- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 1(−1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes ARISE for generalized category discovery, combining geometry-regularized feature adaptation with candidate-specific residual correction. The method uses EMA-based relational regularization and gated square-root residual reweighting to improve fine-grained category discrimination. Experiments on six benchmarks show competitive performance, with the best overall accuracy among the compared methods on four fine-grained datasets.
Critical strengths
- Well-motivated residual correction. The anchor-based decomposition provides a concrete mechanism for underweighted directional evidence. The low-magnitude diagnostics (Fig. 5; Table 13) support the motivation beyond overall accuracy.
- Strong fine-grained benchmark results. ARISE achieves 76.4% on CUB-200, 70.1% on Stanford Cars, 49.6% on Herbarium19, and 63.1% on FGVC-Aircraft (All accuracy), leading the methods in the main comparison (Table 1). Ablations and three-seed results add useful validation.
Critical weaknesses
- Material reporting inconsistencies. The main text describes inference with corrected logits, but Appendix A.6 (including Eq. 37) specifies original logits. Tables 5 and 8 also disagree on apparently matching ablations (e.g., CUB No Sinkhorn: 71.4% vs. 69.8%), while numerical changes stated in Appendix B.3–B.4 do not match Tables 8–9. These conflicts obstruct reproducibility.
- Limited isolation of the main correction. Adding the residual component gives only +1.1/+1.3 All points on CUB/Stanford Cars (Table 2); inference-only correction gives +0.7/+0.1 points, with slight New-accuracy declines (Table 3). Comparisons with simple novel-logit calibration or alternative residual exponents are missing.
Questions for authors
Q1. Were Table 1 predictions made with original logits or corrected logits? Please provide the exact inference path and a same-checkpoint comparison.
Q2. Why do Tables 5 and 8 differ, and why do Appendix B.3–B.4 calculations disagree with Tables 8–9? Please provide reconciled settings/results.
Q3. Under matched settings, how does square-root lifting compare with simple logit calibration and other residual exponents? Does it improve low-magnitude top-1 accuracy?