- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a domain-knowledge guided fusion framework for point-wise recognition of four ELM-related plasma states on the EAST tokamak. It extracts domain-specific physical evidence, activates prototype rules, encodes knowledge graph, and retrieves historical cases. And then, it integrates these knowledge streams with replaceable temporal backbones via reliability-aware future-level enhancement and gated decision-level correction with a minority-class protection safeguard.
Critical strengths
S1. The model incorporates prior agreement and reliability scoring to mitigate over-correction and rule propagation errors. It also introduces a minority protection mechanism to reduce the risk of rare classes being overwhelmed by collaborative updates.
S2. The paper provides fine-grained ablation studies and sensitivity analyses across backbones and individual knowledge components.
Critical weaknesses
W1. The model combines handcrafted rules, a fixed graph, historical cases, multiple gates, safeguards, and auxiliary losses. But it lacks capacity-matched simpler baselines. MLP/ random-graph controls, rule-perturbation tests, or cross-condition evaluation are needed to justify its complexity, robustness and portability.
W2. The model is evaluated under overlapping windows which may leave the statistical and event-level interpretation incomplete. Predictions associated with overlapping windows are temporally dependent, and the reported pooled metrics treat time points observed in different window contexts as separate evaluation instances.
Questions for authors
Q1. How were the physical thresholds, prototype coefficients, graph-relation weights, and the 100 knowledge-construction discharges selected (e.g., from physical priors, training-set statistics, or validation performance)? Please clarify whether any of these choices were tuned on the validation set and confirm that test results were never consulted.
Q2. Could authors clarify the exact implementations of w/o Graph and w/o Reliability in Table 3 (e.g., which inputs and modules are retained or removed, whether model capacity changes, and whether each variant is independently tuned?).
Q3. How were the safeguard parameters (τ,m) selected? How frequently is the safeguard triggered, and what are its class-wise effects on precisions and recall for both minority and majority classes compared with the safeguard-disabled variant?
Please Respond to the Authors’ Rebuttal
Dear Reviewers,
We are now roughly halfway through the Author–Reviewer Discussion period (which runs through 18 November). The authors have submitted their response and, in some cases, a revised manuscript.
Could you please take a moment to:
Even if your evaluation remains unchanged, a short reply confirming your final position is very helpful, as it allows me to track each reviewer’s stance and write an accurate meta-review.
If you are unable to participate further, please let me know as soon as possible.
Thank you for your time and careful reviewing.
Best regards,
Area Chair, ICLR 2027