- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TAFNet, a spiking framework for irregular multivariate time-series (IMTS) forecasting. Its main component is the Time-Adaptive Fractional LIF (TAF-LIF) neuron, which combines fractional-order membrane dynamics with actual inter-observation intervals. Specifically, TAF-LIF adopts a non-uniform L1 approximation of the Caputo derivative, such that historical membrane increments are weighted according to their actual temporal distances, and further adapts the membrane time factor according to the current inter-observation interval. Based on TAF-LIF, the proposed TAFNet combines an event-aligned spike encoder with multi-granularity temporal patching and frequency-guided fusion using non-uniform Fourier features. Experiments on HumanActivity, USHCN, PhysioNet, and MIMIC show competitive forecasting performance against both ANN and SNN baselines. The paper also provides ablations and controlled comparisons of TAF-LIF with vanilla LIF, f-LIF, and EA-LIF.
Critical strengths
1. The paper addresses a meaningful problem by extending fractional spiking dynamics to irregularly sampled time series.
Instead of treating irregular observations as uniformly spaced discrete steps, TAF-LIF explicitly incorporates actual temporal intervals and uses a non-uniform L1 approximation of the Caputo derivative. Consequently, historical membrane increments are weighted according to their physical temporal distances. I find this formulation well motivated for IMTS and technically reasonable.
2. The experimental evaluation is reasonably comprehensive and includes useful controlled neuron-level comparisons.
The paper evaluates four IMTS benchmarks and compares against both ANN and SNN forecasting methods. Importantly, Table 3 compares TAF-LIF with vanilla LIF, f-LIF, and EA-LIF within the same TAFNet backbone, while keeping the other architectural components and training settings unchanged. This provides a relatively focused evaluation of the proposed neuronal dynamics.
Critical weaknesses
1. The incremental contribution of TAF-LIF over the closely related f-LIF is not sufficiently isolated.
Both approaches employ fractional-order neuronal dynamics, while TAF-LIF appears to introduce two main modifications: (i) non-uniform timestamp-aware fractional weighting and (ii) an interval-adaptive membrane time factor . However, the current experiments do not disentangle the individual contributions of these two modifications. Therefore, although Table 3 shows that TAF-LIF performs better than f-LIF on average, it remains unclear which component is responsible for this improvement and whether both components are necessary. I consider this an important issue for assessing the methodological contribution beyond existing fractional spiking neurons.
2. The empirical advantage over f-LIF is relatively modest on several datasets, while the evidence supporting persistent fractional historical memory is limited.
For example, on MIMIC, the reported MSE changes only from for f-LIF to for TAF-LIF. More importantly, the final configuration uses on all four datasets, meaning that the fractional historical-memory term contains at most one preceding state increment. The paper further reports that increasing the memory length does not monotonically improve performance. These observations make it unclear whether the main empirical benefit comes from persistent fractional memory or primarily from better modeling of irregular physical time intervals.
Questions for authors
1. Can the authors disentangle the two main modifications over f-LIF?
In particular, I would like to understand the performance of: (a) fractional dynamics with the proposed non-uniform timestamp-aware weighting but a fixed membrane time factor, and (b) interval-adaptive without the proposed non-uniform fractional historical weighting. A controlled comparison among these variants, f-LIF, and the complete TAF-LIF would substantially clarify the source of the reported improvement.
2. Are the improvements of TAF-LIF over f-LIF statistically significant?
Some differences appear small relative to the reported standard deviations. For example, on MIMIC, the MSE is for f-LIF and for TAF-LIF. Since the experiments are conducted using five random seeds, paired per-seed results or an appropriate statistical test would help establish whether the proposed neuron provides a consistent improvement.
3. Given that is selected for all four datasets, how should the claimed role of fractional historical memory be interpreted?
With , the historical term contains at most one preceding state increment, and increasing does not consistently improve performance. Does this indicate that the primary benefit of TAF-LIF comes from modeling irregular physical time intervals rather than persistent or long-range fractional memory?
The above questions are central to my current assessment rather than suggestions for future work. In particular, convincing evidence that the timestamp-aware fractional formulation and interval adaptation provide complementary and consistent improvements over f-LIF would substantially strengthen the paper, and I would be open to raising my score accordingly.
Thanks for replying. I don't have additional concerns.