- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
In order to better leverage the sampling pattern information in patch-based IMTSF methods, the paper proposes MorITS, which contains a sampling-pattern-guided MoE patch encoder layer. Specifically, Gaussian basis functions are used to model morphology, explicitly encoding masks and timestamps to guide MoE routing. Comprehensive experiments demonstrate that MorITS is competitive against SOTA baselines.
Critical strengths
- Motivation is clear, closely correlated to IMTSF scenarios. The essence of "morphology" is actually sampling pattern, where different sampling rates within and among variables lead to varying observation densities and patterns.
- Comprehensive experiments. Although it is based on the existing code pipeline PyOmniTS to achieve such comparisons, it is not deniable that experiemental setups are sound.
Critical weaknesses
These are not critical weaknesses, but rather some suggestions for improvements:
- "Morphology" is not commonly seen in IMTSF task. Based on my understanding, it essentially refers to sampling pattern. Readers not familiar with IMTS may not be able to quickly understand the term, and the confusion may hinder the understanding of methodology.
- The experimental setups follow PyOmniTS, but its citation is missing. Again, some readers may not understand what PyOmniTS refers to.
Questions for authors
Fairly speaking, the methodology is not that surprising, and one question remains: Why MorITS chooses Gaussian basis functions to model morphology? Compared to other types of networks, is there anything special making it better suitted for such task? For example, TTCN is used in tPatchGNN to encode patches, so why not TTCN?
3 comments
Thanks for your explanations and experiments upon Gaussian basis. Since my score is already a positive one, I'll keep my score as it is.
Response to Reviewer HBsp's Follow-up
Thank you for your follow-up and positive assessment of our work. We appreciate your time and constructive suggestions. We will clarify the definition of observation morphology, add the PyOmniTS citation and repository link, and incorporate the additional encoder comparisons into the revised manuscript.
Thanking Reviewer HBsp and Welcoming Further Discussion
Thank you for your careful assessment and constructive suggestions, and for taking the time to read and consider our response. We hope our explanations of observation morphology, the source and role of PyOmniTS, and the rationale for Gaussian basis functions, along with comparisons against alternative encoders including TTCN, have addressed your concerns. Should any questions remain or further explanation be helpful, we would welcome your feedback whenever convenient. We appreciate your time and thoughtful consideration.