- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies how much directional information about excitation remains when a Hawkes process is observed through temporally aggregated event counts. Focusing on a stationary, mean-matched 2-variate Hawkes process, the authors derive an exact first-order directional score function for the multi-bin setting and show that the directional information per unit exposure decays cubically with the bin width under finite-mean kernels. When only a single bin is observed, the first-order directional information vanishes. Still, the authors identify a nonzero second-order tangent involving both excess dispersion and a mixed third-degree count moment, leading to a fourth-root local testing regime. They further establish locally efficient tests, study the effect of estimating the common event rate, and characterize which count summaries preserve the relevant directional information. Synthetic experiments examine the predicted local testing risks, the contribution of the mixed moment, calibrated directional reporting, and robustness under model misspecification.
Critical strengths
- The paper provides a technically substantial theoretical characterization of directional information in temporally aggregated Hawkes processes, including an exact first-order directional score and a cubic decay law for information under coarse temporal resolution.
- The single-bin analysis is particularly interesting: although first-order directional information vanishes, the paper identifies a nonzero second-order signal involving both dispersion and a mixed third-degree count moment. It derives the corresponding local testing limit and an attaining statistic.
- Extensive synthetic experiments support the theoretical results.
Critical weaknesses
-
The main weakness is the presentation. Several central concepts and notations, including the directional score, directional tangent, count law, the subscript, (the abbreviation of , , , and the equal-prior optimal testing risk, are introduced with little or no intuitive explanation. More importantly, the paper does not sufficiently articulate the practical or statistical significance of its main theoretical results. Key findings, such as the cubic decay of directional information and the local optimality of the score test, are stated formally, but their broader implications are only weakly discussed. The authors should explain more explicitly what these results enable us to do, what aspects of inference or data collection they can improve, and how they should influence the design of methods for aggregated event data. Because of the current presentation, even readers familiar with Hawkes processes may find the theoretical development unnecessarily difficult to follow. In its present form, the paper is accessible mainly to a relatively narrow audience already well versed in local asymptotic statistical theory. This is particularly unfortunate given that the underlying theoretical results appear to be quite interesting and potentially valuable.
-
The positioning with respect to prior work on directional inference from aggregated or discretized observations is incomplete. Prior studies, including (Santitissadeekorn et al., 2023/2025), have investigated network reconstruction from count data, while related work has also considered causal discovery under temporal aggregation. The authors should explain more explicitly how their local information analysis differs from these global identification, network-reconstruction, or parameter-estimation approaches. A more systematic comparison with closely related work is needed to make the precise novelty of the present contribution clearer. In addition, given the focus on binned Hawkes observations, it seems unusual not to refer to (Kirchner, 2016/2017) and clarify how the present analysis relates to that literature.
-
Although I do not regard this as a weakness that should materially lower the score, the theoretical and empirical scope is relatively narrow. The main theoretical results are developed for a stationary, mean-matched feed-forward family, and the empirical evaluation is entirely synthetic. I believe these restrictions should be stated more explicitly as limitations in the main text, together with a brief discussion of which aspects of the theory are expected to extend to more general Hawkes models and real-world data.
Questions for authors
None
2 comments
Thank you for the detailed response and additional experimental results. I appreciate the authors' efforts to address my concerns.
The explanations of the statistical implications of the theoretical results, particularly the cubic information decay and the role of the mixed third-degree moment, are convincing. The additional ablation study provides meaningful empirical support for the theory's practical relevance. I also find the clarification of the differences from prior work satisfactory.
However, my primary concern remains the manuscript's readability and accessibility, which the other reviewers have also identified as major weaknesses. While the response provides helpful clarifications, it is difficult to assess whether this concern has been adequately addressed without seeing how these explanations are integrated into the revised manuscript. In particular, the key concepts, notation, and practical implications should be clearly introduced and discussed in the main text.
Statistical implications, prior work, and presentation
Thank you for recognizing the technical contribution. We agree that its meaning and relation to earlier work should be clear before the theorem statements.
Writing its probability mass as pa±, the directional score is the difference of likelihood derivatives at zero excitation, D=∂alog(pa+/pa−)∣a=0+,J=E0D2. Thus “information” means the squared size of a specified local directional contrast. The “tangent” is its leading distributional term. RN∗ is the smallest average misclassification probability over all tests when the two orientations have equal prior probability. J abbreviates JΔ,T(h). These objects should be introduced together before the two regimes.
At one bin, the first-order directional signal vanishes, but dispersion and a mixed third-degree moment produce an attainable fourth-root experiment. The information split tells a representation designer what dispersion alone misses. At T=τ=1, the mixed term contributes 45.51%, 17.27%, and 4.96% of the second-order information at expected counts 0.25, 1, and 4. Appendix S identifies an added coordinate that preserves the efficient statistic exactly. This guides summary design without asserting neural efficiency.
We have now tested that connection with a matched single-bin learning ablation. Across six fixed-kernel binary settings, both linear and neural decoders receive the same development data and 20,000 independent held-out datasets per setting, with three training seeds. At ν=1,N=65536, the added coordinate reduces neural error from 18.15% to 16.82%, a paired reduction of 1.32 percentage points (SE 0.17). At ν=0.25, the corresponding reduction is 4.38 points (SE 0.24). These uncertainties are over test datasets, conditional on the fitted models. Linear decoding remains competitive: the result supports retaining the missing moment, not neural superiority.
Santitissadeekorn et al. (2023) reconstruct influence networks from counts using ensemble filtering. Santitissadeekorn, Short and Lloyd (2025) develop batch and sequential network reconstruction, including discrete-time Hawkes/Cox models. Their reconstruction procedures and our weak-excitation testing experiment answer different questions. We do not claim to introduce directional network inference from counts.
Gong et al. (2017) establish causal identifiability for temporally aggregated non-Gaussian VAR models. Fan, Gong and Zhang (2024) study when aggregation preserves or distorts causal relations in an i.i.d. setting. We should distinguish these identifiability questions from local statistical difficulty and should not equate predictive Hawkes direction with intervention-based causality. Koyama (2025) supplies the coarse-grained second-order modeling context. A dedicated comparison of observation models, targets, assumptions, and guarantees will clarify these distinctions.