- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
this work studies how to combine two types of perturbation experiments to tell which gene regulates which ( does gene A control B, or B control A?). The motivation is that exchange-invariant evidence has no direction on its own, and can determine or flip how another directional signal is interpreted; so scoring the two data sources separately and adding them up fails, thus we must model them jointly. The paper prove a theoretical bound for this limitation, propose a simple product-kernel method to combine the two sources, and test it on simulations and two small yeast datasets.
Critical strengths
the authors start from exchange-invariant evidence has no directional sign on its own yet can change how another signal is read, and combining channel-specific and joint product kernels, they provide sufficient theoretical analysis (honestly, hard for me to validate its correctness) and a sharp bound (theorem 1)
Critical weaknesses
-
my main concern is the poor readbility, really hard to understand; such as in the title / intro, the author does not introduce background about bioinformatics. only after picking up few words in related works or experiment so that I figure out what domain and context this paper is actually applied to.
-
entire intro section without any reference.
-
lots of non-standard, some details don't make sense such as the abstract reports hyper-precise numbers down to three decimal places (e.g., 9.534% and 16.361%);
-
weird statement such as line 451 “V's observed F increment”.
-
the paper dumps dense, unmotivated equations (eg line 347), also lots of notion do not have explanations. such as Eq.1 M_A.
-
figure 1 might be ai-generated with crop-outs and awkward spacing
-
incremental method: PaD sound like a standard kernel ridge regression with a mixture of linear and ref product kernels.
-
the evaluation jonika dataset has only 21 positive relations; which is no convincing and hard to prove the generalizes of method.
Questions for authors
please refer to the weakness.
also the main body constantly points to supp sections and tables (eg S1–S13, Table S26); pls concretely indicate appendix when referring.