- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes FAMB, a frequency-aware memory bank for training-free anomaly detection on unseen machines. A vibration encoder is pretrained on 38 data sources using DINO-style self-distillation and frozen for deployment. FAMB builds a memory bank from normal reference samples and performs nearest-neighbor retrieval with sensor and frequency constraints while allowing flexible temporal matching. Second-order frequency-shape residuals further enhance anomaly scores. Experiments on four unseen vibration datasets and 16 liquid rocket engines evaluate cross-source transfer, few-shot detection, and cross-device generalization. The results show improvements over the implemented baselines, particularly when normal references are limited.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses an interesting and practical problem: deploying anomaly detection models on unseen machines without target-specific training, particularly when only a few normal samples are available.
-
The experiments are extensive, covering four unseen vibration datasets and 16 liquid rocket engines. The evaluation includes few-shot settings, cross-device transfer, and ablation studies, providing useful evidence of the method's effectiveness.
Critical weaknesses
-
The baseline comparison is not sufficiently convincing. Most baselines are adapted from image anomaly detection methods, such as PaDiM [1], but the paper does not clearly explain how their image-specific components are adapted to vibration spectrograms. Meanwhile, relevant open-source signal anomaly detection methods, such as GenRep [2], are not considered, although differences in signal modality would need to be addressed.
-
The methodological novelty appears limited. BEAM [3] has already explored frequency-local memory matching and training-free anomaly detection. Although FAMB introduces sensor-aware retrieval and second-order frequency-shape enhancement, the paper does not sufficiently clarify its contributions beyond these existing ideas.
[1] Defard et al., PaDiM: a Patch Distribution Modeling Framework for Anomaly Detection and Localization. ICPR Workshops, 2021.
[2] Saengthong et al., Deep Generic Representations for Domain-Generalized Anomalous Sound Detection. ICASSP, 2025.
[3] Saengthong et al., Sub-Band Spectral Matching with Localized Score Aggregation for Robust Anomalous Sound Detection. arXiv, 2026.
Questions for authors
- Most detection baselines are originally designed for image anomaly detection. For example, PaDiM [1] relies on position-dependent Gaussian modeling of image features, which may not directly suit vibration spectrograms. I am concerned about how these image-specific components are adapted to signal anomaly detection, as the paper provides limited implementation details. Could the authors explain how each baseline is adapted, particularly its feature processing and anomaly scoring? Without appropriate adaptations, the comparison may not be fair, especially since FAMB is specifically designed for signal characteristics.
[1] Defard et al., PaDiM: a Patch Distribution Modeling Framework for Anomaly Detection and Localization. ICPR Workshops, 2021.
- Why are recent signal anomaly detection methods not included in the comparison? This field already has relevant open-source methods, such as GenRep [2] and PaAno [3]. Could the authors include these methods as additional baselines or explain why they cannot be fairly adapted to the evaluation datasets?
[2] Saengthong and Shinozaki, Deep Generic Representations for Domain-Generalized Anomalous Sound Detection. ICASSP, 2025.
[3] Park and Kang, PaAno: Patch-Based Representation Learning for Time-Series Anomaly Detection. ICLR, 2026.
- The main differences between FAMB and existing memory-based methods such as RAD appear to be frequency-constrained retrieval and second-order frequency-shape enhancement. Are these the main methodological contributions? Could the authors clarify what is fundamentally new beyond existing retrieval-based approaches? This is mainly a clarification request and does not affect my rating.
3 comments
Thank you for the detailed response, and I apologize for my delayed reply due to other commitments. I no longer have major concerns about the fairness of the comparisons. My main concern remains the limited methodological novelty (W2). After reading the other two reviewers' comments, I noticed that they share similar concerns about the incremental nature of the contributions, although their views on whether these contributions and performance improvements are sufficient for acceptance differ. From my perspective, I would prefer to maintain my original score.
Response to Reviewer FzFH
Thank you for clarifying that W2 is your remaining concern. We agree that BEAM established frequency-local matching. When a new engine has no healthy baseline of its own, the matching rule determines which observations from another engine can serve as healthy references. FAMB preserves sensor location and local frequency correspondence while allowing the time offset within a recording window to vary.
A brief vibration at a pump sensor can fall in a different time column simply because the recording window starts later. Averaging over time before retrieval, as in our BEAM-style comparison, can dilute a brief departure. FAMB retains individual patches for matching across time. It uses second differences across neighboring frequency bands to describe the local shape of the learned feature profile. A patch mismatch receives more weight when that shape differs from those observed in healthy recordings.
The one-factor comparisons in Table 3(b) use the same frozen encoder, reference-engine choices and test windows at the one-engine budget. With the shape term off, allowing matches at any time offset raises AUROC by 1.63 points. Removing the frequency constraint from full FAMB lowers AUROC by 0.83 points. With retrieval fixed, adding the shape term reduces the false-positive rate at 95% sensitivity from 9.56% to 6.47%.
We would welcome your reassessment of W2.
Response to Reviewer FzFH
Thank you for recognizing the practical value of deployment with limited normal references. We clarify the baseline adaptations and FAMB's contribution below.
1. Adapting detection heads to vibration.
All heads use the same frozen vibration backbone, per-channel log-Mel inputs, normal references, test sets and repetitions. The “-style” labels identify unified implementations. Trainable heads optimize on target normal references while the encoder stays frozen (Appendix B.4).
PaDiM therefore retains position-dependent modelling on spectrogram coordinates. FAMB instead preserves sensor and local-frequency correspondence while allowing time positions to vary with window boundaries. Table 3 directly tests these assumptions through controlled ablations.
2. Signal methods and the level of comparison.
GenRep uses generic pretrained representations and normal-reference retrieval for anomalous sound detection; PaAno learns patch representations with triplet and pretext objectives. Section 2 discusses both.
Our evaluation separates representation transfer from scoring with a shared frozen representation. Table E1 compares audio, time-series and vibration encoders under their documented interfaces. BEAM-style supplies the closest signal-domain head comparison: frequency-local memory matching using the same encoder and normal references as FAMB (Appendix B.4).
FAMB leads at all three reference budgets in Table 2:
At one window, the gains are 3.00 AUROC and 3.24 AUPR points, without added noise. Table C3 reports per-dataset means and SDs over 20 reference draws.
3. Contribution beyond BEAM and RAD.
The methodological contribution is the vibration-specific matching geometry and bounded second-order frequency-shape score (Section 3.2):
Table 3(b) isolates these effects with one reference engine. Freeing time matching raises AUROC from 92.58% to 94.21%; shape enhancement raises it to 96.49% and lowers FPR95 from 9.56% to 6.47%. Removing sensor conditioning or frequency anchoring reduces AUROC to 95.21% or 95.66%. These comparisons fix the backbone, reference choices and test windows, directly linking the gains to the matching and scoring design.