- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
In this paper, the authors introduce a solution for the cross-domain bearing fault diagnosis under class imbalance. They introduce two modules. SDDA is proposed to separate adaptation features from those of classification via orthogonality and adversarial alignment constraints. To improve the supervision on minority class, they then introduce CCPC to combine the source-prior-based prediction correction, classifier-prototype agreement and within-class pseudo-label selection. The empirical evaluation is conducted on 6 load-transfer tasks from the CWRU dataset with a manually set class-imbalance ratio.
Critical strengths
-
The proposed class-aware pseudo-label selection is interesting. Using a classifier-prototype agreement with within-class ranking for accepting minority-class samples is a reasonable mechanism to handle class-imbalance problem.
-
The authors introduce a manually setting for developing class imbalance problem using the bearing fault diagnosis benchmark dataset (CWRU).
-
It is also interesting that they chronologically split the raw vibration sequences before making windows, which reduces the leakage risk caused by randomly splitting from overlapping windows.
Critical weaknesses
-
My key concern is formulation of the problem and the limited contributions. The proposed components are all generic for class imbalanced domain adaptation problem, without any specific component designed for bear fault signals. The class imbalance problem is a well-studied problem in the domain adaptation field. Thus, it is important to also conduct evaluation on the benchmark datasets for class imbalanced domain adaptation. At least, it is expected to present results Office-Home RS-UT and imbalanced DomainNet during rebuttal. Meanwhile, the latest baselines (at least after 2025) should be included as baselines for comparisons.
-
A followup concern is the novelty and contribution of the proposed work. The stated challenges, including domain shift, head-class bias and unreliable minority-class pseudo-labels, are all well-studied problems in domain adaptation. The proposed method likewise combine standard feature separation, confidence weighting, prior correction and class-aware self-training, without exploring the characteristics that are unique for bearing fault signals.
-
The authors manually choose a 40:20:10:4:8:1 class distribution on CWRU without any statistical significance analysis or concrete evidence to support this ordering. Normal-versus-fault imbalance does not justify the assumed long tail across fault types and severities. Moreover, vibration-window counts do not represent independent fault occurrences.
-
The implementation details are missing. The reported results lack statistical significance. I am also wondering the motivation of using the unusually short 20-point windows (approximately 1.67 ms). Please provide justification and sensitivity analysis for this window size.
-
The overview figure (Figure 2) is too unprofessional. Please consider re-draw Figure 2 with a better design.
Questions for authors
See my concerns in Critical Weaknesses.
3 comments
Response 2
- Implementation details, statistical reliability, and window length:
We have expanded Appendices B and G to provide detailed information on data partitioning, network configuration, optimization settings, and hyperparameters. Appendix G.2 also presents a sensitivity analysis of four key SDDA-CCPC hyperparameters. For statistical reliability, Table 3 now reports the mean and standard deviation across five independent random seeds (42–46) on all six CWRU transfer tasks. SDDA-CCPC achieves an overall Macro-F1 of 0.9206 ± 0.0027. Appendix G.3 (Tables 16–17) provides the complete seed-wise results and additional statistics for the extreme tail class. The CWRU experiments use a fixed 20-point input window, corresponding to approximately 1.67 ms at 12 kHz. This configuration supports classification through learned local vibration patterns. Appendix B.1 and B.5 provide the chronological data partition procedure, input tensor dimensions, and feature extraction details, including the raw-waveform, local morphological, and FFT-based circular autocorrelation representations.
- Presentation of Figure 2:
We have redesigned Figure 2 to provide a clearer representation of the SDDA-CCPC framework. The revised illustration distinguishes the SDDA and CCPC components and explicitly depicts source prototype memory, classifier–prototype agreement, and progressive within-class reliability ranking. The information flow and module relationships have also been refined to improve readability and highlight the complementary functions of the two proposed mechanisms.
Thanks the authors for the detailed response. Most of my concerns are properly addressed. I am happy to maintain my positive rating.
Response
We thank the reviewer for the detailed comments on the methodological contributions, experimental design, and presentation. We have strengthened the evaluation, clarified the experimental protocol, expanded the implementation details, and revised the framework illustration. Our responses are provided below.
To extend the evaluation beyond CWRU while retaining the vibration-based fault-diagnosis setting, we have added experiments on HUST. The two datasets differ in operating conditions, fault categories, sampling frequencies, window lengths, and class-imbalance configurations. As reported in Appendix F, SDDA-CCPC achieves the highest six-task average Macro-F1 of 0.9343, Accuracy of 0.9467, and Macro-Recall of 0.9511 among the evaluated methods. We have also incorporated two recent methods, CIDSAN (2025) and DMTVCD (2026), into the baseline comparisons. These additions extend the empirical evaluation across two bearing datasets and provide comparisons with recent approaches to class-imbalanced cross-condition fault diagnosis.
The methodological design of SDDA-CCPC is closely related to the characteristics of vibration-based bearing diagnosis. Changes in operating loads can alter vibration responses, while different fault locations and defect sizes produce distinguishable local signal patterns. The challenge is therefore to preserve fault-relevant information during cross-condition adaptation while maintaining reliable recognition of sparsely represented fault categories. These considerations are reflected in two aspects of our design. First, the input representation incorporates raw-waveform, local morphological, and FFT-based circular autocorrelation features to characterize local vibration patterns. Building on these representations, SDDA jointly controls the feature space subjected to domain alignment and the contribution of individual samples, reducing the influence of condition-dependent variations on fault discrimination. Second, CCPC addresses the difficulty of identifying reliable target samples across fault locations and severities with highly unequal sample frequencies. Its calibration, prototype verification, and within-class selection form a dependent process that controls pseudo-label reliability and reduces head-class dominance during target supervision. The contribution thus lies in translating these diagnostic challenges into specific representation-alignment and target-supervision mechanisms, connecting vibration-signal characteristics with reliability-aware cross-condition adaptation.
We construct the 40:20:10:4:8:1 class distribution on CWRU to establish a controlled evaluation setting that examines cross-condition adaptation under multiple levels of sample scarcity. The design goes beyond a simple Normal-versus-Fault imbalance. It includes a dominant Normal class, several moderately represented fault classes, a moderately under-represented 14 mil outer-race fault, and an extremely under-represented 21 mil inner-race fault. This arrangement allows us to evaluate fault recognition across different fault types, defect sizes, and degrees of class imbalance, particularly whether minority classes remain distinguishable under operating-condition shifts. Importantly, the same class proportions are maintained across all four operating conditions. This keeps the imposed imbalance configuration consistent across transfer tasks, allowing performance differences to be examined under different operating-condition shifts. The specific allocation defines experimental sampling proportions rather than physical fault occurrence frequencies. The reported counts represent sampled vibration windows, not independent fault events. We have clarified this construction in Appendix B.2. Additionally, the HUST experiments in Appendix F employ a different 10:1 imbalance configuration, extending the evaluation to another class-distribution setting.