- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes ProtoTail for long-tailed fine-grained GCD, combining prototype-guided representations and pseudo-label selection. However, limited novelty and poor presentation undermine its contributions.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses the practical challenge of long-tailed fine-grained GCD and reports improvements on CUB and Stanford Cars.
Critical weaknesses
- Poor presentation and figure quality. Figure 1 is excessively dense, with extremely small text and poorly organized modules.
- The methodology relies heavily on generic prototype learning, gating, and pseudo-label filtering. It does not adequately explain how these mechanisms address the distinctive challenges of long-tailed fine-grained category discovery beyond existing part-based approaches.
- The long-tailed experiments cover only CUB and Stanford Cars with a single imbalance ratio of 10. Comparisons against recent long-tailed GCD methods are insufficient, and the balanced results do not outperform the strongest competitor in average accuracy.
Questions for authors
see weaknesses
Responses to Reviewer 8S6u
We thank the reviewer for the feedback.
W1: Presentation and Figure 1. We agree that Figure 1 is too dense. We will redesign it as a simplified vector diagram with two clearly separated modules, larger text, and notation consistent with Section 3.
W2: Addressing long-tailed fine-grained GCD specifically. The specific difficulty we target is that fine-grained discrimination depends on category-specific local evidence, and under a long tail that evidence is estimated from very different numbers of samples. Existing part-based GCD methods give every category the same local flexibility. ProtoTail instead constrains how many local parts each category can effectively use (gate mass κ_c) according to its estimated support, so tail categories do not overfit weakly supported cues. The effect appears where it is designed to act: adding the tail-aware term to the full model raises K-Few from 68.90% to 75.52% on CUB and U-Few from 52.00% to 61.36% on Stanford Cars (Table 2). The same trend holds on CIFAR100-LT (U-Few 60.20 → 82.20) and on Herbarium 2019 (K-Few +3.98). A second point specific to this setting is that pseudo-label selection alone hurts a long-tailed base model, and becomes useful only together with the support-aware representation (Table 1).
W3: Long-tailed evaluation and balanced comparison. We extended the evaluation in two ways: stronger imbalance on CIFAR100-LT (IR=20/50; All +3.92 / +4.05, Table 3) and the naturally long-tailed Herbarium 2019 (All 40.25 → 44.50, Table 4). Our base method in all long-tailed experiments, BaCon, is itself a long-tailed GCD method. We agree that ProtoTail is not the best on average balanced accuracy: SEAL reaches 76.3 vs. our 76.1 (Table 5), and PartCo and EAGC report larger gains on some datasets (Table 8). We state this explicitly. Our main target is the long-tailed regime, where the method gives its clearest benefits on low-frequency categories.