- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SmoothTPP, a neural temporal point process that models the conditional intensity function using non-negative B-spline coefficients predicted from event history. This approach enables analytical likelihood evaluation, flexible neural architectures, and efficient smoothness regularization. Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the SmoothTPP.
Critical strengths
The B-spline parameterization provides a simple and tractable way to model intensities with analytical integration.
Critical weaknesses
-
The spline construction is not fully specified, particularly the boundary knots and intensity behavior beyond the training range. Besides, the inter-arrival likelihood omits the terminal survival term. These details are important for reproducing the method and understanding the exact-likelihood formulation.
-
The experiments do not report variability across random seeds and omit comparisons with additional relevant TPP methods, such as ADD-THIN. The multivariate extension is not evaluated experimentally.
Questions for authors
-
How are spline boundary knots selected, and how are terminal censored intervals incorporated into the likelihood?
-
Event sequence modeling involves dependencies on past events. How does SmoothTPP implement parallel training while ensuring that each event’s intensity is conditioned only on its preceding history?
-
Do all models use the same conditional-median prediction protocol for MAE evaluation?
Response to Reviewer 8ktN
We thank the reviewer for the comments.
Responses to the comments:
We did not specify the behavior outside the spline domain because, in our experiments, no observed test inter-arrival times exceeded the maximum training inter-arrival time. Nevertheless, this may occur, so an explicit tail definition is necessary. Several solutions are possible: a simple choice is to keep the intensity constant beyond the spline domain, at its boundary value. Our boundary-knot construction is compatible with this extension: since we use cubic splines, each boundary knot has multiplicity four, ensuring that the intensity at the right endpoint equals the last spline coefficient.
Regarding the survival term, this can be incorporated into our model without any difficulty. However, to our knowledge, this is also omitted in EasyTPP, the framework used for our benchmarks. Moreover, the datasets used in the experiments provide only the observed event sequences, without information about the corresponding observation window.
We will add experiments with multiple random seeds, multivariate datasets, and ADD-THIN as an additional baseline.
Answers to the questions:
The boundary knots are currently placed at the endpoints of the domain, from zero to the maximum inter-arrival time observed in the training set. Since we use cubic splines in our experiments, we assign multiplicity four to each boundary knot.
As the datasets used provide only event sequences and not the total observation time, terminal censored intervals are currently not included, as is also the case in EasyTPP. It is also reasonable to expect these contributions to be negligible.
In SmoothTPP with a Transformer architecture, this is ensured by causal masked attention, which prevents each prediction from attending to future events.
Yes, all models use the conditional median for the MAE comparison. In SmoothTPP, it is computed analytically, whereas for the other models it is estimated empirically from samples generated via thinning.