufficiently justified. The paper does not explain why contiguous channel groups and the specific cyclic exchange pattern are appropriate, or examine alternative group numbers and exchange rules. Moreover, the GRACE ablation evaluates channel exchange together with the learnable enhancement components, leaving the contribution of the exchange operation itself unclear. Please explain why do you select this fixed channel exchange strategy.
- The paper does not provide sensitivity analyses for key hyperparameters, such as the number of channel groups, the GRASP regularization weight, and the MCGA conflict threshold. It therefore remains unclear how robust the reported gains are to these choices. Please provide hyperparameters sensitivity analyses data.
- MCGA computes the g_m using only the ReID and image-to-text losses. How would including the other loss such as image-to-prototype loss affect the detected conflicts and final retrieval performance? Could you provide a controlled comparison to assess the impact of this choice?
- The ablation results provide limited evidence for the effectiveness of MCGA. On RGBNT100, adding MCGA leaves all reported retrieval metrics unchanged. On RGBNT201, it improves mAP by only 0.3 percentage points, although Rank-1 increases by 1.6 points. Without repeated runs or results on additional datasets, it is unclear whether these gains are consistent and reproducible. Could the authors provide further evidence that MCGA offers a reliable benefit?
- On RGBNT201, comparing variants (c) and (d), adding MCGA improves Rank-1 by 1.6 percentage points, while mAP increases by only 0.3 points and Rank-5 and Rank-10 decrease slightly. I think it's weird. Could you explain this mixed pattern and report results over multiple runs to clarify whether the Rank-1 improvement is consistent?
I will improve the rating and confidence if the rebuttal provides clearer explanations and convincing supporting results.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive assessment. We address novelty, fine-grained evidence, presentation, and computational overhead below with new experiments; the corresponding revisions are marked in red in the revised PDF.
W1. "Insufficient novelty: it combines several established techniques."
We acknowledge that feature exchange, regularization, and gradient conflict mitigation have individually been studied, and we do not claim these are new primitives. TRIDA's contribution is their specific coordination within an established ICPL-ReID framework, rather than a newly designed backbone: (i) GRACE simultaneously permutes channel groups across RGB/NIR/TIR without dropping token positions (two groups remain modality-native at G=4), followed by discrepancy-conditioned enhancement with bounded adaptive residual scaling; (ii) GRASP softly penalizes group-wise deviations from a differentiable, sample-specific cross-modal center with warm-up, instead of enforcing identical modality representations; (iii) MCGA selectively arbitrates gradients on the shared enhancement parameters using cosine-thresholded, symmetric, order-independent corrections with severity-adaptive blending, retaining unprobed gradients and recovering the ordinary update when there is no conflict (Eq. (14)). These mechanisms address feature interaction, representation drift, and optimization conflicts at distinct stages.
W2. "Ablation studies are insufficient … figures are poorly presented; visualizations are largely qualitative."
We have added fine-grained analyses and improved the presentation:
W3. "What is MCGA's actual computational cost, and does TRIDA offer a practical efficiency advantage?"
We benchmarked matched MCGA OFF/ON configurations on RGBNT201 (single RTX 4090, batch size 64; identical GRACE/GRASP/parameters/optimization, MCGA being the only difference; 3 runs, 10 warm-up + 40 synchronized timed iterations each):
The overhead decomposes into 9.519 ms/iter for modality-wise gradient probing and 2.437 ms/iter for conflict arbitration. Both configurations contain 354.230M total and 49.036M trainable parameters, so MCGA adds no model parameters and no inference-time operations; TRIDA's inference cost equals the baseline plus GRACE alone. These measurements quantify training-step overhead (excluding data loading, prototype extraction, and evaluation). We do not claim a cross-method efficiency advantage based on these results; they show that the arbitration mechanism is lightweight relative to a training step.
We appreciate the reviewer's suggestions and have incorporated these substantiated analyses and clearer limitations into the revised manuscript.