- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes Geo3D for point-cloud generalized category discovery, combining geometric neighborhood refinement with memory-guided category assignment and known-class anchoring.
Critical strengths
First, Geo3D achieves the highest overall and novel-class accuracy across three benchmarks, improving novel-class accuracy over the strongest competitors by 5.69–7.00%. Second, results with two backbones and multiple random seeds strengthen the empirical evidence beyond a single configuration.
Critical weaknesses
(1) In Table 11, adding MGCA reduces overall accuracy on all three datasets before KnownEx and EMA are introduced. The full ScanObjectNN configuration also adds dataset-specific gates. Although leave-one-out ablations are provided, a precise baseline definition and gate-controlled comparisons are needed to clarify these interactions. (2) Table 2 clusters the mixed known–novel pool into only the number of novel categories. Consequently, low novel coverage may partly reflect the restricted cluster budget. Repeating the diagnostic with all clusters would better establish its relevance to the evaluation setting.
Questions for authors
Please consider my two main concerns: (1) Does Geo3D also outperform the strongest baselines in novel-class macro accuracy? On ShapeNetCore, its 69.98% micro accuracy contrasts with 44.73% macro accuracy, leaving improvements in rare-category discovery unclear. (2) What is the end-to-end training cost, including memory refresh, frozen-reference extraction, and prototype updates, which are excluded from the reported forward FLOPs?
3 comments
Review
Thank authors for your feedback. Some of my concerns are addressed, so I would like to raise my score.
Response to Reviewer wqxn
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the thoughtful reassessment and for raising the score. We greatly appreciate your time, constructive feedback, and recognition of our efforts to address the concerns.
Response to Reviewer wqxn
Thank you. Dataset order: MN=ModelNet40, Scan=ScanObjectNN, Shape=ShapeNetCore.
◆ Q1: Does novel macro accuracy support gains over baselines and rare classes on Shape?
A1: Supplement: Ward with K=40/15/55 and one global Hungarian mapping shared by All/Old/New/macro. Main-table predictions remain native.
Table R1a: Novel-class macro accuracy (%), Ward.
Geo3D leads listed methods by 0.45/7.14/0.27 points over SelEx/LPS/ProtoGCD, respectively. Gains over Baseline are 9.30/10.64/2.03 points; Shape also gains 4.23 over frozen Uni3D. Shape's 69.98% micro weights samples equally; 44.73% macro averages per-class accuracy, equally weighting rare classes and supporting better average novel-class recognition. Appendix L (Table 23) is updated in purple.
◆ Q2: What are training time/peak GPU memory, including refresh, reference inference and prototype updates?
A2: All methods use Uni3D, 1,024 points; timing uses one RTX 4090, batch size 16 and native training/evaluation procedures. Geo3D includes memory refresh, reference-feature extraction, geometry/target construction, parameter updates, evaluation and checkpoint saving.
Table R2a: Trainable parameters (M) / single-object forward FLOPs (G).
Table R2b: Measured minutes per epoch.
Geo3D: 100-epoch times 5.65/6.52/20.75 hours; per-epoch peak allocated GPU tensor memory is 3.84/3.88/4.46 GiB. It improves novel discovery with 26.4%–30.4% fewer trainable parameters, comparable forward computation and lower per-epoch time than ProtoGCD/SimGCD on all datasets. Appendix B.4, Tables 8(a)/(b), adds costs/conditions in dark green, shared by both reviewers.
◆ Q3: Why the Table 11 drop at +MGCA? What are Baseline and Scan-specific settings?
A3: Baseline: Uni3D-B, contrastive objectives, prototype supervision, global/local representations, neighborhood consensus; 3DGR/MGCA/KnownEx/EMA and Scan-specific settings are off. Table 11 adds modules successively; space splitting/gradient projection start at +MGCA (§3.5). Scan Full adds robust geometry processing/dynamic reliability gating, separate from all datasets’ robust pair-scoring descriptor.
Table 3 removes MGCA within Full; both Scan configurations retain robust geometry and gating.
Table R3a: MGCA removal, All/Old/New (%).
Full gains 0.56/1.18/1.78 All and 0.32/0.18/7.79 New points.
Table R3b: Novel objects with a known-slot historical argmax in training memory (%).
+MGCA→Full reduces this confusion by 8.41/19.41/4.90 points, complementing Table 3.
Table R3c: Scan configurations, accuracy (%).
Geometry alone gains 1.04 All/8.41 New points over both off; Full gains another 2.67 All/1.32 New points. These configurations supplement the ablation. Main text/Appendix J (Tables 20–21) updated in purple.
◆ Q4: Does restricted K explain Table 2's low coverage? What changes with total K?
A4: We use K=K_old+K_new, fixing frozen features, diagnostic samples, natural-class-frequency weights and other weighted K-Means settings. Coverage: fraction of novel classes becoming the largest individual class in ≥1 novel-dominated cluster.
Table R4a: Novel coverage (%) by cluster budget.
Total K covers 17/20, 5/7 and 14/27 novel classes: coverage rises on MN/Shape and stays unchanged on Scan. Known-class weighted fractions within novel-dominated clusters are 15.64%/17.54%/15.13%, complementing coverage. This comparison shows the cluster-budget effect. Main text/Appendix K (Table 22) updated in purple.