- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GuideDock, a geometry-guided diffusion framework for rigid protein-protein docking. It uses latent flow matching to generate inter-protein distance maps, which subsequently guide SE(3) pose diffusion through Feynman–Kac steering and gradient-based rigid-body updates. Experiments on DIPS-Het and DB5.5 demonstrate improvements over existing MSA-free neural docking methods.
Critical strengths
-
Well-motivated formulation: Using predicted distance maps as soft geometric constraints is a reasonable approach to improving the reliability of rigid-body pose generation.
-
Interesting integration of geometric guidance: Combining distance-based potentials with FK steering and force-based rigid-body updates provides a structured approach to guiding diffusion in SE(3).
-
Promising empirical improvements: GuideDock achieves better DockQ and RMSD than several MSA-free neural docking baselines, with relatively low reported inference latency.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited methodological novelty and insufficient justification for architectural complexity: The framework primarily integrates existing techniques, including latent flow matching, distance map, SE(3) diffusion, FK steering, and torque-based updates. While assembling these tools for rigid docking is sensible, the paper reads largely as an intricate combination of existing techniques without fundamental methodological novelty in diffusion theory or structural geometry. In addition, Table 6 compares the generative distance-map model with a simple MLP distance regressor and shows only a modest absolute DockQ improvement of about +0.03 on both DIPS-Het (0.24 → 0.27) and DB5.5 (0.06 → 0.09). This is a comparison of the distance-map generation module, not of the full GuideDock pipeline against a regressor, but it still raises a legitimate question: the paper needs to justify more convincingly why the complex latent flow matching / VAE pipeline is necessary relative to a stronger deterministic distance predictor.
-
The absolute docking accuracy remains low, limiting the demonstrated practical utility: On DB5.5, GuideDock achieves a mean DockQ of only 0.09 and a median of 0.05, both below the conventional acceptable-quality threshold of 0.23. Although the relative improvements over several MSA-free neural baselines are encouraging, their practical significance remains unclear without reporting the proportion of successfully docked complexes under standard CAPRI/DockQ thresholds. Evaluation on genuinely unbound protein conformations would further strengthen the applicability claims, since the current experiments use fixed conformations and do not test robustness to conformational change.
-
The inference-time efficiency claims lack sufficient computational accounting: Despite emphasizing single-pose prediction, GuideDock requires 100 latent flow matching steps, 50 pose diffusion steps, and four particles for FK steering. The reported runtime of approximately 7.5 seconds per complex lacks a component-wise breakdown, and it is unclear whether feature extraction and geometric preprocessing are included. More transparent profiling and comparisons under matched computational budgets are needed. Moreover, the runtime comparisons appear to use numbers taken from other papers, which may have been measured under different hardware, batch sizes, and preprocessing assumptions. Since high-throughput inference is a central motivation, the paper should provide transparent profiling and comparisons under matched computational budgets.
-
Missing baseline DFMDock (Chu L S, Sarma S, Xu D, et al. Unified sampling and ranking for protein docking with DFMDock[J]. Proteins: Structure, Function, and Bioinformatics, 2026.).
Questions for authors
See weakness
4 comments
Weakness 3: Runtime breakdown and profiling.
GuideDock returns one pose after 100 latent-flow steps, 50 pose-diffusion steps, and four-particle FK steering. We agree that these internal computations should be explicit when interpreting its runtime. To support this, we profiled the components of GuideDock more closely on RTX Pro 6000 GPUs since 3090 GPUs were unavailable in the given time. The following timings are means of three repeated measurements per complex, averaged over the ten complexes.
| GuideDock component | Mean time (s) |
|---|---|
| Cached feature collation and transfer | 0.0011 |
| Map conditioning, generation, and decoding | 0.7691 |
| Pose initialization | 0.0005 |
| Pose sampling, selection, and CPU transfer | 1.8951 |
| Independently measured total | 2.6668 |
The profile includes map generation, geometric guidance, and all four particles. Static sequence-embedding generation and model loading are excluded. Pose sampling accounts for approximately 71% of the measured time and map generation for 29%, identifying where the computational cost lies.
We also measured the baselines on the same GPU and complexes, using four internal particles or candidates per method and returning one selected pose.
| Method | Mean inference time (s) |
|---|---|
| Direct pose diffusion | 1.83 |
| EBMDock | 0.52 |
| DFMDock | 1.53 |
| GuideDock | 2.67 |
Guidance adds 0.840 s over the same pose model without guidance in this profile. These measurements make the accuracy–runtime tradeoff explicit: geometric guidance adds computational cost while retaining seconds-scale inference. For matched sampling budgets, please see our response to Reviewer EAbw under Weakness 3.
Weakness 4: DFMDock baseline results.
