- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
In order to capture asynchronous variable dependencies and account for varying sampling densities, the paper proposes D2ARIF, trying to address the challenge using the density encoder and decay factor. Experiments demonstrate competitive performance against state-of-the-art baselines.
Critical strengths
- Motivation is clear and sound, and the manuscript is likely written by human.
Critical weaknesses
- While the motivation is clear, the proposed method is not that elegant: The decay approach for asynchronous variable dependency learning is an implicit modeling rather than direct message passing among observations, and the density-aware module fuses its results with the delay-aware one only via concatenation+MLP (only realize 1+1=2 instead of 1+1>2). Even though the density-aware module is designed to be plug-and-play, it can be integrated with other modules in a more complementary way.
- No source code available during the review stage, and the experimental setting setup is vague, making the results less convincing. The experiment seem to be based on code pipeline PyOmniTS, but there's no clear explanation or citation. Also, using to demenstrate benchmark results indicates the performance gain of the proposed method is marginal over baselines.
- The manuscript is not carefully examed: No citation for the four datasets; Inconsistent use of "Density-Aware Module" and "DensAM"; Typos like "moudel".
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.
2 comments
Thanks for your explanations. The primary weakness of the paper is still the novelty part. Bringing your insights into paper makes it an appealing one, but unfortunately there seems to lack such highlights in this manuscript. Therefore, I would still keep my score as it is.
Response to Reviewer 49iU-W1/W2/W3
Weakness 1
Graph-based methods such as ASTGI [1] explicitly select interaction partners through kNN-based sparse observation-level connections. If a relevant observation is excluded from the selected neighborhood, its interaction cannot be captured through a direct message passing edge. In contrast, D²ARIF allows each target variable to retrieve information from all previously observed source-variable memories without preselecting neighbors or constructing edges.
To examine whether the Delay-Aware and Density-Aware Modules could be coupled more tightly, we evaluated three variants in which density information directly modulates memory updates. Density-modulated writing: after layer normalization and a linear projection, the density representation is added to the input of the sigmoid write gate in Eq. (14) to control the strength of the current observation’s memory update. Density-modulated decay: the corresponding projection is added to the input of the softplus function governing the decay rate in Eq. (12) to modulate the retention of historical information. Joint density modulation of writing and decay: both modifications are applied simultaneously. These results support concatenation followed by an MLP as sufficient to combine the modules’ complementary signals on the benchmarks.
Each cell reports MSE / MAE in units of 10−2.
[1] Liu, X., et al. ASTGI: Adaptive Spatio-Temporal Graph Interactions for Irregular Multivariate Time Series Forecasting. ICLR, 2026.
Weakness 2
Thank you for raising this issue. Our implementation builds on the official TFMixer repository, which we cited in the manuscript. Since TFMixer was developed on top of PyOmniTS, our implementation also indirectly depends on PyOmniTS. We inadvertently omitted a separate citation to PyOmniTS. Our code is available for review in the https://anonymous.4open.science/r/D2ARIF-FCC3/. Upon acceptance, we will release it publicly and submit it to the PyOmniTS project. We will add this citation in the revision and provide more detailed experimental settings below.
Appendix A.4 reports the hardware and main training settings (AdamW, learning rate 10−3, weight decay 0.01, up to 200 epochs). Appendices A.1–A.4 describe synthetic data generation, splitting, normalization, and validation-based selection.
For the real-world experiments, we follow TFMixer’s preprocessing and evaluation. We reserve 10% of records for testing and split the remainder 90/10 for training and validation (approximately 81% / 9% / 10% overall). We split HumanActivity records before constructing windows. All methods use the same splits, forecasting targets, and evaluation protocol. We select checkpoints by validation MAE and compute test MSE and MAE only on observed future targets, excluding missing and padded positions. Reproduced and additional experiments report means and standard deviations across seeds 2024, 2025, and 2026.
The ×10−2 display scale preserves relative differences and the resulting comparisons between methods. For example, in Table 1, the USHCN MSE decreases from 15.18 to 14.15, corresponding to a relative improvement of 6.79%. Such relative comparisons are invariant to the display scale.
Weakness 3
We thank the reviewer for pointing out these specific issues. We will cite the original sources for all four datasets. Regarding the abbreviation DensAM, the caption of Table 3 already states that "DensAM denotes the Density-Aware Module." We used this abbreviation only to avoid an overly long table entry. In the revised manuscript, we will consistently use Density-Aware Module instead of the abbreviation. And we have also carefully proofread the manuscript and corrected spelling mistakes, including “moudel,” as well as other grammatical issues.