- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper presents Kukulkan, a new approach to neural temporal point process modeling that builds on ideas from state-space architectures while keeping the interpretability of classical Hawkes processes. The main idea is to keep the excitation dynamics linear and additive, while allowing contextual information to modulate decay rates. Intuitively, Kukulkan can be viewed as a Hawkes process whose event contributions are filtered through a soft neural rejection step (although no actual rejection step is performed).
Critical strengths
- The overall idea is creative and certainly worth exploring.
- The connection between Hawkes processes and state-space models is interesting and useful.
- The findings on quadrature bias and the disagreement between stated and simulated branching ratios are interesting.
Critical weaknesses
- The biggest weakness is the presentation and the lack of narrative structure. The introduction becomes very technical too quickly, and the related work reads like a sequence of loosely connected references that are not properly contextualized. This makes it difficult to understand what is novel and what the main contribution is. There is too little motivation and explanation of why the many different design choices are made. Overall, the paper contains interesting ideas, but they are obscured by a very compressed style, weak transitions, and too little motivation for the individual design choices. In its current form, the manuscript is much harder to follow than necessary.
- EasyTPP seems to be the wrong primary benchmark because it mainly tests next-event likelihood and prediction on standard datasets, whereas Kukulkan’s central claim concerns whether a model learns meaningful and stable excitation dynamics over longer horizons.
- Given that interpretability is central, the evaluation should include qualitative examples showing that the learned excitation patterns are understandable and plausible.
Questions for authors
- Does EasyTPP actually test the property Kukulkan is designed to improve?
- Should the paper include long-horizon or free-running evaluation in the main results?
- Can the interpretability claim be supported without qualitative examples?
Enhanced readability, re-framed paper with no more architectural claim.
I totally agree with your criticism of the presentation. I rewrote the paper from the first page: it now asks one question, states three limitations of the likelihood in plain words in the introduction, and follows the same order in the method and the results. The related work has three paragraphs with one topic each.
On your questions:
The two findings you found interesting, the quadrature bias and the disagreement about the branching ratio, are now what the paper is about.