- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies how donor-atom information can guide pretrained diffusion docking models without retraining. The authors introduce CICG, which applies metal–donor distance corrections during the last two denoising steps of SurfDock. They compare historical donor identities with simpler nearest-donor selection strategies, as well as donor-aware reranking. The experiments show improved coordination-aware docking success, although the benefit of transferring exact historical donor identities over simpler alternatives remains uncertain.
Critical strengths
-
Incorporating metal coordination constraints into a frozen diffusion model is a useful idea. I like that the method does not require retraining and can operate directly on translation, rotation, and torsional coordinates. The comparisons are also reasonably well controlled, with matched sampling conditions and the same correction procedure across different donor-selection policies.
-
Historical guidance improves joint Top-1 success from 21.51% to 36.63% (Table 1), which is a meaningful improvement. I also appreciate the comparisons with nearest-donor selection and donor-aware reranking. The authors are fairly transparent about the limitations, including incorrect donor assignments, reduced ligand accuracy, and increased clashes. These analyses make the results more informative.
Critical weaknesses
-
My main concern is whether the complete historical donor set is actually necessary. Composition-matched Nearest-K already achieves 33.14% joint success, compared with 36.63% for historical guidance. The difference is only 3.49 percentage points, with a confidence interval that includes zero (Table 2). Even the count-only strategy recovers much of the improvement. Donor-aware reranking also improves success without modifying coordinates, suggesting that part of the gain comes from better pose selection. These are useful findings, but they make the specific contribution of complete historical donor identities less convincing. The paper demonstrates that donor information helps, but not clearly that transferring exact donor membership is substantially better than simpler alternatives. I would also like to see a comparison with a simple post-docking coordinate correction using the same donor information. This would help establish whether applying the correction during diffusion offers a real advantage.
-
The improvement in joint success is encouraging, but Table 5 shows some concerning trade-offs. Historical guidance increases the candidate clash rate from 16.83% to 27.22%, while geometry validity decreases from 83.17% to 72.78%. Ligand-only Top-1 success also drops from 106 to 101 out of 172. This is important because correct metal coordination alone does not guarantee a physically reasonable binding pose. The current correction mainly enforces metal–donor distances without explicitly considering receptor clashes, coordination angles, or ligand strain during optimization. The applicability of historical transfer is another limitation. Only 62 of the original 304 queries receive historical donor assignments, and the method requires highly similar receptor sites with available reference complexes. I am therefore not sure how much the reported improvement would help in practical docking campaigns involving new targets or ligands without suitable historical references.
Questions for authors
-
Could the authors compare CICG with a simpler post-docking correction using the same donor sets? Does intervention during diffusion provide an advantage over correcting completed poses?
-
Could the authors incorporate basic clash or ligand-strain penalties into the correction and evaluate whether the coordination improvement can be maintained without reducing overall pose quality?
-
Given the limited historical coverage, what is the expected improvement across the full original query set when queries without reliable donor assignments fall back to standard docking? How well would this approach generalize to less familiar protein families?
6 comments
Physical reliability and applicability
We also tested where donor-conditioned correction helps and where its present objective remains insufficient. The correction reduces metal–donor distance residuals, but its radial objective does not directly penalize receptor overlap or ligand strain. The physical and coverage studies make this distinction visible.
Physical-quality evidence (W2, Q2)
| Original 40-pose-bank measure | C0 | HCT |
|---|---|---|
| All-pose fatal clashes | 16.83% | 27.22% |
| All-pose protein-overlap compliance | 71.66% | 45.84% |
| Confidence-selected ligand success | 106/172 | 101/172 |
| Joint ∩ initial nine-check battery | 33/172 | 54/172 |
An overlap-acceptance gate increases HCT all-pose overlap compliance to 74.04%, but brings joint Top-1 back to 37/172 (from 63/172). This negative control identifies a real trade-off: simply rejecting overlapping correction steps can remove successful coordination fixes. (Appendix G.12.)
We then applied the same output-only 1.2-Å clash filter to C0 and HCT:
| Selected measure / 172 | C0 before → after | HCT before → after |
|---|---|---|
| Joint Top-1 | 37 → 38 | 63 → 64 |
| Fatal clashes | 11 → 4 | 22 → 4 |
| Nine-check pass, Q | 148 → 150 | 127 → 135 |
| Joint ∩ Q | 35 → 36 | 58 → 58 |
Under the pinned PoseBusters 0.6.3 environment, filtered HCT retains a +12.79-pp [5.48, 22.22] advantage over filtered C0 for joint∩Q; the HCT-versus-C0 Q-only result remains lower by −8.72 pp [−14.02, −4.12]. The filter changes only which saved pose is returned, and joint success already excludes fatal clashes. Its contribution is to reduce avoidable selected collisions without disturbing the corrected candidate bank. The initial checker run (33/54 joint∩Q) and the pinned run (35/58 before filtering) use different environments, which we report separately. Applying the filter without retuning to seeds 44/45 likewise reduces HCT selected clashes from 21 to 3. (see §5.5; Appendix G.3, Table 39; G.13, Table 54.)
