- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes KnoGML for battery fault diagnosis from fragmented, variable-length time series. It combines synchronized multivariate plots with phase-dependent diagnostic priors and adapts a pretrained multimodal model using LoRA and a classification head to provide fixed-label outputs without free-form generation. On the semi-synthetic CH-BatteryGen benchmark, it achieves Macro-F1 scores of 90.24 and 87.61 percent on LFP and NCM, respectively. Prompt and component ablations assess the complete design’s contributions.
Critical strengths
-
KnoGML renders variable-length multivariate segments as synchronized plots, providing a common input format that covers the recorded interval and supports temporal comparisons across battery signals.
-
Phase-dependent diagnostic priors connect cross-variable symptoms with fault descriptions, enabling a pretrained multimodal model to incorporate battery knowledge into classification through LoRA adaptation.
Critical weaknesses
-
The source of the image-free performance is unclear. Table 4 reports Macro-F1 scores of 81.61%/79.84% on LFP/NCM without images, while Section 3.2 includes vehicle IDs and operating status in the prompt. Please clarify which inputs remain and report results without vehicle IDs to explain what drives these scores.
-
Please report the classification results of the original Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct model without fine-tuning, using the same images, contextual information, and complete prompt in Table 7.
3.The paper has clear practical value, but its methodological novelty mainly lies in combining existing components. Time-series visualization, diagnostic prompts, LoRA, and classification heads all build on established techniques, and the paper does not clearly explain what new methodological contribution their combination provides.
Questions for authors
-
Which inputs remain in the image-free variant in Table 4, how is the operating-status description generated, and how does performance change when vehicle IDs are removed?
-
Could you report the classification results of the original Qwen2.5-VL-7B-Instruct without fine-tuning, using the same images, contextual information, and complete prompt in Table 7?
-
Finally, what is the main methodological contribution beyond combining time-series visualization, diagnostic prompts, LoRA, and a classification head, and which experiments demonstrate its benefit?