- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GLoRe, a bidirectional global-to-local reranking framework for Generalized Category Discovery (GCD). The method employs cross-attention to capture relationships between global representations and local visual features, aiming to improve the quality of retrieved neighbors. It also incorporates a momentum encoder and KoLeo regularization to enhance representation learning. The experiments show the effectiveness of their proposed method.
Critical strengths
The paper is well-structured and clearly presents its motivation and methodology. It also provides relatively detailed ablation studies, including analyses of different architectural designs, hyperparameter sensitivity,and retrieval quality.
Critical weaknesses
- Missing important baseline. The experimental comparisons omit several important recent GCD methods, particularly GET (CVPR 2025) and TAR (CVPR 2026). Notably, the reported results do not consistently outperform these methods. For example, GET and TAR achieve 77.0% and 78.4% on CUB, respectively, compared with 75.6% for GLoRe under its DINOv1 setting. Although these methods employ different pretrained backbones, their omission raises concerns about the completeness and fairness of the experimental evaluation. The authors should include these representative baselines, clarify the differences in experimental settings, and provide stronger evidence to support their state-of-the-art claims.
[1] Wang, E., Peng, Z., Xie, Z., Yang, F., Liu, X., & Cheng, M.-M. (2025). GET: Unlocking the Multi-modal Potential of CLIP for Generalized Category Discovery. Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR), 20296–20306. [2] Yang, X., Zhang, Y., Mi, S., & Wei, X.-S. (2026). TAR: Token-Aware Refinement for Fine-grained Generalized Category Discovery. Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR), 31995–32004.
- Limited Novelty and Incremental Contribution. The proposed method is largely an incremental extension of CMS, combining existing techniques such as cross-attention, momentum encoding, and KoLeo regularization, with limited methodological novelty.
Questions for authors
Could the authors explain why important recent GCD baselines are omitted from the experimental comparisons?
Rebuttal by Authors for R3 (#ZZX8)
We sincerely thank R3 (#ZZX8) for the thoughtful feedback and for highlighting relevant recent work. Below, we clarify the differences in experimental settings and further explain the methodological contribution of GLoRe.
R3.1 – Comparison with GET and TAR
Response: We thank the reviewer for pointing us to these methods. We did not include GET and the GET-based TAR configuration originally because they train with text, while the methods in our original tables are vision-only. We have now added TAR to Tables 1–2.
GLoRe uses DINO-pretrained visual features throughout. GET [m] builds on CLIP and uses both visual and text representations during training, through a Text Embedding Synthesizer and a dual-branch architecture. Both the pretrained representation and the information available during training therefore differ, so the gap on CUB does not by itself isolate which discovery mechanism is more effective.
We note that TAR is evaluated on two base methods. In Table 1 of Yang et al. (2026) [e], 78.4% on CUB corresponds to TAR(GET), while the vision-only MOS+TAR configuration reaches 70.6%. The relevant comparisons are included in Tables 1–2.
In the vision-only DINOv1 setting, GLoRe significantly exceeds MOS+TAR on all three datasets (Table 1). With a stronger vision-only backbone (DINOv2, Table 8), GLoRe exceeds GET+TAR on all three datasets without using text. For reference, on CUB, GLoRe with DINOv2 achieves 83.7%, compared to 78.4% for the TAR(GET) combination [e].
R3.2 – Methodological novelty and relation to CMS
Response: We acknowledge that GLoRe builds upon CMS and incorporates established components, including cross-attention, momentum encoding, and KoLeo regularization. However, we respectfully disagree that the proposed contribution is merely an incremental combination of these techniques.
The central contribution of GLoRe is the introduction of learned, pair-dependent neighbor relevance estimation into retrieval-based GCD. While CMS relies on global embedding similarity to select neighbors for mean-shift representation learning, GLoRe investigates whether this selection can be improved by exploiting the relationship between global image representations and local patch-level information. This distinction is particularly important for fine-grained categories, where visually similar images may belong to different classes due to subtle local differences.
Our bidirectional reranker addresses this limitation by conditioning each image's local representations on the global descriptor of the other image, enabling complementary visual evidence to influence neighbor selection. Importantly, these comparisons are learned through category-agnostic pairwise supervision and applied to both known and novel categories. The resulting neighbor selection directly affects the mean-shifted representations used for contrastive learning, rather than serving merely as a retrieval post-processing operation.
The experimental evidence supports the relevance of this contribution. Table 12 demonstrates the importance of bidirectional comparison, while Figure 2 (Appendix C) shows improvements in retrieval precision on novel categories of +8.99 and +11.40 percentage points on CUB and Stanford Cars, respectively, despite the absence of direct reranker supervision for these categories.
Full references for [e, m] appear in our General Response.