- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses unreliable pseudo-labels, modality discrepancies, and the difficulty of learning identity-discriminative regions in unsupervised multi-modal re-identification. It proposes a Contrastive Label-aware Spatial-Frequency Learning framework. At the beginning of each epoch, adaptive spectral clustering and the SG-MDL criterion estimate the number of clusters and generate global pseudo-labels and cluster prototypes. During the epoch, pseudo-labels guide cross-modal contrastive learning, while pseudo-label confidence is used to select intra-modal negative pairs and improve identity discrimination. The label-aware spatial-frequency learning module also uses pseudo-labels and frequency cues to guide spatial discrimination. Experiments, ablation studies, and visualizations on datasets including RGBNT201 demonstrate the effectiveness and competitiveness of the method.
Critical strengths
- The experimental evaluation is thorough, covering multiple datasets and showing strong performance. The ablation studies also demonstrate the contributions of the individual modules.
- The framework is comprehensive, and the method’s formulas and mathematical rationale are clearly presented. The paper also includes attention visualizations, analyses of cluster-number changes and feature-distance distributions, runtime analysis, and anonymous GitHub code, which help readers understand and verify the method.
Critical weaknesses
The frequency-domain component in Section 3.5, “Label-aware SF Learning,” is not explained in sufficient detail. In particular, the paper does not clearly explain the rationale or provide enough formulas for how Haar wavelets and high-frequency subbands provide complementary texture cues.
Questions for authors
- The paper analyzes the sensitivity of some hyperparameters, but the choices of key parameters such as (q), (), and () are not sufficiently justified. Could the authors provide sensitivity analyses for these parameters?
- Could the authors provide more implementation details for the frequency-domain component, including the selection of wavelet subbands, the relevant equations, and the normalization method?
answer for reviewer tUvX
Thank you for your approval of the framework and experiment of our paper. Next, I will reply to your questions (the blue font in the updated pdf is our updated part):
Thank you for your question about sensitivity analysis of parameters.. For the choice of q, we found in the references that the author mentioned that the general choice of q would not exceed 10, so we only set the threshold to 5, and did not conduct sensitivity analysis. The sensitivity analysis was supplemented in the appendix. As a balance coefficient, \alpha is generally set to 1/2, and the sensitivity analysis is supplemented in the appendix. According to the spectrum constructed by the current features, the \beta is recalculated at the beginning of each round without being fixed, and the specific updating rules have been supplemented in the appendix.
Thanks to the reviewer for the details of frequency domain calculation. The specific implementation details have been supplemented in the appendix.