Thank you for identifying this baseline. We evaluated the released DFMDock model checkpoint on 100 DIPS-Het and 25 DB5.5 complexes, selecting its prediction by the lowest energy score. We use 40 denoising steps per their documented code config and 4 candidates per-target to ensure an at-parity sampling budget.
| Dataset | Method | DockQ | IRMSD (Å) | CRMSD (Å) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DIPS-Het | DFMDock | 0.08 / 0.03 / 0.13 | 15.52 / 14.04 / 9.02 | 13.89 / 12.95 / 8.68 |
| DIPS-Het | GuideDock | 0.27 / 0.16 / 0.28 | 8.95 / 6.68 / 7.71 | 8.17 / 5.94 / 7.29 |
| DB5.5 | DFMDock | 0.09 / 0.05 / 0.12 | 11.93 / 10.51 / 5.80 | 12.25 / 12.61 / 5.68 |
| DB5.5 | GuideDock | 0.09 / 0.05 / 0.10 | 11.40 / 10.74 / 5.15 | 11.46 / 11.52 / 4.98 |
On DIPS-Het, GuideDock's manuscript result achieves more than three times DFMDock's mean DockQ, alongside lower mean IRMSD and CRMSD. On DB5.5, the two methods have similar mean DockQ at the reported precision, while GuideDock has lower mean IRMSD and CRMSD. Thus, the added baseline supports a substantial docking-quality advantage on DIPS-Het and improved pose accuracy on both datasets. Our response to reviewer wJ6i, Question 1, additionally reports DFMDock in the expanded DIPS-Het evaluation.
Thank you for your clarifications. However, I remain somewhat conservative regarding the paper's novelty and overall contribution to the field. I will make my final recommendation after taking the other reviewers' comments and discussions into consideration.
Thank you for engaging during the discussion period. We respect your decision, and we are happy to answer any outstanding questions or concerns in the time remaining.
We thank the reviewer for the detailed feedback and questions and highlighting our integration of geometric guidance and the empirical improvements of our work. Please see our point-by-point response to each weakness below.
Weakness 1: Novelty, stronger deterministic baseline, and architecture justification.
Our contribution is a way to use predicted inter-protein geometry to guide rigid docking. The distance map supplies a global geometric target, the pose model searches over rigid placements of the supplied monomers, FK steering allocates particles toward promising poses, and the rigid-body updates refine their translation and rotation. Treating the map as a soft constraint allows the pose model to use informative distances even when the full predicted map cannot be realized exactly in three dimensions.
The generative map model is motivated by the ambiguity of inter-protein geometry. A deterministic predictor trained with squared error can average distinct plausible distance maps, whereas a generative predictor can represent their distribution. The benefit of sampling multiple distance maps is exhibited in Figure 7 of the paper, and this capability is not available to deterministic distance predictors. To test a stronger geometric predictor than the MLP baseline supplied, we trained a deterministic model with four invariant point attention layers, joint attention between the partners, and a direct distance-prediction head, all using the same sequence embeddings. Below are the results formatted as
mean / median / std.GuideDock's manuscript results have higher mean DockQ and lower mean IRMSD and CRMSD than the added IPA baseline on both datasets. These results support the generative map predictor against both simple and geometry-aware deterministic alternatives. Separately, holding the backbone and embeddings fixed, our guidance ablation increases DIPS-Het mean DockQ from 0.20 to 0.26, demonstrating the contribution of guidance during pose sampling. We emphasize that the main contribution of the work is not the specific architecture used to predict distance maps but the approach of using distance maps to guide pose diffusion.
Weakness 2: CAPRI categories and conformational change.
Thank you for this suggestion. The quality distribution makes the practical gain clearer than mean DockQ alone. Below we reproduce the CAPRI-style categories from our earlier evaluation; entries are percentages of predictions.
GuideDock increases the fraction of medium- or high-quality DIPS-Het poses from 16.42% to 29.61%. On DB5.5, the earlier evaluation yields acceptable poses in 12% of predictions, compared with none for EBMDock. These results show that the improvement includes a greater yield of useful poses, while the DB5.5 distribution identifies accurate interface recovery as a priority.
Regarding conformational change, the current evaluation uses bound monomer conformations and measures rigid docking. To accommodate substantial conformational changes, a future extension could update internal coordinates alongside rigid-body motion, with the distance map guiding both interface placement and conformational adjustment. For experimental results, please see our response to Reviewer EAbw under Weakness 7 where we report performance on rigid vs non-rigid complexes in DB5.5.We see a clear degradation in performance for the flexible complexes over the rigid-body complexes across the board given the scope of the method, although the gap in performance far from catastrophic. This is expected given that apo and holo structures often share high backbone similarity and often undergo only minor induced fit changes [1, 2].
[1] Clark et al. Inherent versus induced protein flexibility: Comparisons within and between apo and holo structures. PLoS Computational Biology 15 (2019).
[2] Ruvinsky et al. Side-Chain Conformational Changes upon Protein–Protein Association. Journal of Molecular Biology 408 (2011).