- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes the unified probabilistic framework STCD‑Hawkes. It decomposes POI recommendation into two coupled generative processes: a time‑aware Hawkes process with rotation‑based adaptation mechanism is used to model continuous‑time intensity for "when to move"; a score‑based latent diffusion model generates spatial representations conditioned on the learned temporal intensity for "where to go". Furthermore, a disentangled causal Mixture‑of‑Experts (MoE) module with orthogonal regularization separates users’ intrinsic preferences from dynamic contextual sensitivities to achieve causal debiasing.
Critical strengths
It decomposes POI recommendation into two coupled sub‑processes: temporal intensity modeling and conditional spatial generation. The temporal module adopts a Hawkes process with rotation mechanism to model continuous and non‑uniform triggering intensity of user activities. The spatial module leverages score‑conditional diffusion to generate spatial representations instead of simple classification over fixed POI candidates. It explicitly addresses the distribution mismatch between temporal and spatial signals, and adapts to user trajectories of varying lengths.
Critical weaknesses
W1. The core innovations are limited, and the overall design resembles a composition of existing methods.
W2. Orthogonal regularization only imposes constraints in the representation space and achieves representational disentanglement rather than genuine causal intervention. Only counterfactual‑sensitivity heatmap analysis is provided, without intervention experiments (e.g., modifying contextual conditions and observing corresponding changes in recommendations). Thus, it cannot rigorously prove that proximity‑induced confounding effects have been fully eliminated.
W3. The selected baselines lack comparisons against existing diffusion‑based POI recommendation methods, such as Diff‑POI, Diff‑DGMN, UB‑Diff, DiffuRec, and PreferDiff.
Questions for authors
Q1. Spatial generation relies on the score‑based SDE diffusion model which requires iterative sampling. It incurs higher training overhead compared with pure Transformer‑based and graph‑based baselines. What is the actual training time of your model?
Q2. For real‑world online POI recommendation services, how do you balance the generation quality from diffusion and inference efficiency?
Q3. Orthogonal regularization in this work only yields approximate disentanglement within the feature space. Have you considered conducting real causal intervention experiments, for instance artificially modifying distance‑related context and checking whether user intrinsic preferences can still be preserved in recommendations, to further validate the effectiveness of your causal debiasing?
2 comments
Reply to Authors
Thank you for your rebuttal. My concerns still remain, as the core innovations are weak. Secondly, the author's response did not effectively address my Questions. I therefore maintain my score of 1.
W1. Thank you for your evaluation of our contribution. STCD-Hawkes is built on a principled coupling of continuous-time activity modeling, spatial score learning, and structured expert routing. Rather than a naive composition, these components interact through a common learned representation and are jointly optimized via Eq. (19). Table 3 evaluates their individual predictive contributions within this unified architecture.
W2 and Q3. We appreciate your insights on causal motivation. We agree with the reviewer that orthogonal regularization and counterfactual sensitivity analyses serve as structural inductive biases and local context-sensitivity diagnostics, rather than exhaustive causal intervention experiments. In the revised manuscript, we will moderate strong causal phrasing and explicitly clarify the scope of these diagnostics, keeping them distinct from module-level predictive comparisons.
W3. Thank you for the pointer to recent diffusion-based models. While these methods offer valuable perspectives, STCD-Hawkes is uniquely distinguished by its explicit event-intensity formulation combined with time-adapted, expert-based spatial conditioning. We will expand the Related Work section to thoroughly discuss and contextualize these baselines.
Q1 and Q2. Thank you for your questions regarding computational cost. Thanks to the closed-form VP-SDE transition kernel (Eq. 10), training does not require simulating intermediate forward diffusion states. For inference, we control computational overhead by setting the diffusion steps to T=10 (Appendix D.3), striking an optimal balance between generative fidelity and online efficiency. We will include a clear discussion on training and inference complexity in the revision.