Full-roster accounting and unseen families (W2, Q3)
| Measure | Result |
|---|---|
| Historical contract coverage in original roster | 62/304 (20.39%) |
| Covered 62 queries, C0 vs HCT, two seeds | 23/124 → 38/124 |
| Whole-roster effect with identical C0 fallback | +15/608 = +2.47 pp |
| Separate family/site-separated cohort: transferable contracts | 0/26 |
The +2.47-pp figure is accounting under the declared unchanged-C0 fallback, not a new 304-query docking run. The separately frozen 26-query cohort lacked suitable transferable historical references, so it tests the availability of HCT input rather than HCT accuracy on new families. When no eligible reference exists, the policy abstains and retains C0. The 86-query efficacy estimates apply to the HCT-covered, assessable group; we also report the 100-query failure-counted sensitivity for the reporting-stage restriction. (see §§4 and 6; Appendix A.2, B.1, E, G.12.)
Taken together, the experiments establish a specific role for CICG: given a supported donor assignment, it adds useful corrected poses to a frozen docker's candidate bank, with a benefit beyond donor-aware selection alone. Improving reference coverage and enforcing coordination, receptor compatibility and strain together are the next steps. We would welcome any further concern about the evidence or population definitions presented here.
Manuscript revision. We have incorporated the additional experiments and clarifications into the revised manuscript, while retaining the core method, evaluation cohort, and joint-success criterion. Key updates are highlighted in blue, with detailed results and protocols in Appendix G.
Follow-up on our response
Dear Reviewer Eax3,
Thank you again for your helpful comments. We would like to briefly follow up on our responses addressing the bank-by-selector controls, post-docking correction, physical-quality trade-offs, and transfer coverage.
When you have a chance, we would appreciate your feedback on whether any concerns remain about these analyses or their interpretation. We would be glad to provide further clarification or supporting details and respond promptly to any follow-up questions.
Thank you for taking the time to consider our responses.
Coordinate correction versus selection
Thank you for asking us to separate donor information, candidate generation, and final selection. We ran a bank-by-selector comparison that addresses this directly, using the same 86 assessable queries, two seeds and 33 structural groups.
What does changing the coordinate bank contribute? (W1)
With the selector held fixed, CICG-corrected coordinates increase selected joint success from 51/172 to 64/172: +7.56 percentage points (pp), paired 95% CI [1.11, 14.04]. There are 21 improved and eight worsened query–seed banks. This is our most direct evidence that the method contributes useful candidate geometry beyond donor-aware ranking. Selection of unmodified poses helps, but it does not recover all the successes obtained from the corrected bank. (see §5.4, Figure 2, Table 3.)
The same comparison also shows how the gain arises. Banks containing at least one joint-successful pose increase from 91 to 96, while cases where such a pose is available but not selected decrease from 40 to 32. These are related descriptive changes rather than separately identified causal contributions. Under the same selector, ligand-only success falls from 107/172 to 99/172 and selected fatal clashes increase from 12 to 21. A different radial/clash selector gives 48/172 for C0 and 38/172 for HCT, confirming that the bank effect depends on the selection rule. (Appendix B.9, Table 27; G.1, Table 37.)
How specific must the donor information be?
The HCT−composition increment is +3.49 pp [−0.42, 8.93] on SurfDock, +0.58 [−2.03, 3.52] on DiffDock-L, and +3.20 [−0.85, 9.15] across four SurfDock seeds. The extra gain from exact historical identity is therefore uncertain. The supported result is broader and useful: the same inference-time operator improves frozen docking with several donor-information policies, and its coordinate-bank contribution is measurable even when ranking is controlled. Historical references offer one practical source of a complete donor set; the interface can also work from donor count and composition when those quantities are available. (see §5.2, Table 2; Appendix G.7.)
Is correction during diffusion necessary? (Q1)
Interleaved−terminal is −1.16 pp [−3.19, 1.15] using the same donor sets and maximum correction budget. Correcting all 40 rather than only the original Top-1 adds +13.95 pp [6.35, 22.88], with 29 gains and five losses. Thus the correction is effective both inside and after sampling under these conditions, while full-bank processing and reselection matter substantially. (see §5.6; Appendix G.2, Table 38; G.9, Table 49.)