- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces PACT, a lightweight reward-steering method for fixed-backbone antibody design. PACT freezes the inverse-folding decoder and adds a shared amino-acid logit bias with 19 effective degrees of freedom, estimated from within-backbone reward differences without gradient-based training. The paper also analyzes why several tested full-parameter fine-tuning objectives fail to effectively re-rank candidates within the same backbone. Experiments on three antigens show improvements in computational interface reward and shape complementarity, with additional transfer experiments across antigens and inverse-folding decoders.
Critical strengths
- Simple and practical intervention. PACT is lightweight, requires no full-model optimization, and can be applied directly to frozen inverse-folding models.
- Interesting empirical observation. The paper provides evidence that the tested full-parameter fine-tuning methods do not effectively achieve within-backbone reward re-ranking, while a much simpler output-space intervention performs well on held-out backbones.
Critical weaknesses
- Limited methodological novelty. PACT is essentially a frozen decoder with a shared amino-acid logit bias, closely resembling a learned composition prior or simple logit adjustment. The coefficient estimator is also a straightforward association between residue identity and centered reward. Overall, the method feels more like an effective engineering trick than a new modeling or optimization framework.
- The technical contribution is relatively thin. In my view, the most interesting contribution is the empirical observation that simple low-dimensional steering can outperform some full-parameter fine-tuning setups, rather than the PACT algorithm itself. Once the extensive fine-tuning diagnostics are separated from the method, the core technical contribution is quite limited for an ICLR full paper.
- A crucial low-dimensional baseline is missing. A natural comparison would freeze the decoder and train exactly the same shared amino-acid output bias using gradient-based optimization. Without this baseline, it is unclear whether the improvement comes from the proposed estimator or simply from using a low-dimensional output-space parameterization. This is the most important missing control in my assessment.
- Part of the gain may reflect a generic composition effect. The side-chain volume prior performs similarly to PACT on HER2 and IL7R, with no clear advantage for the learned bias on these targets. This suggests that some of the improvement may arise from generic changes in residue size, interface area, or overall composition rather than learned target-specific preferences. This weakens the novelty claim further.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors compare PACT against a frozen decoder with the same shared output bias trained directly by gradient descent? This comparison would materially affect my assessment of whether the proposed estimator itself contributes beyond the low-dimensional parameterization.
- How do the authors interpret the fact that the side-chain volume prior is competitive with PACT on HER2 and IL7R? Can the authors provide evidence that the gains are not primarily explained by a generic composition or residue-size effect?
Dear Reviewer Qbfk, thank you for reviewing the paper and taking the time to consider our response and the additional experiments we conducted during the rebuttal period. Since the rebuttal deadline is approaching, we just wanted to let you know that if you have any remaining questions or concerns, we would be very happy to address them. If our response addressed your comments properly, we would greatly appreciate your consideration of a higher score. We appreciate your time and fully understand that you may need more time to review the results!